Yankees May Have A Risky Answer To Their Catching Problem

The Yankees' offseason catching woes might find a solution in the promising yet risky trade target, Hunter Goodman of the Rockies.

The Yankees still have catching on the offseason to-do list, and Hunter Goodman has suddenly re-entered the conversation.

Austin Wells finished strong in 2026, but New York can’t ask him to carry the position alone. His production against left-handed pitching was rough all year, and the backup options behind him - Ali Sanchez and J.C. Escarra - don’t exactly inspire confidence.

That’s why the free-agent market remains worth watching. Ryan Jeffers is off the board after taking the Twins’ qualifying offer, but the Yankees still have names to consider.

Carson Kelly stands out as the cleanest fit because of his left-right splits, defense, and ability to handle a starter’s workload. If Kelly lands elsewhere, Jonah Heim, Kyle Higashioka, Tyler Stephenson, and even Gary Sanchez are still in the mix.

But the trade market may have opened a door too.

According to Jon Morosi of MLB Network, the Rockies appear more willing to deal All-Star catcher Hunter Goodman. Colorado had considered moving him at the trade deadline, though no club was willing to meet the asking price. Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic reported that the Rockies remain open to a trade, and the price tag still hasn’t changed.

One reason Goodman may be easier to move now: he’s under control through 2029. With labor uncertainty making pending free agents tougher to trade, that kind of long-term control carries real weight.

The Yankees were among the teams interested in Goodman at the deadline, and the fit still makes sense on paper. Colorado is always hunting for pitching, and New York has plenty of arms it could put into a deal.

Goodman brings serious thump. He launched a career-high 41 home runs in 2026, and more than half of them came away from Coors Field. In fact, he was better on the road than at home, posting an .882 OPS and 135 wRC+ away from Denver compared to a .791 OPS and 88 wRC+ at Coors.

Hunter Goodman again!Home run No. 41 is a 3-run jack 💪 pic.twitter.com/fzX9QC8xs8

Still, this is not a simple plug-and-play move. Goodman’s value comes with real baggage, and the Yankees would have to decide whether they’re comfortable paying a premium for a catcher who is still very much a work in progress.

He has three more seasons of club control, which helps explain why the Rockies’ price remains so steep. And even with a combined 6.0 fWAR over the last two seasons, Goodman is not a finished product.

Defensively, there are concerns. He’s not considered a strong catcher behind the plate, and while he excelled using ABS, his blocking and framing need work. He also had a hard time controlling the running game, throwing out just 17 of 91 stolen base attempts last season for an 18.7% caught-stealing rate.

The biggest issue, though, is his approach at the plate. Goodman struck out 30.5% of the time last season, and the only Yankee with a higher strikeout rate was Spencer Jones.

That alone wouldn’t be fatal if he were a disciplined hitter who lived in the zone. He isn’t.

Goodman posted a 40.4% chase rate, which ranked in the 5th percentile on Baseball Savant, and a 34.0% whiff rate, which sat in the 4th percentile. Those are ugly numbers, and they point to a hitter who swings and misses far too often.

The power is real, and that’s what makes the idea so tempting. But the Yankees would be betting that they can clean up his discipline and turn that raw pop into something more reliable. If they can get him to chase less and swing at strikes more often, Goodman has the tools to become a much more dangerous hitter.

That’s the gamble here. Goodman’s ceiling is clearly higher than Wells’, but his floor is just as risky if the swing-and-miss issues never get fixed.

For the Yankees, a trade for him would be a classic high-risk, high-reward swing. If they believe they can develop him into a more complete player, it makes sense.

If not, sticking with Wells and finding a dependable backup may be the safer route.

In Other News...

Yankees Face A Bullpen Decision That Could Shape Their Offseason

The Yankees have already started reshaping the back end of their bullpen by agreeing to terms with left-handed reliever Tim Hill, and the work does not figure to stop there. With relief depth always a priority in New York, the club is still weighing how aggressively to pursue more help, especially with free agency offering a few different ways to add another late-inning arm.

Adrian Morejon is on the radar, but his qualifying offer complicates the equation, and there is also a case for a different route if the Yankees want to prioritize depth over a single splashier move. Jason Adam has emerged as an appealing alternative in that discussion, with the decision coming down to contract expectations, health history and how the Yankees want their bullpen to look by the time camp opens. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Fans Have Every Right To Be Embarrassed By This Triple-A Rollout

The Yankees Triple-A affiliate has a new identity, and it comes with a heavy dose of franchise nostalgia. Scranton/Wilkes-Barre is now the Highlanders, a name that nods both to the Pennsylvania highlands and to the Yankees own early days from 1903 to 1912, giving the club a built-in historical hook as it tries to refresh its brand.

The rollout, though, did not exactly land the way the organization probably hoped. The team unveiled an AI-created promotional video featuring its mascot and historical imagery, and the reaction on social media was immediate and negative, with fans taking aim at the production quality as much as the concept itself. For a fan base already frustrated with the broader direction of the Yankees, from ownership concerns to recent on-field disappointment, even a minor-league rebrand became another easy target. [Read more 🡒]

Jasson Dominguez Just Made The Yankees Outfield Crunch Even Tougher

Jasson Domnguezs winter work in the Dominican Republic has only sharpened the conversation around his place in the Yankees plans. After a stretch that has him hitting .375 with a 1.146 OPS in 11 games, the 22-year-old has drawn notice beyond the organization, with general manager Brian Cashman acknowledging that other clubs have taken interest as the Yankees continue sorting through their outfield picture.

For New York, the issue is not whether Domnguez has talent, but how that talent fits into a crowded mix. He is still working through defensive questions and his struggles against left-handed pitching remain part of the evaluation, which makes his path to steady playing time far from simple. The Yankees are weighing his market appeal at a time when roster decisions are already complicated, and while no formal trade offers have been announced, the attention around him is only adding another layer to the outfield crunch. [Read more 🡒]