The idea of a 24-team College Football Playoff has been floating around for a while now, and it keeps coming back for the same reason: the sport’s biggest decision-makers keep looking for ways to make the postseason bigger. The field already jumped from four teams to 12 a few years ago, and in recent months, talk has picked up again about pushing it all the way to 24.
That chatter got another boost over the past couple of days. Part of it has come from the first edition of an expanded FIFA Men’s World Cup, with some people openly asking what lessons college football might take from that event. More directly, ACC commissioner Jim Phillips said again at the conference’s Kickoff event this week that he supports expansion.
For plenty of fans, the reaction to a 24-team field is immediate and pretty simple: no thanks. The skepticism is rooted in the belief that this is about money, not about improving the sport. That criticism is hard to dismiss.
Still, there is a version of a 24-team playoff that makes sense. If every conference champion got in - whether that meant the ACC, SEC or MAC - the format would actually open a real path for every FBS team to play for a national title. A team like 11-2 Western Michigan, for example, would probably run into a 10-3 power conference opponent and lose right away, but the broader structure would at least give every league a legitimate route into the bracket.
It would also help keep the at-large spots from going to overly ordinary power conference teams. In that setup, the last at-large team last season would have been No.
18 Michigan, with one less conference in the mix than there is now since the Pac-12 has a full set of teams again. Below that line, there really wouldn’t be much of a case for a national title run, and the appeal of seeing a team like Western Michigan get a shot is a lot stronger than watching an 8-4 Iowa type of team fill out the field.
There’s also the matter of how the games are played. The best version of this playoff would feature on-campus games all the way through, or at least until the semifinals. Three rounds that feel basically like bowl games hasn’t done much for me, I have to day.
But that’s not the version that’s likely coming. If the playoff grows to 24, it will probably be built around the 24 highest-ranked teams, which means solid but not truly title-worthy power conference teams getting a payout for a loss.
A good number of the games would likely still be held at neutral-site bowl venues, too, which would take some of the edge out of the atmosphere. At least the SEC and Big 10 would get to cash a bunch more checks.
In Other News...
ACC Vs Big Ten Debate Will Hit Tar Heels Fans Hard
A fresh round of conference chest-thumping has put the ACC and Big Ten back in the same conversation, and for North Carolina fans it is the kind of debate that always comes with a little extra weight. Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi leaned on his own experience to make the case, pointing to the leagues early success against both the Big Ten and SEC during the opening stretch of his time in Pittsburgh.
The harder part for ACC supporters is figuring out how much of that still holds up now. The leagues record in those matchups was much stronger in the first couple of years of Narduzzis tenure, but the broader picture over the nine seasons that followed has been less flattering, which leaves his argument looking more like a snapshot of a moment than a settled verdict on where the ACC stands today. [Read more 🡒]
UNC May Have Found The Defensive Star Belichick Desperately Needs
After a 4-8 season in Bill Belichicks second year, North Carolina has spent the offseason trying to give the program a cleaner offensive footing, from bringing in Bobby Petrino as coordinator to adding transfers. But the bigger question in Chapel Hill may be on the other side of the ball, where the Tar Heels need someone who can help steady a defense that never quite found its edge.
Kaleb Cost is one of the names worth watching there. The redshirt junior has already been productive over the past two seasons, and his background as a former baseball player only adds to the intrigue around how far he can still climb as a football piece. He has mostly worked in the nickel role under both Belichick and Mack Brown, but there is a sense his responsibilities could grow if UNC is going to find the defensive playmaker it has been missing. [Read more 🡒]
UNC Just Made The Cut For A Recruiting Battle Fans Know Matters
North Carolina has landed in the middle of another important recruiting race, this one for four-star forward Sienna Williams, who has trimmed her list to six schools. The 6-foot-3 prospect from Colorado is ranked No. 64 in the Class of 2027, and Courtney Bangharts staff has stayed active in her recruitment as the Tar Heels try to position themselves as a strong fit for both Williams and the programs culture.
What makes this one worth watching is the company UNC now keeps in the chase, with the Tar Heels standing as the lone ACC program still in the mix. For a staff that has made recruiting identity and long-term roster building a priority, getting to this stage matters, even if the next step will come down to how Williams sorts through a finalist group that already tells you how competitive this battle has become. [Read more 🡒]