CHICAGO - The Yankees entered the final stretch before Monday’s trade deadline with a bullpen question that looked simple a month ago and feels a lot murkier now.
Do they actually need to go get a lot of relief help?
Tuesday night’s 3-2 win over the Chicago White Sox at Rate Field offered a strong case for why the answer might be no, or at least not as urgently as it once seemed. Gerrit Cole set the tone with six scoreless innings and seven strikeouts, and then three relievers who have been trending up lately handled the rest.
Angel Chivilli worked a perfect seventh. Brent Headrick tossed a scoreless eighth. David Bednar closed it out for his 22nd save, even after allowing a two-run homer with two outs - his first earned runs since May 18.
“It’s incredible,” shortstop Anthony Volpe said of the bullpen’s recent performance. “I think just everyone’s stepping up.”
That view isn’t just coming from the clubhouse. Two Yankees decision-makers, speaking anonymously to The Athletic for candor, pointed to the same thing: the bullpen has changed shape fast. Chivilli and Headrick have emerged as real late-game options, and Paul Blackburn’s move from the rotation to the bullpen has added another arm to the mix.
There’s also a larger wave that could be coming. Those same decision-makers said Clarke Schmidt, who is recovering from Tommy John surgery, and Luis Gil, who is dealing with shoulder inflammation, might be bullpen options by September.
They also noted that Ryan Weathers or Will Warren could slide into relief once Carlos Rodón returns from elbow inflammation. Aaron Boone didn’t rule out Carlos Lagrange, who recently started playing catch after a shoulder sprain, pitching again this season.
Bednar’s recent run has only strengthened the case that this group is holding together better than it looked earlier in the year. Tuesday was a blip, not the trend line.
The Yankees still aren’t immune to the need for upgrades. Camilo Doval has been pushed almost entirely into low-leverage work, and the team is expected to try to trade him.
Tim Hill, once a dependable left-handed option for the Yankees, has been battered by righties this season, who have a 1.024 OPS in 67 plate appearances against him. Jake Bird, who posted a 5.93 ERA in 36 games, was demoted July 19.
And the Yankees have reportedly been scouting the San Diego Padres, a club that could make elite closer Mason Miller available. Any team would want him if it could get him.
Still, the bigger picture has shifted. What began the season as a bullpen with plenty of uncertainty has turned into one of the Yankees’ strengths. Since July 1, Yankees relievers have combined for a 2.06 Win Probability Added, third best in the majors according to FanGraphs, and a 2.65 ERA over that span, also third best in baseball.
Chivilli was especially sharp Tuesday, needing just eight pitches to finish his inning. Since his July 5 recall, he hasn’t allowed an earned run in 10 appearances. He’s been throwing his fastball at an average of 97.9 mph, and entering Tuesday he had strong whiff rates on both his changeup (35.6 percent) and slider (37.1 percent).
“Getting more and more adjusted to a new organization and some new things that we’ve had for him from a usage (standpoint) and everything,” Boone said. “I think he’s leaned into that.
You’re seeing a very effective pitcher right now. He’s earned some really significant opportunities.
He was, once again, really efficient (Tuesday). So, you need guys to step up in roles that you don’t necessarily account for early in the season or in spring training or whatever.
He certainly, over the last month, has done that.”
Headrick was just as economical, getting through his inning with five pitches and working around a single. His path has been similar to Blackburn’s: a starter-to-reliever conversion that started last year and has paid off this season. Headrick now owns a 1.33 ERA, and his 54 appearances are tied for the second most in baseball.
Bednar, meanwhile, has been one of the bullpen’s anchors. He owns a 2.74 ERA in 43 appearances, and Tuesday marked his fifth outing in seven days. Boone brushed off the workload, noting that Bednar threw only five pitches Monday and didn’t pitch Sunday.
“He’s been awesome,” Boone said. “Again, you talk about command - he’s had that.
Feels like he’s been pretty much ahead of everyone. I feel like all three pitches - his fastball-(splitter combination) has been in a really good place now for a couple of months.
Mixing in the curveball strategically 0-2 and just really aggressive and on the attack, but the stuff has been crisp.”
The bullpen may be trending the right way, but the Yankees’ bigger immediate need might be elsewhere. With Cody Bellinger out at least the next month because of a left hamstring strain, and return dates still unclear for Aaron Judge, who has a right first rib stress fracture, and Giancarlo Stanton, who is dealing with a right calf strain, the offense looks like the area that needs the most help.
In Other News...
Yankees May Finally Have A Real Answer To Their Catching Problem
The Yankees search for catching help may be getting a little more concrete, with the market around Miami beginning to take shape. MLB.coms Mark Feinsand reported that the Marlins could be willing to move a catcher because of a logjam behind Joe Mack, and that has put a handful of clubs, including New York, into the conversation as teams look for a cleaner answer behind the plate.
For the Yankees, the appeal is obvious: they need stability at a spot that has been a recurring question, and any deal would likely have to balance immediate help with the cost of giving up young talent. Hicks contract situation only adds to the intrigue, since he would bring years of team control, but the real question now is whether New York is willing to part with the kind of prospects Miami would want back. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Made A Catcher Move That Could Cost Someone Soon
The Yankees had a brief feel-good moment behind the plate when backup catcher Ali Snchez finally picked up his first major league home run, but the roster picture around him still looks unsettled. With catching depth a clear area of focus, the club has already started lining up alternatives as it weighs whether to keep rolling with what it has or make a more meaningful move.
One of those options is veteran Christian Bethancourt, whom the Yankees signed to a minor-league deal as insurance while they sort through the market. The team is also being linked to a handful of possible catching targets, and that kind of interest usually means somebody on the current roster is living on borrowed time, even after a moment worth celebrating. [Read more 🡒]
A-Rods Latest Relationship Twist Has Yankees Fans Doing A Double Take
Alex Rodriguez has been making more than baseball headlines lately, and the latest one has plenty of Yankees fans doing a double take. On his 51st birthday, his relationship with Meghan Hayden became public in a way that fit the modern celebrity playbook, with Hayden sharing the moment on Instagram and Rodriguez now being seen with her in public as the two spend time together in New York circles.
Hayden brings her own athletic background to the story as a former Division I player and New York-based fitness coach with a degree in exercise physiology, which only adds to the intrigue around the pairing. The summer setting has also fueled the conversation, with reports tying the couple to a Hamptons rental, but for now the broader picture is still the one getting attention: Rodriguez, long one of the most watched figures in baseball, has a new off-field storyline unfolding in full view. [Read more 🡒]