The Yankees do not need another headline-grabbing splash to start solving their biggest problems. What they need is a better roster shape, the kind that holds up when October tightens the screws and every matchup matters.
That was the lesson once again in Game 3 of the ALDS, when Tampa Bay ended New York’s season with a 4-3 win at Yankee Stadium. Victor Mesa Jr. delivered the decisive swing with a two-run homer off Max Fried in the sixth inning.
Ian Seymour got the win, Fried took the loss and Bryan Baker finished the sweep. Anthony Volpe’s apparent game-tying homer turned into an RBI double after fan interference, and the Yankees were left one run short.
It was a fitting finish for a team that won 90 games and still never quite felt balanced enough for the postseason grind. New York scored 739 runs in 2026 and posted a plus-138 run differential, according to MLB standings, but still finished behind Tampa Bay in the AL East before dropping all three Division Series games.
The talent was there. The fitting-together part was not.
That’s where the Yankees’ offseason can get interesting. Instead of chasing only the biggest names, they also have room to target players who plug holes, handle tough matchups and let Aaron Boone build lineups with more options. Catcher and the outfield are the obvious places to start.
Austin Wells finished on a better note after a rough first half, but left-handed pitching remained a problem area. In the outfield, the Yankees still have to decide how much responsibility should fall on Spencer Jones and which veteran can soak up center-field innings without making the lineup too left-handed when October pitching staffs start stacking up. Those aren’t glamorous questions, but they matter.
Two Chicago free agents are starting to make sense in that lane: Carson Kelly and Tyrone Taylor.
Kelly, a right-handed hitting catcher who finished 2026 with the Cubs, hit .258 with 10 home runs and a career-high 58 RBIs in 120 games. He was especially strong against lefties, batting .298 with six homers and an .871 OPS in 136 plate appearances. There is one wrinkle on his status: MLB lists him in the upcoming free-agent class, but his Cubs deal includes a $7.5 million mutual option for 2027 with a $1.5 million buyout.
Taylor is also right-handed and comes off a productive year split between the Mets and Cubs. He hit .279 with 11 homers, 38 RBIs and an .827 OPS in 97 games.
Against left-handed pitching, Baseball Savant shows a .318 average, six homers and a .921 OPS in 118 plate appearances. He made $3.8 million in 2026 and is an unrestricted free agent.
If the Yankees are looking for a cleaner fit behind the plate, Kelly stands out immediately next to Wells. Baseball Savant had Wells at a .436 OPS against lefties in 2026, while Kelly posted the .871 mark in those same matchups. That kind of split gives New York a straightforward platoon path without taking the starting job away from Wells.
Kelly’s value is not just about the bat, either. Baseball Savant credited him with positive framing and ABS value in 2026. An MLB executive who evaluated the fit made the case this way:
“Kelly is a tough out. He grinds his at-bats.
Is he an All-Star? No.
But you’re talking about a platoon with Austin Wells, who I think will be better next year. Kelly does well back there.
He’s a good receiver. I think that’s a good fit for the Yankees.
Kelly makes more sense to me than signing Jeffers,” the executive said to NJ.com.
Taylor brings a different kind of usefulness. He can cover all three outfield spots, and MLB records show he played left, center and right field in 2026. That kind of range matters for a club trying to avoid locking itself into one-dimensional roster pieces.
He also finished strong. After the Cubs acquired him from the Mets with Clay Holmes on Aug.
3, Taylor hit .351 over his final 30 regular-season games. He ended the year with 16 doubles and 11 homers in only 219 at-bats.
The same executive saw him as exactly the sort of flexible piece the Yankees can use.
“Tyrone is a gamer who’s got versatility in the outfield. That’s the reason he keeps finding a job.
He can play center, too. Is he a Gold Glover?
No, but he’s going to be just fine out there, just like Spencer Jones is. At the plate, Tyrone always has been a tough out.
I’ve always liked him,” the executive said.
The appeal of both players comes back to the same point: production against left-handed pitching and enough versatility to matter without costing the Yankees an everyday role or a premium price tag. Kelly and Taylor combined for 254 plate appearances against lefties in 2026 and hit 12 home runs in those matchups, with both posting OPS marks above .870.
That is the kind of shopping list that can quietly change a roster. Kelly could spell Wells in the right spots and help steady the catching group. Taylor could function as a fourth outfielder, handle center field and give Boone a right-handed option without blocking Jones.
The Yankees still have the bigger swings ahead of them. But if they want a roster that plays better in October, these two Chicago free agents fit the kind of upgrade that makes the rest of the puzzle work.
In Other News...
Yankees May Have Finally Found A Ryan McMahon Trade Path
Ryan McMahons first Yankees season did not go the way anyone in the organization imagined. He struggled at third base both at the plate and in the field, and with one year left on his contract, the Yankees are already being pushed to think about what comes next rather than waiting for the fit to improve on its own. If they are going to move him, they will need a partner willing to take on a short-term answer at the hot corner, which narrows the field quickly.
The Cardinals may offer that kind of opening, since they have shown interest in a short-term third baseman. That does not mean a deal is close, but it does give the Yankees a plausible trade path if they decide to move on from McMahon, and any discussion would likely center on whether a return piece such as catcher Pedro Pages could be part of the conversation. For now, it is still mostly a framework for a deal rather than a finished one, but it is at least the sort of framework New York has been looking for. [Read more 🡒]
Jazz Chisholms Old Feud Just Gave Yankees Fans Another Reason To React
Jazz Chisholm Jr. has dragged an old clubhouse grievance back into the spotlight, saying Miguel Rojas once destroyed his custom cleats during their shared time with the Miami Marlins as part of hazing. Rojas has since addressed the allegation without exactly disputing it, saying he would rather keep those kinds of matters private. It is the sort of off-field dustup that still has a way of following players long after they leave the same room.
Now Rojas has given Yankees fans another reason to take notice after showing up in custom cleats celebrating the Dodgers back-to-back championships and nodding toward a possible third straight title. For a New York fan base that is always watching the other contenders, and especially one with Chisholm now in pinstripes, the timing adds a little extra edge to a relationship that already carried some baggage. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Once Had A Future Brewers October Threat In Their Hands
Jake Bauers was one of those low-key Yankees acquisitions that looked more like a depth move than a long-term piece, but he made enough noise in 2023 to get noticed. After a strong start in Triple-A, he brought some power and patience to the plate in pinstripes, giving New York a useful left-handed bat before the club moved on from him the following offseason.
The Yankees sent Bauers to Milwaukee in a trade for Brian Sanchez and Jace Avina, and the Brewers have since gotten the better end of the deal in the short term. Bauers has fit well in Milwaukee and even chipped in during the 2024 National League Championship Series, with a free-agent decision looming next and a reminder that a player New York once had in hand could end up mattering on a bigger October stage. [Read more 🡒]