As the first College Football Playoff rankings spark the usual November debate, Colin Cowherd made it clear where he stands: Notre Dame being slotted at No. 11 is, in his view, flat-out wrong.
On “The Herd with Colin Cowherd” Wednesday, the Fox Sports host took aim at the early CFP list, with Indiana sitting at No. 4 and the Fighting Irish at No. 11. Cowherd said the rankings are “how ridiculous” to start out, and he argued that Notre Dame’s place makes even less sense when you look at the matchup coming this weekend.
He pointed out that the Irish are a heavy favorite against unbeaten No. 1 Miami on Saturday, then posed a question he clearly thought answered itself.
“Ask yourself this question: In the history of college football, has the No. 11 team (Notre Dame) ever been a touchdown favorite over an unbeaten No. 1 team? The answer is I doubt it,” Cowherd added.
Cowherd also pushed back on the committee’s explanation that Notre Dame hasn’t earned a higher spot because it lacks a signature win. In his view, Indiana doesn’t have one either. The Hoosiers are 6-2, and Cowherd noted their narrow wins over Minnesota, Michigan and Nebraska.
He said BYU should have counted as one of Notre Dame’s defining victories, but the Irish’s road loss to the Cougars has been treated differently because of the ending.
“Notre Dame has blown out everyone on their schedule, except BYU,” Cowherd said. “Notre Dame goes on the road and loses.
It’s not just that they lost...this has to be considered. On the final play, the Big 12 admitted that it was pass inference and that Notre Dame should get another play.
The Big 12 also admitted that when the ball hit the ground, there was a second left. They butchered two calls in the final five seconds.”
Cowherd wrapped up by saying Notre Dame stacks up better than Indiana in several key areas, citing the Irish’s “better point differential, better total offense and defense...basically better everything” than the Hoosiers.
In Other News...
College GameDays Notre Dame Split Will Fuel Miami Debate
ESPNs College GameDay made South Bend the center of the college football world Saturday morning, setting the stage for Notre Dames matchup with Miami and giving the Irish another national spotlight before kickoff. The usual cast of Desmond Howard, Nick Saban, Pat McAfee and Kirk Herbstreit was joined by guest picker Jason Sudeikis, and the shows weekly picks segment quickly turned the game into a referendum on how the panel sees these two teams.
Four of the five panelists leaned toward Notre Dame, but Howard went the other way and backed Miami, a split that should only add to the conversation around a game already loaded with attention. For Notre Dame, the broader takeaway is clear enough: the Irish have the kind of stage where every national voice gets amplified, and even a single dissenting pick can sharpen the debate before the first snap. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Just Got Pulled Into Notre Dames Weirdest GameDay Moment
College GameDays Kicking Is Easy segment brought an extra jolt to Notre Dames Saturday atmosphere, and it centered on pre-med junior Michael Milano. The setup was simple enough on paper: a 33-yard field goal attempt, a big crowd, and the kind of national-stage pressure that can make even a routine kick feel enormous.
Milano missed his first try, then got a second crack with tackling dummies set up as blockers, including one with Michael Irvins face on it. He made the kick the second time, turning a quirky in-game stunt into a million-dollar finish and adding one more strange, memorable chapter to a GameDay scene Notre Dame fans will be talking about for a while. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Fans Got A GameDay Moment They Wont Forget
College GameDay brought a little extra theater to South Bend, and Notre Dame fans got a front-row seat to one of the shows most memorable side acts. Pat McAfees Kicking is Easy contest put student Michael Milano in the spotlight, and after an initial miss, he came back on his second try and drilled the $1 million kick even as the challenge got tougher.
The scene had plenty of Irish flavor beyond Milanos finish. Joe Montana was on set to back the Notre Dame student, while Riley, the leprechaun mascot, added to the day with a $500,000 charity kick of his own. It was the kind of GameDay moment that mixed pressure, pageantry and a little bit of luck, exactly the sort of thing Notre Dame fans will be talking about long after the cameras moved on. [Read more 🡒]