The Miami Hurricanes left South Bend with their first loss of the season, and they did it without Malachi Toney, their superstar wide receiver who is out for the rest of the regular season after surgery to repair his ankle injury. Mario Cristobal said after the game that the surgery went well.
Miami trailed early, fought back late and had a real shot at turning the night around before a controversial call on a potential touchdown helped seal the loss to rival Notre Dame. Even so, the game offered a clear look at where the Hurricanes stand without Toney - and where they still need work.
The offense looked stuck in the mud for much of the first half. Miami managed only three points after getting stuffed three times at the goal line, and it seemed for a while like losing Toney might flatten the attack.
But the second half told a different story. The Hurricanes finished with 24 points and 377 yards, both below their season averages, yet they moved the ball far better after halftime.
Cooper Barkate stepped into a bigger role and delivered. Miami’s No. 2 receiver led the team with 10 catches for 92 yards and two touchdowns.
Elija Lofton was even more eye-catching, finishing with 113 yards for his first career 100-yard game and coming close to the game-tying touchdown. Vandrevius Jacobs, making his second start of the season, also showed off his big-play ability.
“It was tough,” Barkate said. “Besides how good of a player he is, he’s a real leader on the team. So losing him was a hurt to the team, but it’s a next-man-up mentality, and he wanted us to go out there and play like he was out there.”
One area that took a beating was the offensive line. Darian Mensah spent too much of the night on the move, and Miami’s front had a rough time with Notre Dame’s pressure.
The Hurricanes allowed only two sacks, but Pro Football Focus credited them with 21 quarterback pressures allowed - the most in a game by any Cristobal-led Miami team. It’s also the most pressures Miami has surrendered since giving up 28 to Duke in 2019.
Left tackle Samson Okunlola was charged with seven pressures allowed, right tackle Matthew McCoy with six and right guard SJ Alofaituli with four. After what had been one of the unit’s better outings against UNC, this was a major step backward against what Miami saw as the toughest defensive front it will face in the regular season.
“They were creating pressure,” center Ryan Rodriguez said. “They were doing a lot of stuff that other people have done, and we’ve got to continue to work and continue to fix it.”
There were positives on the other side of the ball. After last week’s struggles against North Carolina, Miami’s defense showed more fight against Notre Dame.
The Hurricanes got stops on six of the Fighting Irish’s 11 completed drives. Once Notre Dame had scored touchdowns on three of its first six drives and added a field goal on another, Miami tightened up in the second half, forcing back-to-back three-and-outs and then getting a missed field goal to give the offense a chance.
It still wasn’t a clean night. Miami did not record a sack, and CJ Carr still threw for 319 yards and three touchdowns. But the defense was better than it had been a week earlier.
“I would say it just comes back to coming together,” defensive lineman Justin Scott said. “I feel like (in the) first half maybe different guys trying to make plays rather than just trusting in the defense and just doing what you got to do in your job.
And coming out in second half, we took it back to the fundamentals. Everybody got close together, and we just took it one play at a time.”
The run defense, though, remained a strength. Notre Dame came in averaging 186 rushing yards per game, and Miami held it to 93. Pro Football Focus gave the Hurricanes an 86.9 run defense grade, their best of the season.
That matters again next week, when Miami has to deal with Duke running back Nate Sheppard, who is second in the nation in rushing yards with 1,189 and fourth in touchdowns with 17.
The bigger picture for Miami still looks strong despite the loss. The Hurricanes will almost certainly drop from No. 1 in the College Football Playoff rankings, but their season is far from derailed.
If they win their final three games, they are guaranteed a spot in the ACC title game. Win the ACC, and the playoff berth follows.
Even if Miami drops one more game, it will still reach the conference championship game because every team besides Wake Forest has at least two conference losses.
“This one definitely stings. … We’ve got to use it,’ Mensah said. “Everything we want is still in front of us, and we’ve got to just stay positive and be ready to come to work on Monday.”
In Other News...
Colin Cowherd Just Gave Notre Dame Fans New CFP Ammo
Colin Cowherds latest take on the College Football Playoff rankings gave Notre Dame fans fresh talking points, and not just because he pushed back on the Irish sitting at No. 11. He took aim at the committees decision to place Indiana at No. 4, while Notre Dame remains on the outside looking in, and argued that the gap between the two teams is not as straightforward as the rankings suggest.
Cowherd also revisited Notre Dames loss to BYU, saying the ending should be viewed through the lens of controversial officiating and the Big 12s admitted errors. He pointed to Notre Dames statistical edge over Indiana and questioned how the committee is weighing signature wins, which leaves the Irish with another public argument for why their rsum deserves a closer look. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dames 2028 Class Just Added Another Intriguing Defender
Notre Dames 2028 recruiting class picked up another promising piece when linebacker Julian Bruno committed to the Fighting Irish, choosing South Bend over Stanford and other programs. Bruno adds to a quick run of momentum for the class, becoming the third player to pledge to Notre Dame in two days as the staff continues to build early around a group that already includes names like Zaiden Jernigan and Asa Burch.
Bruno brings the kind of profile Notre Dame tends to value on and off the field, with a reputation as a strong high school defender and a high academic prospect. For a program that has long sold both development and fit, landing a player with that combination only adds to the intrigue around what the 2028 class could become as more decisions start to stack up. [Read more 🡒]
College GameDays Notre Dame Split Will Fuel Miami Debate
ESPNs College GameDay turned South Bend into the center of the college football weekend ahead of Notre Dames matchup with Miami, and the shows pick segment only added to the buzz around the game. Desmond Howard, Nick Saban, Pat McAfee, Kirk Herbstreit and guest picker Jason Sudeikis all weighed in on a slate of Week 10 games, with the Irish drawing the bulk of the support in the marquee showdown.
Four of the five panelists backed Notre Dame to handle Miami, but Howard went the other way and sided with the Hurricanes. It is the kind of split that gives a prime-time matchup a little extra edge, especially with GameDay on site and the Irish getting the kind of national attention that comes with being the featured game of the day. [Read more 🡒]