Sunday night’s Yankees loss in Boston put Ben Rice back under the microscope, and not just because of the final score. The play that opened the bottom of the 10th - Anthony Seigler’s ground ball sneaking through the hole for an RBI single - turned into the kind of defensive moment that can linger, especially when it fits a larger pattern.
Rice has now played 46 games at first base and served as the DH in his other 31 games played. Paul Goldschmidt has handled a heavy share of the work, with 41 games at first and 11 at DH, even though the early assumption was that Rice’s hand contusion from May explained the split. But that no longer seems to be the full answer, because with June nearly over, Rice has still spent less than half of the month at first base.
That leaves the Yankees with a real question: is Rice not getting enough reps at first, or is his defense the reason those reps keep getting pulled back? The Sunday night play only sharpened that debate. On the overhead view, there didn’t appear to be any reason for that ball to get past him, yet it did - and it was hardly an isolated case.
Rice has repeatedly been out of position on ground balls, whether he’s fielding them or missing them entirely, and those mistakes have helped extend innings and create miscommunication. That makes the Yankees’ first-base setup look less like a settled plan and more like a moving target.
Goldschmidt was supposed to be more of a backup first baseman and DH, but injuries changed the mix and pushed him into a bigger role. The question now is whether the Yankees should lean even more heavily on him at DH, especially with age and durability in the background, while also making sure Rice gets the development he needs at first base. He’s supposed to be the player of the future there, after all.
Instead, Rice keeps going two or three days at a time without defensive work, which does not sound like a great long-term formula. It’s also another issue for Aaron Boone, who predictably went with the hot veteran once Goldschmidt started producing.
And just to make the picture messier, Rice was also the worst hitter in all of MLB over the past week. That may not last, but when the offense dips and the defense wobbles, the concerns stack up fast.
The Yankees are at the point where Rice needs to be on the field as much as possible. They can’t afford to wear Goldschmidt down, and they also can’t keep treating first base like a spot to manage cautiously if Rice is supposed to be the answer there. Whatever the shortcomings are, the only way through them is more playing time, not less.
In Other News...
Aaron Boone Made One Choice Yankees Fans Wont Stop Arguing About
The Yankees have spent most of this week trying to patch together an offense that has vanished at the worst possible time, and the latest loss only added to the frustration. After the 11-inning defeat to the Tigers, the clubs losing streak reached seven games, with the lineup still operating under the strain of an overnight illness that left Aaron Boone with fewer options than usual and a group that has struggled to put together anything resembling a sustained rally.
The bigger concern is how thin the margin for error has become. New York has managed only 23 hits over its last six games, the fewest in any six-game span in franchise history, and every decision now gets magnified when the bats are this quiet. Boones in-game maneuvering is already under the microscope, and after the Yankees had a chance to grab the game in the 10th before things unraveled in the 11th, it is clear the debate around his choices is not going away anytime soon. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Made A Bullpen Move Fans Will Absolutely Hate
The Yankees latest stumble only added to the frustration around a bullpen that has been asked to carry a heavy load during this losing stretch. After an 11-inning loss to the Tigers completed a three-game sweep and extended the slide to seven straight, the club again found itself trying to patch together relief innings while the margin for error kept shrinking.
Then came the move fans were expecting to hate: rookie right-hander Yovanny Cruz was optioned to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, a decision that landed badly because of how effective he has looked in recent relief work. In a bullpen already feeling the strain, the timing made the reaction even sharper, and the backlash around the decision quickly became part of the story. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Fans Wont Like Boones Latest Call During This Brutal Skid
The Yankees seven-game slide has put every in-game choice under a microscope, and Aaron Boones latest decision only added to the frustration. In the middle of an extra-inning chance to finally stop the bleeding, the Yankees had their best opening to end the skid after Jos Caballeros bunt moved Spencer Jones to third, setting up a tense spot where the margin for error was tiny.
Instead of leaning into a different look at the plate, Boone stayed with Oswaldo Cabrera and later framed the call as one rooted in confidence that Cabrera could put the ball in play. It was the kind of explanation that is bound to draw second-guessing when a team is stuck in its worst slump since 2023, especially with injuries and a sputtering offense making every missed opportunity feel even bigger. [Read more 🡒]