If the Yankees and Red Sox end up meeting in the Wild Card Series, one of the first questions New York will have to answer is how to handle Payton Tolle.
The left-hander has already given the Yankees plenty to think about this season, and he’s done it with a fastball that has become the engine of his game. Tolle leans on his four-seamer 45% of the time in 2026, and hitters are batting just .190 against it. That pitch was on full display in his Sept. 13 start against the Kansas City Royals, when he ripped through an immaculate inning with the kind of ease that makes a lineup look helpless.
But that start also offered the Yankees a possible opening.
As the outing went on, Tolle’s velocity slipped. He began the night around 97 MPH with the four-seamer, a touch above his season average of 96.1 MPH, but by the sixth inning it had fallen as low as 92.7 MPH.
He still finished without allowing a run and struck out seven, so there’s no simple way to call it a warning sign. Still, if New York can force long at-bats and drive up his pitch count, the Yankees may be able to make that fastball less dangerous as the game wears on.
That idea matters because Tolle has already handled this lineup well. In two starts against the Yankees this season, he has gone 1-1 against them while giving up very little damage.
On April 23, he allowed one run on three hits over six innings and struck out 11, though the Yankees later scored three runs after he left and won in Boston. On June 26, he was even sharper, tossing seven innings of one-hit ball with two walks and seven strikeouts in a 6-1 Red Sox win at Fenway Park.
Now the Yankees get a chance to see whether the script changes in October.
There’s also the workload angle. Tolle is at 143 innings this season, more than 50 innings beyond his previous career high, and 2026 has already become the longest season of his baseball life at either the college or professional level. That doesn’t guarantee anything, but it does give New York something to watch closely if this series goes the distance.
The Yankees, for their part, have some bats that profile better against heat. Ben Rice has been the club’s best fastball hitter by a wide margin, posting an .845 slugging percentage against the pitch.
Luis García Jr. and Paul Goldschmidt have also done damage against fastballs this year, though García Jr. has not hit as well against left-handers. Aaron Judge is returning from injury and working back toward form, which gives New York another hitter capable of punishing a mistake in the strike zone.
Not everyone in the Yankees’ lineup fits that description. Cody Bellinger and Austin Wells have both struggled against the fastball in 2026, and if Jazz Chisholm Jr. is healthy enough to return, his .338 slugging percentage would be the lowest of any starting position player. Those numbers make the fastball battle one of the more interesting parts of the matchup.
There’s another wrinkle, too. Boston could also bring Garrett Crochet into the picture, though the Red Sox are expected to handle him carefully and he will likely be on a pitch limit. The exact usage isn’t clear, but he would give Boston another dangerous left-handed option if needed.
For now, Tolle remains the starter New York is most likely to prepare for. He has already shown he can shut the Yankees down, but the late-game dip in his velocity gives them at least a path to work with. In a short series, that might be enough to matter.
In Other News...
Yankees Needed This From George Lombard Jr More Than Ever
With Aaron Judge on the injured list because of a right calf strain, the Yankees needed someone young to step into a larger spotlight in Arizona, and George Lombard Jr. answered with one of the best games of his brief big league run. The rookie collected two hits and drove in three runs in a 9-2 win over the Diamondbacks at Chase Field, giving New York some much-needed production from a lineup suddenly missing its biggest bat.
Lombard Jr. delivered both a two-run single and a home run, the kind of timely damage that can change how a game feels when the Yankees are trying to keep moving without Judge. Gerrit Cole also provided a steadying presence, working six innings and allowing two runs while striking out six, adding another milestone to a night that gave New York a cleaner look at how its depth can hold up when the roster gets tested. [Read more 🡒]
Bernie Williams Is Giving Yankees Fans A Whole New Reason To Watch
Bernie Williams has never really been just a former Yankees center fielder, and this fall he is adding another high-profile stage to a second career that has quietly become part of his identity. Beginning Oct. 22 and running through Nov. 29, Williams will perform with the Tony- and Grammy-winning band behind Broadways Buena Vista Social Club at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre, giving fans another chance to see him in a setting far removed from the old Yankee Stadium outfield.
For Yankees followers, it is a neat crossover that brings one of the franchises most beloved alumni into the Broadway spotlight at the same time former major league infielder Jose Iglesias is also in the show. The result is a rare baseball-to-theater connection that fits Williams longstanding music background and adds a little extra intrigue for anyone who still associates him with the pinstripes. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Suddenly Face A Brutal Aaron Judge Timeline
Aaron Judges trip to the 10-day injured list has put the Yankees in a familiar but unwelcome spot, waiting on the health of the player who still shapes nearly everything they do. The calf strain, specifically in the soleus muscle, is the latest setback in a season where the margins around Judge have mattered constantly, and Boone said the club will try to get him back before the year is over. Judge has said he wants to return by the postseason, but for now there is no firm timeline.
What makes this latest pause so tricky is the lack of clarity around just how long the Yankees may be without him. Boone did not offer any further detail on the severity of the injury, leaving the team to manage both the roster and the uncertainty that comes with losing its centerpiece. For a club built to contend now, the question is no longer only when Judge can swing again, but how much time the Yankees can afford to spend guessing. [Read more 🡒]