Nick Saban isn’t sold on the idea that a bigger College Football Playoff will make life easier for coaches.
If anything, the former Alabama coach thinks the move to 24 teams could turn up the heat. Speaking Saturday on College GameDay from Provo, Utah, Saban said the expanded format may change how teams are judged in a way that leaves fewer coaches with room to breathe.
A larger field will “create an expectation that if you don’t get in the playoffs, they’re going to fire your ass,” Saban said while the show previewed No. 2 Notre Dame at No. 8 BYU.
His warning landed a day after the playoff reached a handshake agreement with ESPN on a 24-team format that would begin in 2027. The network would pay an average of $345 million more per year over five years for the expanded bracket, though the deal still needs final approval.
Saban’s argument is that expansion cuts both ways. Yes, more teams get in. But once a 24-team playoff becomes the standard, he said, the public bar rises too.
He said the new setup would “raise the expectations of the fans to get into the playoffs.”
He also pushed back on the idea that coaches should see the larger field as a safety net. While “lots of coaches think” the expanded playoff will help protect jobs, Saban said it actually removes the cushion that came with a respectable season but no postseason berth.
With 19 at-large spots added to the four Power Four champions and the top-ranked Group of Six champion, even an 8-4 team could hang a playoff banner next year. Missing out on that kind of field, Saban argued, would be a much tougher sell to athletic directors and boosters than missing a 12-team playoff.
That kind of pressure is already in the air this season. Florida State coach Mike Norvell is facing questions about his future ahead of Saturday night’s trip to No. 3 Miami.
Pat McAfee opened the discussion by asking Saban why the sport keeps moving from “two to four, four to 12, now 12 to 24.”
Saban’s answer pointed away from expansion and toward scheduling. He said better games don’t require a bigger postseason.
“You don’t need a 24-team playoff to have a nine-plus-one,” he said. “They did that in the SEC. They should have done it in all the conferences so we have better games and people play a more equal schedule.”
The SEC moved to nine conference games this season and requires each school to schedule an additional power-conference opponent or Notre Dame.
Saban also made clear that his biggest concern is the workload. He said his Alabama teams played 15 games “maybe three times, and I thought that was too many.” Under the 24-team setup, a team seeded ninth or lower and good enough to reach the title game would play 17 games total, with five postseason games added to the 12-game regular season.
He said Friday that he would prefer a 16-team format, with conference title games used as play-ins.
In that version, seeds 1 through 8 would get byes and then home games, while seeds 9 through 16 would host first-round games against seeds 17 through 24. Power Four conference championship games would go away, and the regular season would start a week earlier.
The quarterfinals and semifinals would remain in the New Year’s Six bowls, and the national championship game would still be played in January. If the agreement is finalized, this season’s 12-team bracket would be the last one of its kind.
In Other News...
Notre Dames New Starting Five Says Plenty About Shrewsberrys Reset
Micah Shrewsberrys projected starting five for the coming basketball season says a lot about where Notre Dame is headed after a busy offseason. Braeden Smith, Braeden Shrewsberry, Ethan Roberts, Brady Koehler and Logan Duncomb form the group the Irish are planning around now, a lineup that leans into a fresh identity as the roster continues to settle.
The bigger takeaway is what is no longer in the picture, with Marcus Burton moving on to Indiana and leaving a noticeable opening in the backcourt. Around campus, there are still other threads to follow, from Notre Dame hockeys recent loss to the expected return of football player Jason Onye, but for basketball the focus is squarely on how quickly this new starting group can come together. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Faces A Playoff-Proving Test In Hostile Territory
Two undefeated teams are heading into a primetime Week 7 meeting that should tell plenty about where Notre Dame stands in the playoff conversation. The Irish have leaned on a strong defense and an efficient offense to get here, and the setting only raises the stakes as they prepare to face a BYU team that has handled its own business with a physical approach and a balanced attack.
BYU has done it while absorbing injuries and still finding ways to stay perfect, which makes this matchup more than just a record-versus-record showcase. For Notre Dame, the road test is about matching that toughness and making enough plays in the passing game, because a game like this often turns on which defense bends less and which quarterback keeps the offense steady when the pressure rises. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Defense Awaits A Possible Boost Against BYU
Leonard Moore and Jason Onye both moved closer to returning at the right time for Notre Dame, with Marcus Freeman saying the defensive back and defensive lineman are on track to play against BYU after getting work in during the week. Moore missed the previous game because of a concussion, while Onye has been sidelined since the season opener with a left ankle injury, leaving the Irish short on two pieces of depth they would like back on the field.
Both players are still listed as questionable, but the signs this week were encouraging enough to put them in line for a possible boost on defense. If their recovery keeps trending the right way, Notre Dame could get a welcome lift for a matchup that will ask plenty of its front and secondary. [Read more 🡒]