The Yankees have spent the final stretch of the season juggling more than just wins and losses, and Trent Grisham has become one of the trickiest pieces on the board.
New York’s 8-4 loss to the Arizona Diamondbacks on Sunday in Phoenix came with its own flurry of offense - a 4-1 lead, three third-inning home runs and a loud 448-foot blast from Spencer Jones, who had just returned from a sore left heel. Heliot Ramos and George Lombard Jr. also went deep. But the bigger story for the Yankees is what all of this means for the roster as October approaches.
The club is 89-66, six games behind Tampa Bay in the AL East with seven games left, and already locked into a postseason spot. That means the last week is less about simply stacking wins and more about protecting the 26-man group they’ll need for a Wild Card Series.
Aaron Judge is already on the 10-day injured list with a right calf strain, and Jazz Chisholm Jr. could be back from a sprained right thumb as early as Tuesday. Add in Jones, add in Ramos, and the lineup math gets complicated fast.
That’s where Grisham’s situation turns awkward.
The Yankees made a $22.025 million bet on him for 2026 after he accepted a qualifying offer following a career year. In 2025, Grisham put up 34 homers, 74 RBIs and an .812 OPS, enough to make that one-year commitment look reasonable even at a hefty price.
This year has gone in the other direction. He’s sitting on 18 homers, a .211 average and a .703 OPS in 121 games, with two right hamstring strains interrupting the season.
The first came in June and sent him to the injured list on June 13. He returned July 3, then hurt the same hamstring again in a different spot on Sept.
- He’s been out since Sept. 5, and that absence may have quietly changed his place on the roster.
The gap between last year and this year is hard to miss. Grisham’s OPS has fallen by 109 points, and his home-run total has dropped from 34 to 18. He’s also set to hit free agency after the season, which leaves open the possibility that Sept. 4 was his final regular-season game in pinstripes even if he does return for the playoffs.
That would make for a strange finish to a pricey contract year: a player coming off a three-plus-week absence and potentially heading straight into postseason action while a younger outfielder has taken over his spot.
Spencer Jones has shifted the center-field picture. He has handled much of the work there and has put together a strong September, hitting .279/.343/.475 with three homers through Sunday, good for an .818 OPS.
That’s 115 points better than Grisham’s season OPS. Jones still swings and misses plenty, and the Yankees can still play matchups, but his emergence gives Aaron Boone real options.
Grisham no longer appears to have a locked-in starting job waiting for him. He could still start against a right-hander, serve as a left-handed pinch-hitter or become a late-game defensive piece rather than walking right back into everyday center field. And with Ramos able to play right and Jones able to move between center and right, Boone has more ways to mix and match than he did a few weeks ago.
The roster wrinkle is the part that makes this more than a simple injury return. The Yankees are unlikely to activate Grisham before the regular season ends, even if he’s physically ready.
Bringing him back would mean clearing a spot, and under MLB rules, an optioned position player generally has to stay in the minors for 10 days before being recalled unless an exception applies. That kind of late move could leave the Yankees without a useful player for the Wild Card Series and maybe beyond.
Boone put it plainly before Sunday’s game: “I know he’s trending to be close, but the activation might be a little complicated,” Boone said.
He also said Grisham has made real progress. “He’s been doing quite a bit.
He’s pretty deep into his running progression, hitting and doing baseball activities. So he’s getting pretty close,” Boone said.
That leaves the Yankees weighing whether it’s better to wait. Holding Grisham on the injured list through the final week would avoid an unnecessary regular-season roster move and preserve flexibility for October. Then they could reset to a 26-man postseason roster and decide whether his left-handed bat, defense and experience are worth carrying after the layoff.
For now, Grisham is still running, still hitting and still getting closer. New York heads home Tuesday for a four-game series against Tampa Bay, but his next big-league plate appearance may not come until the games matter most.
In Other News...
Yankees Camilo Doval Trade Just Took Another Ugly Turn
Camilo Dovals journey since leaving the Yankees has turned into the kind of bullpen story teams hope to avoid. New York dealt him last year in search of relief help, and the Pirates followed by taking a look of their own before quickly moving on. Dovals stint in Pittsburgh was marked by shaky command and uneven results, as he posted a 3.79 ERA and 1.737 WHIP over 19 innings.
Pittsburghs decision to cut ties came as it cleared room to activate Kirby Yates, a move that only adds to the odd look of the trade tree. The Yankees, meanwhile, were left with catching prospect Omar Alfonzo, but the latest twist gives the deal an even rougher sheen for everyone involved in it. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Judge Concern Hangs Over Crucial Yankees Doubleheader
The Yankees head into a crucial doubleheader against the Rays still trying to make up ground in the AL East, and the timing could hardly be more unforgiving. They trail Tampa Bay by six games with seven to play, which leaves little margin for anything less than a strong day, and the focus remains squarely on whether Aaron Judge can return from the injured list after a right calf strain.
Judges absence has become the looming subplot around a series that already carries obvious postseason weight, especially with the playoff picture tightening by the hour. The day also comes with the usual added details that matter this late in September, including game times, pitching matchups, broadcast plans and betting lines for both ends of the doubleheader, but the bigger question for the Yankees is whether their captain can get back in time to help at all. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Ruined A Rays Moment Fans Would Have Hated
Cody Bellingers two-run homer in the fourth inning was all the Yankees needed in the opener of a day-night doubleheader, and Carlos Rodn made sure the lead never felt in danger. The left-hander worked eight scoreless innings, limiting Tampa Bay to three singles while picking up his 100th career win and becoming the latest Yankee to join the 1,500-strikeout club.
Nick Martinez gave the Rays a chance by going six innings and allowing just two runs on five hits, but New York still controlled the tone of the afternoon. For a Tampa Bay club that was looking to build any kind of momentum in a short set, the Yankees turned the first game into a clean, compact statement and left the day-night split with plenty still hanging on the second half. [Read more 🡒]