The New York Yankees are stirring the pot once again, with manager Aaron Boone casually dropping a big one: he’s “comfortable” with Ryan McMahon playing shortstop if the season were to kick off today. Now, while Boone might be sipping his coffee with ease, Yankees fans might not be feeling as cozy.
McMahon, known for his stellar defense at third base, has been trying to adjust to the shortstop position during spring training. However, his performance has been a bit like trying to solve a Rubik’s Cube while sprinting-his natural third base instincts don’t quite translate to the demands of shortstop.
This move is classic Brian Cashman roster maneuvering. The Yankees are looking to maximize their offensive potential on the bench, eyeing veteran Randal Grichuk as a key piece.
By slotting McMahon as the emergency shortstop, they can stack a bench featuring Grichuk, Paul Goldschmidt, Amed Rosario, and JC Escarra. On paper, it’s an impressive lineup of reserves, but it leaves the infield defense on shaky ground.
The root of this situation is Anthony Volpe’s absence. He’s recovering from shoulder surgery and isn’t expected back until late April or May.
Volpe was a standout before his injury, posting a 115 wRC+. In his absence, Jose Caballero is set to take the reins.
Caballero, known for his speed and solid defense, could be the spark the Yankees need. But if he gets sidelined, McMahon is next in line-a risky move the Yankees seem willing to make.
Grichuk’s bat is the driving force behind this decision. The Yankees are eager to have his prowess against left-handed pitching, boasting a career 118 wRC+ in that department. To make room for him, they’re forgoing a traditional backup shortstop, betting on Caballero’s health and Volpe’s swift recovery.
This gamble is emblematic of the Yankees’ current strategy: prioritizing potential offensive firepower over defensive stability. McMahon could find his rhythm with more time, but the margin for error is slim.
If a crucial play slips away in the early season, questions will arise about the Yankees’ choices, especially with their substantial payroll. It’s a bold move, and only time will tell if it pays off.