The Yankees still haven’t picked Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s replacement at second base, but Brian Cashman’s latest comments made one thing clear: this is not a one-man search.
Cashman did not lock the club into an outside move during the general managers meetings Tuesday, and he left the door open for an answer from within the organization. That matters now that New York declined to extend Chisholm a $23.15 million qualifying offer, sending the former All-Star into free agency and forcing the Yankees to sort through their next move.
“I think we have people that, you know, internally certainly want to take their run at that. Those are multiple players, and then we will see what’s external at the same time,” Cashman said.
He added that the Yankees are not yet at the point of handing out positions for 2027.
“But we do have internal options, you know, that I’d say that we’re comfortable with. But at the same time, it’s my job to explore any outside opportunities that may exist as well,” Cashman said.
That leaves several names in the mix, including Anthony Volpe, José Caballero and Luis García Jr. Cashman also told García’s agent that the Yankees view him as a first baseman and second baseman, not a third baseman. García spent most of his time at first after being traded from Washington in 2026, and second base is another path to regular at-bats.
But the most interesting internal case may be Roderick Arias.
Arias, 22, started 2026 in High-A and finished it with a stronger profile than he had at the start of the year. The Yankees promoted him to Double-A Somerset on Aug. 4 after his run with Hudson Valley, and he ended the season batting .267 with 16 home runs, 84 RBIs, 38 stolen bases and a .784 OPS in 128 minor league games.
His value isn’t just tied to the bat. Arias played second base, third base and shortstop, giving the Yankees a more versatile infield option than they had before.
The defensive numbers at second base stand out: two errors in 29 games, a .977 fielding percentage and 237 2/3 innings. At third base, he had 18 errors in 74 games and an .893 fielding percentage.
Those numbers don’t make him a finished product, but they do give the Yankees a real reason to look at him as more than a shortstop prospect. He also bats from both sides of the plate, which only adds to the appeal if the Yankees want more flexibility.
Volpe remains the more immediate option. He made 19 starts at second base in Triple-A in 2026 and later played the position in the majors after Chisholm injured his thumb. In September, the Yankees said Volpe had one error in 162 1/3 minor league innings at second, good for a .987 fielding percentage at that point.
Arias, though, has not played above Double-A, so any talk of him opening 2027 as part of a second-base solution is still more projection than plan. He also struck out 164 times in 547 plate appearances in 2026, a swing-and-miss issue that keeps him from looking like an immediate fix.
The Yankees’ decision at second base also ties into the rest of the roster, including García, Ben Rice and the remaining infield mix. Cashman’s stance suggests the front office wants to keep its options open before making a financial commitment.
Chisholm’s 2026 line - .231 with 19 home runs, 55 RBIs and 41 stolen bases in 137 games - is not easy to replace. The Yankees can still look outside, with Brandon Lowe and Luis Arraez among the veteran possibilities if they decide the internal route isn’t enough.
For now, though, Cashman has not named Arias, Volpe or García the everyday second baseman. Arias is still a Double-A prospect, but his 2026 season gave the Yankees a new in-house name to watch.
In Other News...
Yankees Get Another Shot At A Catcher They Could Really Need
The Yankees may get another crack at a catcher they already tried to pry loose at the trade deadline. Colorado is now said to be more open to moving All-Star backstop Hunter Goodman this offseason than it was during the summer, a shift tied in part to the looming expiration of the collective bargaining agreement and the possibility of a lockout. Goodmans bat is the obvious draw after a 41-homer season in 2026, and he remains under team control through 2029.
For New York, the fit is easy to see. Catcher has been a spot worth monitoring, and Goodman would bring a rare middle-of-the-order threat behind the plate if the Yankees can line up the right package. The Rockies still appear focused on pitching in any talks, which means the price would not be modest, but the fact that Colorado is even more willing to listen gives the Yankees a fresh opening after coming up short at the deadline. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Fans Will Love What Cashman Said About Hideki Matsui
Last month, Brian Cashman got a Zoom message from a familiar face with big news. Hideki Matsui wanted to tell the Yankees general manager himself that he was taking over as manager of the Yomiuri Giants, a move that marked the latest step in a baseball life that has already taken him from Japanese stardom to the Bronx and back again.
Matsui, the former Yankees slugger and 2009 World Series MVP, was officially named to the post on October 23, and Cashman made it clear he was proud to see him reach that point. For Yankees fans, it is another reminder of how much Matsui still means to the organization, and why his success continues to resonate well beyond his playing days. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Rumors Are Zeroing In On Two Urgent Needs
The general manager meetings in Las Vegas wrapped up with the sense that this offseason could move quickly, and the Yankees already appear to be circling a couple of areas that need attention. One of the more concrete links has been to free agent catcher Carson Kelly, while the broader rumor mill has also tied New York to pitcher Tarik Skubal and third baseman Alec Bohm as the front office weighs ways to reshape the roster.
For a team that expects to stay in the thick of the race, the urgency is obvious. Catching help and infield stability remain obvious pressure points, and the Yankees are being mentioned in conversations that could address both, even if none of it has been confirmed by official sources. With the market now shifting from meetings to real negotiations, New York looks like a club worth watching closely as the winter gets moving. [Read more 🡒]