ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. - The Yankees can live with Ryan McMahon’s bat coming and going. What they can’t afford against the Rays is sloppy defense at third base.
That’s where the tension sits as New York gets ready for the AL Division Series opener Saturday at 6:30 p.m. ET at Tropicana Field.
Tampa Bay doesn’t rely on one swing to flip a game. It chips away, bunts, runs, and makes infielders hurry.
That kind of pressure can turn a routine inning into a mess in a hurry, and the Yankees saw a taste of it already when Taylor Walls dropped down a run-scoring bunt single in a 6-1 Rays win at Yankee Stadium in September.
The Rays led the majors with 45 sacrifice bunts, according to MLB’s official team statistics, and they spent the regular season forcing defenders to charge, throw on the run and make plays from awkward angles. That style helped them win seven of 13 meetings with the Yankees and finish 98-64 while taking the AL East. New York, meanwhile, comes into the series after overwhelming Boston in the two-game Wild Card sweep, but Tampa Bay presents a very different test.
Gerrit Cole will start Game 1 for the Yankees against Drew Rasmussen, and the matchup immediately puts the spotlight on the left side of the infield. That’s where McMahon’s recent work has created a real question for Aaron Boone.
McMahon was brought in during 2025 for exactly this kind of role: steady glove, premium defense, and a history of making life easier on the rest of the infield. He entered with four straight Gold Glove finalist nods through 2024, and in his final full season with Colorado, MLB credited him with seven Outs Above Average while Sports Info Solutions gave him 10 Defensive Runs Saved. That version of McMahon fits a series like this one.
But the Yankees haven’t consistently gotten that version lately.
On 10 regular-season bunts directed toward McMahon, he turned seven into outs. The problem is how the misses clustered.
Three of the failures came in his final four chances, and one of those was more on the pitcher than on McMahon himself. The most damaging one came Sept. 20 in Arizona, when Geraldo Perdomo bunted toward the left side with the Yankees leading 3-2 in the sixth.
McMahon got to the ball near the mound but couldn’t finish the transfer, and Arizona ended up loading the bases, tying the game on a sacrifice fly and winning 5-3.
Two days later, Walls punished him again. His seventh-inning bunt single scored Chandler Simpson and helped spark a four-run frame in Tampa Bay’s 6-1 victory.
The broader defensive numbers only sharpen the concern. Baseball Savant had McMahon at zero Outs Above Average at third base in 2026, and his September Fielding Run Value checked in at minus-2 for the month. That’s a sharp drop from the kind of defensive profile that made him such a natural fit for this roster.
His offense hasn’t given Boone much room to ignore the glove, either. McMahon finished the regular season at .213/.279/.357 with 11 homers and 41 RBIs over 124 games, and Statcast showed a .200/.259/.300 line in September with one homer. He did have a big night against Tampa Bay on Sept. 23, driving in five runs with a grand slam in a 9-2 Yankees win, and he went 1-for-4 with an RBI and a walk in the Wild Card Series sweep of Boston.
Boone has already shown he’s willing to move pieces around. Before the postseason, he said Anthony Volpe could get time at third and mentioned Jose Caballero as another possibility.
“Trying to be as flexible as possible,” Boone said Sept. 23. “There’s a lot of different [roster] iterations and ways we could go in the Wild Card Series.”
He followed through on that flexibility. Amed Rosario started at third against left-hander Payton Tolle in Wild Card Game 1, with McMahon entering later. McMahon then returned to the lineup against right-hander Sonny Gray in Game 2.
Rasmussen is a right-hander, which normally would favor McMahon’s left-handed bat. But Tampa Bay’s brand of offense makes that simple logic a little harder to trust. The Rays are built to squeeze extra value out of bunts, ground balls and speed, and that means the Yankees need clean outs more than anything else.
McMahon doesn’t have to carry the lineup. He has to make the routine play, cut off the small-ball damage, and keep innings from unraveling before the middle of the order even gets a chance.
If Boone decides to go in a different direction, it doesn’t have to mean McMahon is off the roster. It could mean a shorter leash, a late defensive replacement, or using Volpe, Caballero or Rosario at third.
The Yankees will set their ALDS roster before Game 1. And against a Rays team that lives on pressure, the decision at third base looms a lot larger than McMahon’s spot in the batting order.
In Other News...
Joe Girardi Just Reopened The Yankees' Ugliest Clubhouse Debate
Joe Girardis latest comments cut straight back into a Yankees conversation that never really goes away after a bad October. In the wake of the ALDS sweep by the Rays, the former manager focused on accountability, questioning whether enough internal leadership was present in the clubhouse and pointing to the kind of clean, avoidable mistakes that tend to define a postseason exit, from errors to baserunning lapses.
Girardi also framed the issue in a broader way, saying other teams seem to have players who better understand their roles, while praising the organizations handling of Anthony Volpes demotion. For a club that keeps talking about standards and urgency, his remarks reopened the old debate about where that responsibility starts, who enforces it, and why it so often feels like a problem that surfaces only after the season has already slipped away. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees May Have Found Two Quiet Fixes For A Familiar Problem
The Yankees season ended in the ALDS with the same kind of roster questions that have shadowed them even through a strong regular season, especially around balance and depth. As the front office looks ahead, the focus is not necessarily on splashy fixes so much as smaller, complementary moves that could smooth out two problem spots without changing the shape of the roster.
Carson Kelly has emerged as one possible answer behind the plate, where his profile fits as a platoon option with value against left-handed pitching and steady defense. Tyrone Taylor is another name in the mix for the outfield, bringing versatility and coverage without needing the kind of everyday role that can crowd an already packed lineup. For a team trying to avoid repeating familiar shortcomings, those quieter additions may be the most practical place to start. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees May Have A Luis Garcia Jr. Decision Fans Wont Like
The Yankees are already staring at an offseason full of roster math, and Luis Garcia Jr. has become one of the names tied to it. With the club looking to shore up the bullpen and sort through a crowded mix that also includes Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton and Ben Rice, the possibility of moving Garcia has surfaced as a practical, if unpopular, way to create some flexibility. Joel Shermans comments only added fuel to the idea that Garcia could be viewed as a trade chip rather than a fixed part of the long-term plan.
Luis Garcia Jr. fits the kind of discussion that usually follows a team with more needs than clean answers. The Yankees may prefer to use a move like this to address a relief corps issue or ease a positional squeeze, but the broader question is whether dealing a useful young piece is the cost of doing business. For now, it remains only a possibility, though it is the sort of rumor that tends to linger when a front office has to make room somewhere and strengthen somewhere else. [Read more 🡒]