Tommy Carr may not have taken over Michigan’s quarterback job, but he did enough in a small window to keep the conversation alive.
Kyle Whittingham made it clear on Monday that Bryce Underwood is still the starter, saying, “Bryce is our guy, and we'll move forward.” But the coach’s comments also hinted that Tommy Carr’s role is worth watching, especially after the younger quarterback turned in more work last week than usual.
“[Offensive Coordinator] Jason [Beck] will call plays, and Bryce is our guy, and we'll move forward,” Whittingham said before shifting to Carr. “Tommy did get a lot of good reps last week, which he would typically get in a bye week anyway.
He'll get a good set of three or four on the way. So we've gotten a lot of work done, not because of anything.
It was a great opportunity to get the second-team guys' work across the field.”
Carr’s path is different from his brother’s. CJ Carr was never really in the running for the Notre Dame job in the way Tommy has been around Michigan this season. Tommy arrived in the spring knowing Underwood had already been installed as the starter, but the early-season struggles have led plenty of analysts to wonder whether that should have been a true competition.
Whittingham was asked directly about whether Carr might get live-game snaps, and he left the possibility open without making any promises.
“To be determined,” Whittingham said. He sure looks good in practice, like he has throughout all spring and fall camp. His small, tiny sample size that he had in the game is positive.”
“But right now, like I said, Bryce is our guy. If we think giving Tommy a series or two helps our chance to win, then we'll see that.”
So far, Carr’s only game action came in garbage time against UTEP, and he made the most of it. He completed both of his passes for 23 yards and a touchdown, and added two carries for 18 yards.
The family connection is part of the appeal, too. Tommy and CJ are both grandsons of former Michigan head coach Lloyd Carr. CJ landing at Notre Dame was already a surprise wrinkle in that lineage, and Tommy now looks like the one inching closer to carrying that legacy forward.
In Other News...
Notre Dame Defense Faces One Big Question Entering BYU Trip
Notre Dames defense could get a meaningful boost heading into its trip to BYU, with linebacker Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa no longer on the injury report and expected back in the mix. The Irish also have some movement in the front seven and secondary, as defensive tackle Jason Onye has been upgraded to questionable after sitting out more than five games with a left ankle injury, while cornerback Leonard Moore remains listed as questionable for the matchup.
Brauntae Johnson is still working his way back from foot surgery and is expected to return around November, leaving Notre Dame with a few moving parts as it prepares for one of the more demanding road environments on its schedule. For a defense that has already had to manage injuries at multiple levels, the key question now is how much of that depth can be restored in time for Saturday and how quickly the group can settle in once it gets there. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dames Talent Edge Faces A Real Test In Provo
Notre Dame heads into Provo for a meeting that carries a little extra weight because it has been so long since the Irish played there, with the last trip coming in 2004. On paper, the talent profile still leans toward Notre Dame, but the deeper look at both rosters is more interesting than the recruiting rankings alone. Some of the most effective players on each side were not the highest-rated prospects coming out of high school, and some of the bigger-name recruits are not even starting.
That is why the real test will come in the matchups that decide whether raw talent translates on the field. Notre Dames wide receivers will have to deal with BYUs defensive backs, while the lines on both sides figure to shape the game in the trenches. BYU also enters without two of its top offensive players because of injury, which only raises the pressure on the Irish to make their edge count in a difficult road setting. [Read more 🡒]
BYU Faces A Program Defining Stage Against Notre Dame
BYUs trip to Notre Dame carries the kind of weight that can change the way a program is viewed for a long time. The matchup is part of a busy college football weekend loaded with high-end games, but this one stands out because of what it means for the Cougars against a traditional power. Notre Dame brings the backdrop, the history and the expectation that comes with being the standard in games like this.
For BYU, the stage is less about the ranking and more about the opportunity to answer questions that only a game like this can settle. The broader slate around it, including Indiana-Ohio State, UCLA-Wisconsin and Alabama-Tennessee, gives the weekend plenty of marquee appeal, but few teams face as much to gain from the spotlight as BYU. A result here would resonate well beyond one Saturday and could shape how the rest of the season is judged. [Read more 🡒]