A Luis Garcia Jr. trade this offseason used to sound like a stretch. After Joel Sherman’s read on the Yankees’ roster, it looks a lot more plausible.
The basic problem is the same one the Yankees created when they brought Garcia in: the fit in the lineup is tricky, and the bench math is getting tighter. Ben Rice is locked in as a centerpiece and should settle in at first base this offseason.
Aaron Judge is returning, but the question of how long he can keep playing full-time in right field is hanging there. Giancarlo Stanton remains under contract, and that situation is still one of the biggest offseason questions.
On top of that, the Yankees may also want to keep a right-handed first baseman like Paul Goldschmidt around, which only adds to the squeeze.
That’s why Sherman’s warning this week carried weight. The idea that Garcia Jr. could be dangled in a trade, possibly to help the bullpen, lines up with how the Yankees have to think about the roster. If there’s a way to turn him into a different need, they can’t be afraid to do it.
The irony is obvious: the Yankees traded bullpen help to get Garcia, and now they could flip him for bullpen help. That kind of loop doesn’t exactly scream efficiency, but it does make sense if the front office sees him as more of a short-term piece than a core bat.
And that may be the biggest clue here. If Garcia stays in the Bronx, it sure sounds like the Yankees would view him as more of a 2027 rental than a long-term answer.
He can still push that conversation in a different direction if he becomes more reliable and more flexible defensively, especially away from first base. For now, though, the team’s commitment to Rice makes a first base/DH pileup hard to ignore.
There are also other paths the Yankees could explore. A slugging third baseman like Isaac Paredes, who is on the way out in Houston, would fit a different need.
Christian Walker, a right-handed first baseman, is another name that could be attached to a deal. And the Diamondbacks reportedly pushed for Garcia Jr. at the deadline, which opens the door to the idea that Garcia plus prospects could be part of a larger move involving Ketel Marte.
That doesn’t mean the Yankees should be eager to move him. Garcia is a fun player, and the source of this whole conversation isn’t about dumping him for the sake of it.
It’s about making room. If the chance comes to strengthen another area and clean up a logjam that’s already building for next year, the Yankees can’t afford to blink.
Garcia may need to expand his defensive range this spring, with second base and third base both mentioned as possibilities. If he does, he gives himself a better shot at sticking. If not, the Yankees may decide that he’s exactly the kind of movable piece that can be used to solve a bigger problem.
In Other News...
Yankees May Have Finally Found A Ryan McMahon Trade Path
Ryan McMahons first Yankees season did not go the way anyone in the organization imagined. He struggled at third base both at the plate and in the field, and with one year left on his contract, the Yankees are already being pushed to think about what comes next rather than waiting for the fit to improve on its own. If they are going to move him, they will need a partner willing to take on a short-term answer at the hot corner, which narrows the field quickly.
The Cardinals may offer that kind of opening, since they have shown interest in a short-term third baseman. That does not mean a deal is close, but it does give the Yankees a plausible trade path if they decide to move on from McMahon, and any discussion would likely center on whether a return piece such as catcher Pedro Pages could be part of the conversation. For now, it is still mostly a framework for a deal rather than a finished one, but it is at least the sort of framework New York has been looking for. [Read more 🡒]
Jazz Chisholms Old Feud Just Gave Yankees Fans Another Reason To React
Jazz Chisholm Jr. has dragged an old clubhouse grievance back into the spotlight, saying Miguel Rojas once destroyed his custom cleats during their shared time with the Miami Marlins as part of hazing. Rojas has since addressed the allegation without exactly disputing it, saying he would rather keep those kinds of matters private. It is the sort of off-field dustup that still has a way of following players long after they leave the same room.
Now Rojas has given Yankees fans another reason to take notice after showing up in custom cleats celebrating the Dodgers back-to-back championships and nodding toward a possible third straight title. For a New York fan base that is always watching the other contenders, and especially one with Chisholm now in pinstripes, the timing adds a little extra edge to a relationship that already carried some baggage. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Once Had A Future Brewers October Threat In Their Hands
Jake Bauers was one of those low-key Yankees acquisitions that looked more like a depth move than a long-term piece, but he made enough noise in 2023 to get noticed. After a strong start in Triple-A, he brought some power and patience to the plate in pinstripes, giving New York a useful left-handed bat before the club moved on from him the following offseason.
The Yankees sent Bauers to Milwaukee in a trade for Brian Sanchez and Jace Avina, and the Brewers have since gotten the better end of the deal in the short term. Bauers has fit well in Milwaukee and even chipped in during the 2024 National League Championship Series, with a free-agent decision looming next and a reminder that a player New York once had in hand could end up mattering on a bigger October stage. [Read more 🡒]