Former Notre Dame walk-on fullback Tyler Plantz thought he was returning the favor when he took over as head coach at Providence Catholic High. The Providence Catholic graduate, class of 2010, had come back to the school that helped set him on the path to Notre Dame, and later to a stint on Brian Kelly’s staff with the Fighting Irish. Instead, his run at his alma mater ended abruptly, and with little clarity.
Providence Catholic fired Plantz on Saturday despite a 4-0 start and a spot atop the state’s Class 5A rankings. The Celtics were also ranked among the top five teams in Illinois’ Super 25.
Plantz had even taken the program to the Class 5A championship game last season, where Providence lost to St. Francis.
Across parts of five seasons, he went 35-19.
The school offered only a brief explanation for the move.
"Providence Catholic High School is announcing a transition in the leadership of its football program as we move in a new direction," the school’s athletic director, Doug Ternick, said. "The Celtics thank Coach Tyler Plantz for his time and service as head coach and for his commitment to our student-athletes and football program since 2022."
Plantz said Monday that the decision came out of nowhere. In a statement, he said the school has not been fully open about why he was removed and described a meeting that lasted less than an hour with the school’s president and pastoral director, Father John Merkelis.
“During our meeting for less than an hour, Father Merkelis informed me that other staff members had told him about a few disgruntled colleagues and a few football players’ parents. He cited problems with disorganization related to scheduling games for lower-level teams, which was not my responsibility. He also said he was not satisfied with how I managed college recruiting this year and structured lower-level practices,” Plantz wrote.
Plantz said Merkelis told him those were his “only concerns” and that he was then asked to resign. Plantz declined, and the school dismissed him.
For now, the reasons behind the firing remain unclear. The school’s statement gives no details, and Plantz’s account is the only explanation on the table. That leaves a striking question hanging over a coach who had the program winning and competing at a high level just days earlier.
In Other News...
Notre Dame Still Has One Offensive Concern Fans Can't Ignore
A 52-0 shutout over Rice gave Notre Dame plenty to feel good about, especially after safety Adon Shulder sparked the early tone with a defensive play that helped set up Boubacar Traores scoop-and-score. The Irish controlled the game in every obvious way, and the opener looked like the kind of clean, convincing win a top program wants to stack in September.
Still, the performance did not erase one lingering concern: the run game has not yet shown the kind of burst Notre Dame wants. The Irish have drawn criticism for a lack of explosiveness on the ground, and Marcus Freeman acknowledged after the win that more big plays are needed there. For a team with bigger goals ahead, getting the rushing attack moving from steady to dangerous remains one of the most important things to watch. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Is Trying To Separate In A Crowded Chase For 2028 Wing
The early chase for Kingsley Rogers is already starting to take shape, and Notre Dame is in the middle of it. The 6-foot-7 guard-wing from the 2028 PSA Cardinals has drawn interest from a long list of programs that also includes Utah, Hofstra, Rutgers, Baylor, Marquette, Auburn, Syracuse and Buffalo, but the Irish have been especially active in staying connected with him as the evaluation process begins to build.
Rogers has pointed to frequent contact from Notre Dame and Utah, while assistant coaches from Hofstra and Utah have also been in steady pursuit. Notre Dame is set to attend an open gym session at Rogers' school, another sign that the Irish want to keep separating themselves in a crowded field before this recruitment gets even more competitive. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dames Recruiting Edge Faces A Michigan State Test Fans Will Feel
Notre Dames recruiting momentum has become one of the clearest signs of where Marcus Freeman has taken the program, with a highly ranked class helping the Irish stack talent and deepen the roster ahead of the 2026 matchup with Michigan State. The comparison with the Spartans is part rankings, part development, and it sets up a familiar kind of test for Notre Dame: proving that the edge it has built on paper can hold up when the game is actually played.
Michigan State arrives under first-year coach Pat Fitzgerald with a different kind of argument, one built less on recruiting buzz than on getting production out of unranked prospects who have turned into starters. The contrast gives this rivalry a little extra bite for fans on both sides, because the matchup is not just about the historical connection between the programs but also about whether Notre Dames talent advantage can withstand a team that has found value in unexpected places. [Read more 🡒]