The Yankees once came close to building a package for Paul Skenes, and the longer this keeps going, the more that old idea starts to look less like fantasy and more like a future the Pirates may not be able to avoid.
Back at the 2025 trade deadline, New York tried to get Pittsburgh to consider moving Skenes, according to Jon Heyman of the New York Post in March. The ask would have been massive: Cam Schlittler, Carlos Lagrange, George Lombard Jr. and Spencer Jones may have been part of the haul. Pittsburgh shut it down before an offer ever got to the finish line.
The Yankees kept their young talent, and that decision ended up shaping the rotation they took into 2026. Schlittler became the arm they could not lose, piling up 193 2/3 innings with a 1.95 ERA and 239 strikeouts in his first full major league season. He started Game 1 of the Wild Card Series at Yankee Stadium on Sept. 29 as the presumptive American League Cy Young Award winner.
The rest of the staff followed the same script. Max Fried, in the second year of an eight-year deal, posted a 2.80 ERA in 20 starts despite two trips to the injured list for an elbow bone bruise.
Gerrit Cole returned from Tommy John surgery in May and finished at 3.61 in 22 starts. Carlos Rodón, back from elbow inflammation in August, had a 1.89 ERA in seven starts.
That’s why the Yankees are heading into the winter with a familiar kind of question hanging over everything: what does it take to win in October? Aaron Judge has already said the front office should go all-in.
And now the same name from last summer’s trade conversation may be getting easier to chase.
Skenes is heading into arbitration for the first time, and his salary is about to climb. The gap between what he costs and what the Pirates typically spend is shrinking fast. People around Pittsburgh expect his pay to push past the club’s comfort zone after the 2027 season, and some believe he could be pitching somewhere else by 2028.
That matters for the Yankees because the timing fits their own books.
Cole’s nine-year deal and Rodón’s six-year deal both run through 2028. If New York were to line up a trade before the 2028 season, it would get two controllable years of Skenes as those contracts come off the ledger.
Skenes has already built a résumé that would make any front office pay attention. Through 87 career starts and 495 innings, he owns a 2.62 ERA with 586 strikeouts. His 2026 expected ERA was 3.30, which hints that some of the rise in his numbers may have been bad luck.
This past season, though, was not the same runaway dominance people had gotten used to. Skenes went 10-11 with a 3.82 ERA in 32 starts, struck out 200, and made his third straight All-Star team. His average fastball dipped to 96.8 mph, and he pointed to his World Baseball Classic workload as part of the reason.
After his final start, a 2-1 win over St. Louis at PNC Park on Sept. 24, he evaluated the year plainly.
“I think it was a good year. I don’t think it was to the caliber of the last two years,” Skenes said.
He also made clear where his own confidence sits.
“I think my best baseball is ahead of me and I think our best baseball is ahead of us,” Skenes said.
The Yankees connection has followed him before. After a November 2025 report said he wanted to play in New York, Skenes pushed back on The Dan Patrick Show.
“It is what it is. There’s stuff that’s gonna come out, good and bad. Obviously, it’s not true,” Skenes said.
The financial side keeps moving in the same direction. Skenes made about $1.1 million in 2026, and MLB Trade Rumors projects $7.2 million for 2027.
That would land just under the $7.25 million Dallas Keuchel received in 2016 in his first arbitration year after winning the AL Cy Young Award. No current pitcher with three years of service has won both a Rookie of the Year award and a Cy Young.
The raises get steeper after that. Skenes has two more arbitration years after 2027, and he won’t be eligible for free agency until after the 2029 season. His Rookie of the Year award gave him a full year of service time, which moved that timetable up a season.
For Pittsburgh, the bill keeps getting harder to carry. The Pirates have 10 arbitration-eligible players projected to cost just under $30 million, which is roughly a quarter of their 2026 payroll. General manager Ben Cherington said last November that Skenes would be a Pirate in 2026, but Heyman has since reported that Pittsburgh has little hope of signing him long term under the current rules.
The club has not shown any sign it is ready to move him now. And with the collective bargaining agreement expiring Dec. 1 and an owners’ lockout expected, the larger picture is only getting more complicated.
Still, the Yankees already know where to look if the door ever cracks open. Heyman wrote that they would “circle back if they ever detect even a glimmer of an opening,” and there have been no reported trade talks since. Skenes remains under Pirates control through 2029.
In Other News...
Yankees Just Lost A Key Coach In A Troubling Development Blow
The Yankees are losing one of the more quietly important figures in their development pipeline, as the Astros have hired Spencer Medick away from Triple-A to become their new director of pitching. Medick had been in the organization since 2022 and spent time working with Cam Schlittler during the right-handers rise through the minors, a stretch that helped shape one of the most encouraging young pitching stories in the system.
Schlittlers 2026 season only sharpened the interest around that work, finishing with a 1.95 ERA, the lowest qualifying mark for the Yankees since 1978. So while the move is being made at the staff level rather than on the major league roster, it still lands as a meaningful development loss for a club that has leaned heavily on continuity in its pitching instruction. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Boone Just Made Jazz Chisholms Yankees Future Feel Clear
Jazz Chisholm Jr.s first full run in pinstripes never quite settled into the kind of season the Yankees were hoping for, and it ended with more questions than answers. His uneven 2026 performance was already under the microscope before a costly throwing error in the ALDS only added to the scrutiny, making the fall feel even steeper for a player brought in to bring energy and production.
Then Aaron Boone said the quiet part out loud. The Yankees manager made it clear that Chisholms approach has rubbed him the wrong way, pointing specifically to the kind of behavior that can grate inside a clubhouse, and the comments only sharpened the sense that Chisholm may not be part of the teams long-term plans. For a player whose talent still makes him intriguing, the issue now is whether the Yankees see enough fit beyond the flashes to keep the relationship going. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Fifth Starter Battle Comes Down To Upside Or Reliability
The Yankees have plenty to like at the top of their rotation, with recent All-Stars like Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodn and Max Fried headlining a group that also includes Cam Schlittler. The question now is less about star power than about how to round out the back end, where the fifth-starter spot has turned into a familiar kind of camp debate: do the Yankees lean into upside, or do they choose the arm they trust most to take the ball and keep them in games?
Ryan Weathers looked like a real candidate after a solid 2026 season, but the forearm injury he suffered late in the year complicates his case. Will Warren, meanwhile, brings the kind of durability teams value in April and beyond, having topped 150 innings in each of the past two seasons, even if his command can wander at times. For a club built to expect excellence from the front of the rotation, the final choice may come down to whether it wants the ceiling of a comeback candidate or the steadier profile of a workhorse who does not always have perfect feel. [Read more 🡒]