Notre Dame and SMU don’t cross paths often, and their recruiting profiles tell a pretty clear story when they do.
The Irish and Mustangs have met only 13 times, with the latest showdown coming in 1989 in South Bend. Notre Dame rolled to a 59-6 win that day, and the Irish have owned the series 10-3 overall.
Eight of those meetings came between 1949 and 1958. On the recruiting trail, the gap has been just as noticeable, but the deeper look shows both rosters are built on more than star ratings.
Start with Notre Dame’s offense against SMU’s defense, where some of the most productive players were never the kind of names that lit up recruiting boards. SMU linebacker Brandon Booker, ranked No. 908, and Alexander Kilgore, ranked No. 524, are two of the team’s three leading tacklers, yet both were unranked in high school. Defensive end Marques White is another example: he leads the Mustangs in sacks, tackles for loss and total pressures, but came out of high school unranked.
Notre Dame has its own version of that story. Jordan Faison leads the Irish in receiving, and he was unranked as a recruit while also being mostly known as a lacrosse prospect. At quarterback, CJ Carr came in as the No. 68 player and a four-star recruit, but his last two seasons haven’t matched that billing.
The most interesting individual battle on this side is Notre Dame’s wide receivers against SMU’s cornerbacks. Marcellus Barnes, ranked No. 305, and Jayvon Thomas, ranked No. 136, were both four-star recruits, just like Irish wideouts Jaden Greathouse, ranked No. 158, and Micah Gilbert, ranked No.
- The biggest paper mismatch tilts Notre Dame’s way with Greathouse against nickel corner Jarvis Lee, who is ranked No. 1150 and is the third-lowest ranked player on SMU’s defense.
SMU’s offense is where the Mustangs’ recruiting profile leans even more heavily on overlooked players. Only four former four-star recruits are in the starting lineup, and three of them are on the offensive line: left tackle Drew Evers, ranked No. 214; right guard Addison Nichols, ranked No. 166; and PJ Williams, ranked No.
- Williams was injured in the first half against Wake Forest, and if he can’t play against Notre Dame, Andrew Chamblee, ranked No. 336, would likely take his place.
The skill-position matchups are the ones to circle. SMU receiver Yamir Knight, ranked No. 2300, leads the team in receiving despite being a three-star recruit, while Yannick Smith, ranked No. 566, was also a three-star prospect. Knight’s matchup with Notre Dame nickel corner Christian Gray, ranked No. 112, looks lopsided on paper, but it should be one of the best individual battles of the night.
Tight end is another area to watch. Theo Melin Ohrstrom, ranked No. 296, and Randy Pittman, ranked No. 693, will line up against Notre Dame safeties Adon Shuler, ranked No.
295, Luke Talich, who was unranked, Joey O’Brien, ranked No. 35, and potentially Brauntae Johnson, ranked No. 220.
Notre Dame has had trouble covering tight ends before, so while the Irish have the recruiting edge there, that doesn’t guarantee much once the game starts.
The broader recruiting picture still favors Notre Dame. Over the last five classes, the Irish have finished No. 5 in 2026, No. 12 in 2025, No. 9 in 2024, No. 12 in 2023 and No. 7 in 2022.
SMU’s class rankings over that same stretch were No. 35, No.
32, No. 117, No. 72 and No.
- Advantage: Notre Dame.
In Other News...
Notre Dame Fans Are Facing A New Playoff Reality
Notre Dames latest College Football Playoff update brought a familiar kind of frustration for a team that had just handled Boston College convincingly. The Irish slipped to No. 6, falling behind Texas even as their own rsum got a boost from the win, and the timing makes the move sting a little more with only two weeks left in the regular season.
With unranked opponents still on the schedule, the path to a Top 4 seed and the first-round bye that comes with it has narrowed considerably. If Notre Dame stays at No. 6, the playoff picture shifts from chasing a break to preparing for a home game against No. 11 Wake Forest, a very different kind of finish than the one the Irish had been eyeing. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dames Final Home Game Carries More Playoff Weight Than Expected
Week 12 brings a strangely quiet national slate, with no AP Top 25 matchups on the schedule for the first time in November since 2009. Even so, there is still plenty at stake for teams hovering around the playoff picture, and Notre Dames final home game of the regular season fits right into that mix as the Irish host SMU in a matchup with postseason implications hanging over it.
It is the kind of weekend where the rankings may not deliver a marquee showdown, but the pressure is still real for teams trying to strengthen their case. Ohio States trip to Nebraska and Texas Techs meeting with Baylor also carry weight in the broader playoff race, but for Notre Dame, the focus stays on making sure this last home date does not become just another November game on the calendar. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Recruiting Buzz Around Elite DB Just Raised The Stakes
Notre Dames recruiting momentum on the defensive side picked up another notch this week with buzz around 2028 five-star cornerback Keaton Fields. Rivals analysts Steve Wiltfong and Brandon Huffman both projected the Irish as the frontrunner, a notable development for a prospect already drawing national attention as the No. 13 player in the class and Arizonas top-ranked recruit.
Fields already has more than 30 scholarship offers, which is the kind of early competition that usually turns a top prospect into a long, winding recruitment. For Notre Dame, being in the lead this early is a strong sign, but the bigger question is whether the Irish can keep that edge as the process stretches on and other programs keep pushing for one of the most coveted defensive backs in the country. [Read more 🡒]
