TAMPA - As the Yankees gear up for Opening Day, the roster decisions they've made tell a compelling story. It’s less about spring stats and more about contractual nuances, Rule 5 requirements, and opt-out clauses.
Take Jasson Dominguez, who dazzled with a .325 average and a .978 OPS this spring, yet finds himself optioned. Kervin Castro, with a stellar 0.96 ERA, and Max Schuemann, who led the team in walks while hitting .321, were also sent down.
Meanwhile, Randal Grichuk, despite a .105 average, and Rule 5 pick Cade Winquest, with a 4.91 ERA, made the cut. It’s clear that roster logistics have taken the front seat.
Grichuk’s Opt-Out Clause
Grichuk's minor league deal came with an opt-out that forced the Yankees' hand. His agent made it clear: guarantee a spot or he walks.
The Yankees, valuing his .819 OPS against lefties and consistent power, decided to keep him. Despite Schuemann’s strong spring, his career .212 average didn’t help his case.
Manager Aaron Boone expressed confidence in Grichuk: “He looks what we hoped. He’s in a good spot and can help us.”
The Yankees’ bench for the opener against the Giants includes catcher J.C. Escarra, first baseman Paul Goldschmidt, utility man Amed Rosario, and Grichuk.
Winquest and the Bullpen Dynamics
The bullpen decisions mirror this logic. As a Rule 5 pick, Winquest must stay on the roster or be offered back to the Cardinals, giving him an edge over others.
Castro’s options allowed the Yankees to send him down despite his impressive spring. Jake Bird’s option status could also work against him.
Brent Headrick and Winquest are the front-runners for the final bullpen spots.
Boone emphasized the fluidity of these decisions: “The first decision isn’t always the last. Things can change quickly.”
Rotation Uncertainties
Luis Gil’s recent performance added intrigue to the rotation. After early struggles, his latest start was electric, hitting 98.8 mph and striking out seven over five innings. Boone was impressed: “That was 2024 Luis Gil right there.”
With off days early in the season, the Yankees won’t need a fifth starter until April 11. Max Fried will start the opener, followed by Cam Schlittler and Will Warren.
Gil is slated as the fourth starter, leaving Ryan Weathers’ role uncertain. Despite his high ERA, Boone sees potential in Weathers, possibly starting him in the bullpen.
There’s also talk of Carlos Lagrange’s potential as a reliever, given his 103 mph fastball, though it’s considered unlikely for now.
Cole’s Anticipated Return
Gerrit Cole’s brief spring appearance showed promise, with his fastball averaging 97.1 mph. He’s on the injured list but could return sooner than expected. Cole’s focus is on enjoying the game: “I just wanted to enjoy all of it, so that was my goal.”
The Big Picture
With 32 players left, the Yankees need to trim to 26 by Wednesday. Injuries to Cole, Carlos Rodon, and likely Oswaldo Cabrera will open some spots. Jorbit Vivas, out of options, is expected to be designated for assignment.
Boone summed it up: “You try and make the best decisions for the club. It doesn’t mean you always make the right decision, but it’s a disciplined process.”
The roster is set, shaped by forces beyond just performance. Now, it’s time for the Yankees to make it work.