North Carolina’s push for another season of eligibility has now expanded beyond football and into field hockey, with kicker Rece Verhoff and former Tar Heels Ryleigh Heck, Dani Mendez and Sietske Brüning all joining an amended complaint in Monroe Circuit Court in Indiana.
The filing asks the court to grant each of them a fifth season for this school year, and it folds the four UNC athletes into Daley v. NCAA, the broader challenge built around the NCAA’s new “five-for-five” age-based eligibility model, adopted June 23, 2026. UNC men’s basketball center Cameron Fens is not part of the complaint.
For North Carolina, the field hockey names are the ones with the most immediate impact. Heck, Mendez and Brüning would be major additions for Erin Matson’s team, which is off to a 3-3 start and ranked No.
- What happens if they are ruled eligible is still unclear.
Heck and Brüning helped deliver national championships in 2022 and 2023. Heck was named national player of the year in 2023 after building a career total of 65 goals.
Last season, she put up 19 goals and 13 assists, while Mendez matched that kind of production with 15 goals and 16 assists. They were the only ACC players to finish with double-digit totals in both categories last season.
Brüning added six assists last season and was named second-team All-American.
The eligibility issue centers on a specific group the new rule leaves out: members of the high school Class of 2022 who went straight from high school to college and played four straight seasons without redshirting. All four UNC athletes in the complaint fit that category.
Verhoff’s path is different only in the details. He played at Marshall in the 2022, 2023 and 2024 seasons before transferring to North Carolina for 2025.
The complaint says Verhoff “competed with and against numerous fifth-year players in his career,” language that also appears throughout the larger case. If the injunction is granted, the filing says, he will attend North Carolina for the 2026-27 school year.
Mendez’s filing uses the same framework. She played at Virginia during the 2022, 2023 and 2024 seasons before transferring to Chapel Hill for the 2025 season, and the complaint says she also “competed with and against numerous fifth-year players in her career.”
Heck and Brüning, meanwhile, stayed at North Carolina for all four of their college seasons from 2022 through 2026. All three field hockey players could take part if the injunction is granted.
Verhoff’s case has already been through one round of courtroom whiplash this offseason. He was declared eligible in early August after U.S.
District Judge Charlotte Sweeney’s ruling in Wisne v. NCAA out of Colorado granted a fifth season to Class of 2022 athletes nationwide.
North Carolina brought him back onto the roster, and he returned to practice within a day. That lasted 16 days.
On Aug. 21, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals granted the NCAA’s request for a stay, and Verhoff’s status flipped back to uncertain just over a week before North Carolina’s opener against TCU in Dublin.
On the field, Verhoff’s absence has already forced a change. Last season he set the program field goal record with a 57-yard kick against Wake Forest, making 19 of 23 field goal attempts and all 20 extra-point tries. Without him, junior LSU transfer Aeron Burrell has handled all placekicking duties, along with kickoffs and punting - a rare one-man setup.
The case is being heard in Monroe County because of Indiana’s connection to Stephen Daley, the Indiana Hoosiers defensive end whose season-ending knee injury cut short his 2025 year and made him one of the lead plaintiffs. Judge Kara Krothe has overseen the litigation and spent more than five hours on Monday hearing testimony on the request for a preliminary injunction without issuing a ruling. Both sides must now submit proposed findings and conclusions of law by Thursday.
For the moment, nothing has changed for the Tar Heels involved. Mendez and Heck have already used up their eligibility, while Verhoff remains off UNC’s roster. Their next chance to change that rests with Krothe’s decision in the coming weeks.
In Other News...
Bill Belichick Just Turned Clemson's Next Game Into A Bigger Stage
Bill Belichicks arrival in Chapel Hill has already added a different level of attention to North Carolina football, and Clemson coach Dabo Swinney helped underline that this week. During a recent media session, Swinney spoke openly about the respect he has for Belichick, calling it an honor to coach against him and praising the veteran coachs consistent approach and professionalism even with all the criticism that has followed him over the years.
For the Tar Heels, it means the upcoming Clemson game carries more than the usual ACC weight. Swinney made clear he wants to beat Belichicks team, which is exactly the kind of backdrop that gives this matchup extra juice. North Carolina is getting the benefit of a national spotlight, and Belichicks presence alone has turned a conference game into something that feels a little bigger than the calendar would normally suggest. [Read more 🡒]
Bill Belichick's Viral UNC Interview Just Added To A Growing Problem
Bill Belichicks arrival at North Carolina brought instant attention and a whole different level of scrutiny to Chapel Hill, but the on-field results have been uneven enough already. He came in on a five-year contract and managed only a 4-8 debut season, and while the Tar Heels have opened the next year with two wins, including a recent victory over East Tennessee State, the program has not exactly settled into quiet routine.
The bigger concern now is everything happening around the team. North Carolina is dealing with an ongoing internal human resources investigation, and the ripple effects have already been felt in the staff structure with general manager Michael Lombardi resigning and defensive coordinator Steve Belichick on medical leave. For a program trying to build momentum under a high-profile coach, the off-field churn has become its own storyline, and it is one that still does not look close to being resolved. [Read more 🡒]
UNC Suddenly Has A Center Problem Michael Malone Must Solve
Michael Malone spent the offseason trying to patch the Tar Heels biggest roster holes, and the frontcourt was a major part of that work. North Carolina brought in Sayon Keita and Alexandros Samodurov up front, while Terrence Brown, Matt Able and Neoklis Avdalas were added to give the backcourt a different look after last seasons shortcomings.
The problem now is the middle, where South Dakota transfer Cameron Fens was supposed to provide another option at center but is currently ineligible after his fifth year of eligibility was denied. With Fens unavailable, Keita and Samodurov are the two names left to battle for the starting job, turning what looked like a deeper position into one of the early questions Malone still has to sort out. [Read more 🡒]