Cam Schlittler’s season has already given the Yankees a frontline arm, a Cy Young case and plenty of noise. Now it has a new label, too.
Ryan Weathers, a fellow Yankees pitcher, joked in the comments on Schlittler’s recent post by calling him a “professional ragebaiter.” It was a clean little line, but it landed because of everything swirling around Schlittler right now: the Boston feud, the deleted post, the screenshots, the chatter that never seems to die down.
That whole mess started after a Red Sox-centric Section 10 podcast episode in which co-host Rusey took a shot at Schlittler while talking about his New England background, calling him ugly and saying she hated him. The jab came after Schlittler had shut out Boston.
Schlittler answered with a post that was quickly deleted but widely screenshotted, firing back with the now-traveling “solid 4’s with oversized sunglasses” line. Rusey had been wearing oversized sunglasses while hosting.
Schlittler then added another layer on Wednesday by posting a glasses emoji on X, a move many read as another swipe in the same ongoing back-and-forth. His original post was otherwise routine, showing him in his Yankees uniform. Weathers supplied the punchline, and Schlittler’s account liked the comment, which made the whole exchange feel less like tension and more like teammates having fun with the chaos.
The irony is that Schlittler has never hidden from the rivalry or the reaction that comes with it. When asked about the steady stream of hostility from Red Sox fans, he admitted the fire started on his end after last year’s playoffs.
“It’s never stopped,” Schlittler said. “Whether it’s comments on my posts or my messages or Twitter or whatever it is, or messaging people in my family, it’s always been there.
It hasn’t stopped at all. I don’t expect it to stop.”
He went even further on his own role in the whole thing.
“I feel like I probably created that issue,” Schlittler said. “I could have easily just thrown last year and not said anything, but it didn’t feel right to not say anything.”
That makes Weathers’ nickname hit a little harder, because Schlittler basically described the same behavior without using the word. He knows the reaction he gets.
He knows he helps feed it. And he keeps leaning in anyway.
Weathers is not just some random teammate tossing out a joke from the cheap seats, either. The Yankees acquired him from the Miami Marlins in January, and he had a 3.60 ERA with 143 strikeouts across 25 starts before a forearm flexor strain sent him to the injured list in late August.
He’s also the son of former Yankees pitcher David Weathers, part of one of the few father-son pairs to wear the uniform. This was clubhouse humor from someone with his own place in the room.
The timing only sharpened the spotlight on Schlittler, because the numbers he’s putting up are no joke. He blanked the Angels for eight innings on Tuesday, allowing one run and two hits while striking out nine and walking none. That was his 19th start giving up one run or fewer, a Yankees single-season record that pushed him past Ron Guidry, Whitey Ford and Jack Chesbro.
The outing against Boston that lit the fuse came days earlier, when he threw 5⅔ scoreless innings with eight strikeouts in a 1-0 win. Through 29 starts, the 25-year-old has a 2.04 ERA and 210 strikeouts in 171⅔ innings. On the road, he’s been even nastier, carrying a 1.14 ERA across 16 starts away from Yankee Stadium.
That’s the backdrop for the nickname now sticking to him online. Schlittler is in the middle of an AL Cy Young race with Toronto’s Dylan Cease, with Schlittler holding the edge in ERA and innings while Cease leads in strikeouts. He’s also become one of the Yankees’ defining stories in a tight division fight.
And now, thanks to a deleted post, a viral screenshot and a teammate who couldn’t resist the joke, he has another unofficial title attached to the run.
In Other News...
Yankees May Be Facing A Giancarlo Stanton Reality Nobody Wanted
Giancarlo Stantons latest calf issue has added another layer of uncertainty to a season already interrupted by multiple injuries, and for the Yankees it has become more than just a health update. The power hitter had already dealt with a re-strain in June before suffering a new injury to the other calf, leaving his 2026 availability in serious doubt and forcing the club to confront how fragile his role has become at this stage of his tenure in New York.
Around the team, the bigger question is no longer just whether Stanton can get back on the field this season, but whether this is the point where the Yankees have to start planning for life without him. Some insiders and media voices are already wondering if his time in pinstripes is nearing its end, and if that proves to be the case, the lineup would need a different shape going forward. For a club built to contend, the possibility of losing one of its most feared bats creates both urgency and an offseason decision that could ripple through the rest of the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Ex Caught In Roster Squeeze As Pirates Prospect Returns
Konnor Griffin is back on the Pirates active side of the ledger after missing time with a finger injury, and Pittsburgh cleared the way by designating veteran catcher Christian Bethancourt for assignment. Griffin had been sidelined since June 5, but he was producing before the injury, hitting .276 with five home runs, so the move puts a familiar prospect back into the organizations mix at a time when every roster spot matters.
Bethancourts exit is a reminder of how quickly the margins can shift for a player acquired in a minor league deal, especially one with a short runway to make an impression. The former Yankee was brought over from New York but never got into a regular-season game for Pittsburgh, leaving the club to make a choice that tells you where its priorities are right now, even if the full roster fallout is still to come. [Read more 🡒]
Former Yankees Minor Leaguer Just Took A Public Shot At Their Approach
Nick Torres, who recently went back to the Mexican League after a brief stop with the Yankees Double-A affiliate, put the organizations hitting development under a public spotlight this week. On social media, Torres contrasted the approach he saw in New Yorks system with the one he associates with the Mexican League, framing it as a difference between a focus on analytics and individual metrics on one side and a more traditional emphasis on winning and manufacturing runs on the other.
The critique lands in a system that has generally produced results on the field, at least in the minors. Yankees farm clubs have been among the better offensive groups in baseball, leading their affiliates in runs scored, home runs and RBIs, which makes Torres comments as much a challenge to philosophy as to production. Even so, his remarks add another layer to the ongoing conversation around how the Yankees develop hitters and whether their process looks different from the box score. [Read more 🡒]