Brian Cashman has made it clear the Yankees are willing to look everywhere for help at third base. Alec Bohm just doesn’t look like the answer.
That’s the tension at the heart of New York’s offseason search. Cashman said Tuesday at the general managers’ meetings in Las Vegas that the club was open to upgrading after Ryan McMahon’s 2026 season fell short of expectations. McMahon finished with a 78 wRC+, minus-3 Defensive Runs Saved and zero Outs Above Average, and he was also below average as a baserunner by FanGraphs’ metric.
“Obviously, ’26 didn’t go as expected,” Cashman said Tuesday. “But that doesn’t mean it’s not there (for McMahon).
It doesn’t mean it can’t be there for us next year. It also doesn’t mean that I can’t be looking around to see how I can upgrade at the same time.
We’ll see if (McMahon) is here. I know he’s capable of more, and I do believe in his abilities.
We’ll evaluate all options and see where that takes us at the same time.”
Then came the report that the Yankees, along with the New York Mets, have interest in Bohm, the former Phillies third baseman now on the free-agent market. On paper, Bohm gives you a right-handed bat and a career 130 wRC+ against lefties, which sounds useful for a roster that could lose Amed Rosario and Paul Goldschmidt in free agency. But the fit starts breaking down fast.
The Yankees have spent years valuing strong defense at third base, and that was a major reason they went after McMahon at the 2025 trade deadline. They were done watching poor defense from Oswald Peraza and Oswaldo Cabrera cost them games, so they brought in a proven glove and absorbed McMahon’s contract to stabilize the position.
Bohm is the opposite kind of bet. Since his MLB debut in 2020, no third baseman has been worse defensively.
He has minus-58 Defensive Runs Saved over that span, a number that is 17 runs worse than Rafael Devers from 2020-26. The Phillies even moved Bohm to first base after the trade deadline this season, mostly to make room for Luis Arraez.
That alignment put Bohm at first, Arraez at second, Bryson Stott at third and Bryce Harper in right field. Bohm has been better at first than at third, but even there his defensive numbers have still been negative in DRS and OAA.
That’s where the roster puzzle gets messy for New York. Ben Rice is an everyday player, whether he’s at first base or DH.
Luis García Jr., if he stays, figures to get most of his work at first even though Cashman has said the team wants him to get second-base reps this offseason. And Giancarlo Stanton is expected to remain on the roster at least into spring training, and longer if he’s healthy.
If Stanton is still around in the regular season, the Yankees would want him in the lineup against lefties, too.
So if Bohm is brought in, the most realistic place for him is third base - and that’s the problem. The Yankees would be asking a team that already prioritizes defense at the hot corner to live with a player whose glove has been a major liability.
There’s also the question of whether New York even needs to chase another first-base type at all. On days when the Yankees face lefties, the cleanest offensive setup might be Aaron Judge at DH, Rice at first and Heliot Ramos in right field, which would reduce the need for a player who profiles better at first than third.
And if the Yankees are willing to live with Bohm’s defensive issues at third, it raises another question: why not go after Teruaki Sato instead? He’s viewed by at least one Yankees evaluator as a player whose future may not be at third base, while multiple rival scouts think his best position could be corner outfield.
Cost matters here, too. FanGraphs projects Bohm for a one-year, $10 million deal.
McMahon is owed $16 million in 2027, so keeping him and adding Bohm as a platoon partner would be a questionable use of money. A better path, if the Yankees want to move on, would be to eat part of McMahon’s contract and trade him for a new starter.
That all comes back to ownership. Cashman said Hal Steinbrenner has already set payroll parameters, though the number remains unknown.
If the Yankees want a real upgrade, the trade market offers more appealing possibilities than Bohm. Corey Seager is one possibility, though he has a full no-trade clause, would need to approve any deal and has five years and $162.5 million left on his contract.
Houston’s Isaac Paredes, who is on an expiring deal, could also be available. Other names that could surface include Baltimore’s Jordan Westburg, San Francisco’s Casey Schmitt, Cubs’ Matt Shaw and Texas’ Josh Jung.
The free-agent class at third base is thin. That’s why the best route for the Yankees may be a trade, not a stopgap. And if they’re serious about fixing third base, Bohm doesn’t look like the move that should get them there.
In Other News...
Yankees Fans Suddenly Have A New Power Prospect To Watch
Kyle West gave Yankees fans a reason to keep one eye on the Arizona Fall League this fall. The 22-year-old outfielder earned a spot in the American League Fall Stars game after a productive run with the Salt River Rafters, where he showed the kind of power that can turn a prospect from a name in the system into a player worth tracking closely.
Over 21 games, West put together a .257/.361/.543 line with six home runs and 17 RBIs, but the number that really stood out was the one attached to his biggest blast. He launched a 462-foot homer, the longest in the AFL this season and the fifth-longest in league history, a reminder that his bat can leave a mark long before he reaches the Bronx. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Fans Just Got An Unwanted Reminder About Verdugo
The Red Sox are once again in the middle of an outfield conversation that has plenty of Yankee fans paying attention, even if they would rather not. Jarren Duran is reportedly being shopped, a topic that has been widely known around the GM Meetings, and it has naturally stirred memories of Bostons 2023 decision to move Alex Verdugo to New York.
For the Yankees, the comparison is an uncomfortable one because Duran and Verdugo share a similar profile as talented left-handed outfielders who flashed early promise before their careers took an unexpected turn. Verdugos stint in pinstripes did not go the way the Yankees hoped, so any reminder of that trade brings back a familiar question about whether Boston is again trying to move on from a player with a lot of talent and a lot of uncertainty attached. [Read more 🡒]
Brian Cashman Just Added To A Growing Yankees Injury Debate
The Yankees spent much of the 2026 season trying to patch together a roster that kept getting hit by injuries to major names like Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger and Gerrit Cole. At the GM Meetings, Brian Cashman acknowledged that the club did not communicate well enough about injuries during the year, a candid admission that only adds to a debate that has lingered around the organization for a while. Judges rib stress fracture became a particularly pointed example of how much uncertainty surrounded the teams injury updates.
Cashmans comments land in the middle of a larger pattern the Yankees have struggled to shake, with past injury situations often handled cautiously or with delays that left fans and observers wanting clearer answers. For a team that has spent so much time managing absences from key players, the issue is not just who gets hurt, but how the club explains what is happening and when. The next step for the Yankees is not only getting healthier, but proving they can handle the communication side of the equation better than they did this season. [Read more 🡒]