Stephen A. Smith’s latest college football take set off a fresh wave of backlash, this time over his comments on Utah’s place in the rankings.
Smith reacted to a top-five list from ESPN’s Chris Canty and zeroed in on the Utes at No. 2.
"What the Hell is this team doing at No. 2?"
Smith asked of Utah. "Your quality wins?
I’ve got BYU, Houston, that’s it. That’s all it is.
And Houston was suspect to begin with.... I’m not sold on Utah being the No. 2 team in the nation."
He didn’t stop there, adding that Alabama should be in the top five as well. But it was his dismissal of Utah that drew the loudest response, especially given what the Utes have done so far.
Utah is 9-0 and has outscored opponents by an average of 38-16. The schedule hasn’t featured a long list of elite teams, but the resume has still been enough to put the Utes at No. 2 in the current CFP seeding.
Social media wasted no time pushing back.
"The Utah hate is unreal considering they let Notre Dame pass with a weak schedule every year."
That reaction pointed to another part of Canty’s list: 8-1 Notre Dame at No. 3, while the Irish sit No. 5 in the CFP rankings despite a schedule that many online considered no more impressive than Utah’s.
"ESPN has ruined college football. Utah hasn’t lost bama and Texas lost twice. The man that can’t speak proper English is trying to sell 2 losses better than 0."
Smith’s praise for Alabama also drew scrutiny, with critics noting that the Tide’s two best opponents were both losses.
"Let’s compare Notre Dame and Utah’s common opponent..."
That common opponent was BYU, which beat Notre Dame and lost to Utah.
"Stephen A logic, being mad at Utah’s inclusion and Bama’s exclusion pic.twitter.com/4dQ4ZnbLY8"
Some viewers also saw a broader pattern behind the take.
"As soon as you realize ESPN has an agenda the sooner you realize why these stupid takes exist. This clown hasn’t watched Utah play once all year."
Another response took aim at Smith’s Houston comment directly.
"Suspect" Houston’s two losses: at current #2 Utah and at current #10 Texas Tech. Both by one score, both came down to the final possession.
But sure, Screamin’ A. Whatever you say.
For plenty of viewers, that was the problem in a nutshell: Smith’s narrative didn’t seem to line up with the facts people were pointing to, and they let him hear about it.
In Other News...
Notre Dame Just Lost A Huge 2031 Matchup At The Worst Time
A future trip to Gainesville had been on Notre Dames calendar for years, but that plan is gone now after Florida canceled the home-and-home series scheduled for 2031 and 2032. The move comes with the SECs shift to nine conference games, which gave the Gators a contractual out and reshaped a matchup that would have been one of the more attractive nonconference dates on the Irish schedule.
Notre Dame has already filled the opening by lining up Washington for a home-and-home series beginning in 2031, keeping the long-range slate moving even as the search for additional Autonomy 4 opponents continues. For a program that has to plan years ahead to maintain the kind of schedule it wants, the change is a reminder that even the biggest future games can disappear quickly when conference realignment and scheduling rules collide. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame May Have Found A Dangerous New Role For Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa
Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asas day against Miami looked like more than just a breakout moment in the box score. He turned in the first sack by a Notre Dame linebacker this season, but the bigger development may have been how the Irish deployed him in the middle of the defense, where he handled the sideline communication duties and stayed on the field for a career-high 70 snaps.
For Notre Dame, that kind of workload matters because it came in a game where the defense was dictating terms from start to finish. The Irish generated 32 total pressures on Miami quarterback Darian Mensah and kept him from finding much rhythm, with Viliamu-Asa emerging as part of the front-line answer in a role that could give this defense a different edge as the season moves on. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Defense Faces A Discipline Test In Crucial Boston College Spot
Notre Dames defense comes into the Boston College matchup riding the confidence of a strong showing against the No. 1 team, but the challenge now is less about proving it can rise to the moment and more about staying sharp against an offense that invites mistakes. Boubacar Traore and Christian Gray are among the key names in focus, with both expected to help the Irish attack the weak spots Boston College has shown on offense.
For Notre Dame, this is the kind of game where discipline matters as much as talent. The Irish are still in a position to keep their College Football Playoff hopes on track, and that means avoiding the lapses that can turn a manageable night into a frustrating one. Against Boston College, the defensive front and secondary will be tested in the details, and how well they handle those matchups could say plenty about where this group stands now. [Read more 🡒]