The Yankees have spent most of their offseason attention on the bullpen and third base, and that makes sense. Those are the loudest needs on Aaron Boone’s roster. But catcher belongs on Brian Cashman’s to-do list too, because the production there in 2026 was uneven at best.
Austin Wells opened the year in rough shape, hitting just .155/.247/.258 with six home runs, 13 RBI, and a .504 OPS in the first half. He steadied himself after that, though, and the second half looked much better: .229/.351/.436 with eight home runs, 19 RBI, and a .787 OPS. Even with that turnaround, the Yankees still need more certainty behind the plate.
The depth behind Wells didn’t do much to calm things down. J.C.
Escarra and Ali Sanchez both left plenty to be desired with the bat, and neither is locked in as a full-time backup answer. That’s why the Yankees had some hope of landing Ryan Jeffers in free agency, but earlier this week he took the qualifying offer from the Minnesota Twins.
That pushes New York further down the list of available catching options, with Tyler Stephenson and Carson Kelly now standing near the top. Kelly makes a lot of sense as a right-handed bat, but Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic raised the obvious question on Thursday: would he rather chase a starting job somewhere else than platoon in New York?
If Kelly goes that route, the Yankees could look at Jonah Heim.
Heim, 31, is a switch-hitter coming off a solid 2026 season split between the Atlanta Braves and the Athletics. His overall line was modest - .204/.262/.366 - but he still managed 13 home runs and 43 RBI in 105 games.
A lot of that damage came with the A’s in a friendlier park, but the power track record is real. He has hit at least 10 home runs in five straight seasons, and that doesn’t even include this past year.
The splits tell a more interesting story. Heim struggled badly against right-handed pitching, hitting .160 with three home runs, 20 RBI, and a .471 OPS.
Against lefties, though, he was a different player entirely, posting a .267 average with 10 home runs, 23 RBI, and an .855 OPS. Those numbers against southpaws are right in the neighborhood of Kelly’s 2026 line against lefties, when he hit .298 with six home runs, 24 RBI, and an .871 OPS.
Defensively, Heim brings some value too, though it’s not a clean upgrade across the board. He posted a 23.0% caught-stealing percentage, which was better than the league average of 22.8% and a jump from his 15.7% mark in 2025.
But the deeper metrics are less flattering. Baseball Savant had him in the third percentile in Blocks Above Average at -9 and the 33rd percentile in framing at -2.
That matters because Escarra and Sanchez weren’t exactly liabilities in those areas. Escarra ranked in the 73rd percentile in Blocks Above Average at 4, while Sanchez came in at the 45th percentile in Blocks Above Average at -1 and got a 6 in framing.
So the Yankees probably wouldn’t be buying a major defensive upgrade if they went after Heim. What they would be getting is a bat that could fit into a platoon and make sense if Kelly and/or Stephenson end up elsewhere.
The price tag should stay reasonable. A two-year, $8 million deal feels like the right range, especially with Yankee Stadium in the picture. Spotrac projects Heim’s calculated market value at two years and $7.6 million, and if Cashman wanted to protect the club a little more, the second year could be a club option.
It wouldn’t be the splashiest move on the market, and it wouldn’t carry the same weight as Kelly or a trade for Hunter Goodman. But Heim would be a workable addition, and enough of one to give the Yankees a solid platoon in 2027.
In Other News...
Yankees May Finally Have What It Takes To Land Hunter Goodman
The Yankees had Hunter Goodman on their radar at the trade deadline, but Colorado never moved him then, even as New York kept looking for ways to add offense behind the plate. Goodmans bat has only made the fit more obvious since, after a strong 2026 season that included 41 home runs and a road total that stood out for a primary catcher.
This offseason, the Rockies sound more willing to listen as they try to patch a pitching staff that needs help in a big way, and that opens the door for a different kind of deal than the one New York explored in July. The Yankees have pitching assets they could put into a package, which gives them a path back into a conversation that was already active once and may finally have the pieces to move forward. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Linked To A Blockbuster Idea Fans Will Strongly Debate
Jim Bowden floated a trade idea that would certainly get Yankees fans talking, one that would send All-Star infielder Otto Lopez from Miami to the Bronx in exchange for Anthony Volpe, Jasson Dominguez and Will Warren. The concept is straightforward enough on paper: New York would be trying to shore up its middle infield and add another bat to the lineup, while Miami would be getting a package built around younger, controllable talent.
For the Yankees, the appeal is obvious, but so is the price. Volpe remains a central figure in the organizations infield plans, Dominguez still carries major upside, and Warren gives the Marlins another arm to consider. It is all purely hypothetical for now, though, and there has been no indication from either club that anything close to this kind of blockbuster is actually in motion. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Got A New Trade Deadline Edge They Could Use Soon
Dustin Mays new three-year, $52.5 million deal with the White Sox is the kind of move that can ripple beyond one clubhouse. For the Yankees, it offers a fresh reference point as they weigh how other teams might value controllable arms, especially pitchers like Will Warren and Ryan Weathers, whose appeal comes from a mix of team control, upside and the kind of durability questions front offices always have to sort through.
For New York, that matters because the trade deadline is rarely just about what the Yankees need, but what the market will pay for what they can spare. If pitching prices keep climbing, the Yankees could find themselves with a better lane to deal from, whether they are chasing help on the mound or looking to add an infielder. The challenge now is figuring out which clubs are willing to meet that price and which direction New York wants to push when the offers start coming in. [Read more 🡒]
