The Yankees’ offseason infield puzzle has a name attached to it now, and it comes with some real thunder in the bat.
Ryan McMahon was supposed to steady third base when New York dealt for him, but the postseason showed the problem the Yankees can’t brush aside. He wasn’t locked into the job when the games mattered most, and after a season that ended with the Tampa Bay Rays sweeping New York in the American League Division Series, the front office has to sort out what comes next. The Rays took the decisive Game 3, 4-3, at Yankee Stadium on Oct. 7, and that loss pushed the focus straight to Brian Cashman’s next move.
McMahon is under contract through 2027, and his glove still makes him a usable answer at third. The issue is what he gave the Yankees with the bat. New York needs more offense, but it can’t afford to give up defensive stability for the sake of it, especially with other infield spots still in flux.
That’s where Teruaki Sato enters the conversation.
The Hanshin Tigers third baseman just put together a monster season in Japan, winning the 2026 Central League Triple Crown by hitting .306 with 39 home runs and 106 RBIs. He also posted a .991 OPS and scored 100 runs. He’s the first Hanshin player to win the Triple Crown and the ninth player in league history to do it.
And it wasn’t a one-year spike. Sato followed his 2025 Central League MVP season, when he hit 40 homers and drove in 102 runs, with another huge year in 2026. Over six NPB seasons, he’s piled up 163 homers and 518 RBIs.
MLB Network insider Jon Heyman has named the Yankees, Mets, Phillies and Dodgers as possible landing spots if Hanshin posts Sato. That’s just a list of clubs that could fit - not a sign New York has made an offer or even entered talks.
Sato has mostly played third base in Japan, but he’s not limited to that spot. He’s also logged time at first base and in right field, including an outfield role for Japan at the 2026 World Baseball Classic. That versatility matters for any MLB team trying to map out a roster.
SNY analyst Dani Wexelman offered a scouting look after seeing Sato in Japan, and she leaned into the parts of his game that jump off the screen.
“First of all, he can play multiple positions. He has a ton of power,” Wexelman said.
She also pointed out that the power isn’t just a pull-side trick.
“He has, as you can see, very easy power, opposite field power,” Wexelman said.
The catch, of course, is that nothing happens unless Hanshin posts him, and then any interested club has to get a deal done in the negotiating window. The talk right now is about possibility, not paperwork.
The comparison with McMahon shows why this is even on the Yankees’ radar. McMahon finished the 2026 regular season with a .213 average, 11 home runs, 41 RBIs and a .635 OPS in 328 at-bats. He’s still owed money on a six-year, $70 million deal that runs through 2027.
Sato’s numbers are obviously louder. His 39 homers are 28 more than McMahon hit in MLB this season, and his 106 RBIs are 65 more.
But there’s real risk baked into the projection. Sato struck out 164 times in 614 plate appearances in 2026, a 26.7% strikeout rate, while drawing 68 walks for an 11.1% walk rate.
That profile screams impact power, but it also leaves evaluators with a swing-and-miss concern to sort through.
Munetaka Murakami’s first MLB season offers the cautionary note. Now with the Chicago White Sox, he hit 35 home runs but batted .207 in 2026. Success in NPB does not automatically carry over.
For now, the Yankees are stuck in the middle: McMahon is still on the roster, and Sato is still with Hanshin. Cashman has to decide whether to stay with the veteran defender, chase a trade or take a swing on an international bat that could change the shape of the infield.
The Mets are in the mix as another New York possibility, which only adds another layer if Sato does reach the market. But as of Oct. 11, there’s no verified bidding war, no Yankees offer and no posting yet.
It starts in Japan. Then it becomes a Yankees decision.
In Other News...
Yankees Face A Costly David Bednar Decision With Mets Watching
After a season in which David Bednar stabilized the late innings for the Yankees, the club is suddenly staring at a familiar offseason question: how far is it willing to go to keep its closer in pinstripes? Bednar is a free agent, and the Yankees have to weigh whether to extend a qualifying offer while also sorting out the bigger picture of bullpen construction and the rest of their winter plans.
The interest around him does not stop in the Bronx, either, which only raises the stakes for a decision that could ripple beyond one roster spot. The Mets have been mentioned as a possible suitor, but for now that remains just speculation, with no reported contact or offer, leaving the Yankees to decide whether they want to bet on continuity before the market has its say. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Offseason Blueprint Signals A Roster Reset Fans Saw Coming
The Yankees postseason exit has already turned the conversation toward 2027, and the early read on the roster is pretty clear: there is work to do, especially in the bullpen. The relief group is a priority because the front office will have to sort through uncertainty around David Bednar and Paul Blackburn, both of whom are headed for free agency, while also considering outside help if the market offers the right fit.
Second base and catcher are part of the same larger reset, with the club weighing its internal options alongside possible additions. Anthony Volpe remains in the mix, Ryan Jeffers is among the names being floated behind the plate, and the broader picture suggests a roster that may look meaningfully different by the time the next run begins. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees October Exit Exposes A Bigger Problem Than One Bad Series
October ended the Yankees season with another familiar frustration, as they fell to the Rays in the division series and went quiet at the worst possible time. The offense never really found a rhythm in the matchup, managing just 12 hits while striking out 31 times, and the loss only sharpened the sense that this was about more than one bad week in October.
Aaron Judge was not available for the postseason after being limited by rib and calf injuries during the year, leaving a lineup that was already under pressure without one of its biggest bats. In the aftermath, Michael Kay pointed to the need for organizational change, while Judge made clear the standard in New York has to be higher than regular-season success, a reminder that the conversation around this team now extends well beyond the final out. [Read more 🡒]