The Yankees’ offseason to-do list starts at third base, and Ryan McMahon’s future is tied directly to what happens there.
New York is open to moving McMahon if it can bring in another infielder, according to a league source who spoke to FanSided. That makes the search for help on the dirt the key domino before any trade talks around McMahon can really take off.
McMahon’s first season in the Bronx was rough from start to finish. In 124 games in 2026, he hit .213/.279/.357 with a .635 OPS, 76 OPS+, 11 home runs, 41 RBI and a 0.0 bWAR. Even more striking, he finished with 0 Outs Above Average at third base, the spot where his glove is supposed to carry the most value.
The Yankees know they need more production there after getting swept by the AL East rival Tampa Bay Rays in three games in the ALDS this past October. With a 17-year World Series title drought still hanging over the franchise, the front office is looking for upgrades, not just a reshuffle.
There’s also the financial side of the equation. McMahon is owed $16 million in 2027, the final year of his contract, and New York understands it may have to pay down part of that salary or absorb another undesirable deal to move him.
The free-agent market doesn’t offer many clean answers unless the Yankees go big for Japanese slugger Teruaki Sato to handle third base. On the trade front, Isaac Paredes is one name that could surface, though the Yankees haven’t completed a major trade with the Houston Astros since Brian McCann in 2016. Jon Heyman of The New York Post also reported that the Yankees have discussed shortstop Corey Seager with the Texas Rangers, but Seager still has five years and $165 million left on his contract, along with a full no-trade clause, so whether he would even approve a move to New York is unknown.
That leaves the Yankees in a spot where creativity may be the only path forward. If they land another infielder, McMahon looks like the odd man out. If they don’t, they could bring him back for another year and hope for a rebound, though that would do little to satisfy a frustrated fan base or improve a roster that just got knocked around in October.
Aaron Boone is staying on as manager for at least one more season, which only raises the pressure on the Yankees to get this right. The organization needs to give him a roster that can win now, because another year like the last one could put Boone in a very different conversation after the 2027 season.
In Other News...
Cashman Just Reopened A Yankees Outfield Debate Fans Wont Ignore
Brian Cashman added a little fuel to an already familiar Yankees conversation when he said Spencer Jones can handle center field, even if the organization sees him fitting better in a corner. It is the kind of comment that gets noticed in New York because it touches both the present roster picture and the long view, especially with the Yankees always weighing how their outfield pieces might fit together down the line.
The remark has already sparked speculation about what the 2027 alignment could look like, including the possibility of Cody Bellinger shifting to center. For now, though, the Yankees have not tipped their hand on any firm outfield plan or on possible trade paths involving Jones, Heliot Ramos, or Jasson Dominguez, which leaves the debate very much alive for fans tracking every clue. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Bring Back A Familiar Arm For A Bullpen They Needed To Fix
The Yankees have moved to shore up a bullpen that needed attention, reaching a two-year agreement with right-hander Jonathan Loisiga and adding a third-year club option to the deal. The reported $18 million pact brings back a familiar arm for a relief group that has been a clear offseason priority, and it gives New York a pitcher it knows well after his long run with the organization.
Loisiga had drawn interest from several other clubs, including the Diamondbacks, Mets, Dodgers and Phillies, before choosing a return to the Bronx. For the Yankees, the appeal is obvious: they get a proven reliever back in a role where stability matters, while also keeping open the possibility of more help down the line if the option comes into play. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Passed On An Infield Chance They May Regret Fast
The Yankees spent the non-tender window trimming and sorting their pitching depth, moving on from Fernando Cruz and Luis Gil while keeping Clarke Schmidt, but the more interesting roster wrinkle came from elsewhere. When the Twins sent Royce Lewis to the Dodgers in a deal for Bobby Miller and Francisco Espinoza, it created the kind of infield opening New York has spent much of the winter trying to solve, especially for a club that values versatility and has been forced to weigh every move against its current roster construction.
Lewis would have fit the Yankees need for a player who can move around the diamond and add another layer of lineup upside, yet they passed on the chance to get involved. That decision may look sensible if the front office is prioritizing pitching depth and roster flexibility, but it also leaves a familiar question hanging over the winter: whether New York is being patient or simply letting a useful fit slip past while the market keeps shifting around it. [Read more 🡒]
