The Yankees find themselves in an intriguing position battle for the fourth outfield spot, with Jasson Dominguez and Spencer Jones vying for the role. While the coaching staff leans toward starting both players in Triple-A to get regular playing time, the Yankees need someone reliable who can step in as needed throughout the season.
Jones’ Swing Transformation: A Nod to Judge
Spencer Jones has been busy in the offseason, revamping his swing by eliminating a leg lift to establish a more stable base. This adjustment mirrors Aaron Judge’s approach, focusing on a quiet lower half and balanced weight distribution.
By simplifying his mechanics, Jones aims to improve his contact rate, relying on his natural power rather than extra momentum. This change could be pivotal, given his raw strength and potential.
Numbers Paint a Picture
Jones’ 2025 minor league stats were impressive, with a 153 wRC+ and 35 home runs, showcasing his five-tool potential. His .274 batting average and .362 on-base percentage reflect significant progress from 2024.
On the other hand, Dominguez’s MLB numbers tell a different story. His .257/.331/.388 slash line indicates solid on-base skills but lacks the power expected from a corner outfielder. With only 10 home runs in 381 at-bats, his power production is a concern.
Defensive Dynamics
Defensively, Jones offers more versatility, capable of handling center field and the corners, paired with good baserunning skills. His 29 stolen bases in 2025 highlight his threat on the bases.
Dominguez, while a strong baserunner with elite arm strength and sprint speed, struggles with defensive positioning. His limitations in the field make him a less reliable option for a role that demands versatility.
Platoon Potential and Triple-A Path
Dominguez’s left-handed bat struggles against right-handed pitching, making him more of a platoon player. Conversely, Jones’ adjustments could help him become a full-time option, especially if he improves against lefties. His strikeout rate remains a concern, but his improved plate discipline is promising.
The Yankees are wise to start both players in Triple-A, where Jones can test his new swing in game situations and Dominguez can work on his power and defense. Both have considerable upside, but patience will be key.
The Edge
If the Yankees had to decide today, Jones would likely have the edge. His defensive skills, baserunning prowess, and outstanding minor league performance make him a safer bet. The swing changes could address his strikeout issues, aligning him more with Judge’s philosophy of power through stability.
Dominguez has immense potential, but his defensive struggles and platoon limitations pose risks. His speed and arm strength add value, but they don’t fully compensate for his current shortcomings at the plate.
Ultimately, the Yankees will monitor both players closely in Triple-A and promote the one who proves ready. As spring training approaches, Jones seems to be in the driver’s seat, thanks to his recent adjustments and impressive 2025 performance.