Yankees Still Betting on Anthony Volpe’s Potential, Despite Setbacks
The Yankees know the pressure that comes with playing in pinstripes-especially when you're a homegrown shortstop expected to be the next big thing. Anthony Volpe entered the league with high expectations, but after a third consecutive season with an OPS of .666 or lower and a string of defensive miscues, some fans are starting to lose patience.
It’s not hard to see why. Volpe’s bat hasn’t come around the way many hoped, and his glove-once billed as a strength-hasn’t been as reliable as advertised.
But there’s a key detail that’s easy to overlook: Volpe was playing through a partially torn labrum in his left shoulder last season. That’s no small thing, especially for a player whose swing and range rely heavily on upper-body strength and mobility.
Now, with offseason surgery behind him, Volpe is set to begin the 2026 season on the injured list as he continues his rehab. In his place, the Yankees will turn to Jose Caballero, who led the majors with 49 stolen bases last year. Caballero brings a different dynamic to the lineup-speed, defense, and a spark on the basepaths-but the Yankees aren't closing the book on Volpe by any means.
Manager Aaron Boone made that clear during an appearance on WFAN Sports Radio NY on Monday morning. When asked about Volpe’s future, Boone didn’t hesitate.
“I still think Anthony's gonna be a frontline shortstop in this league,” Boone said. “Everyone's path isn't linear. We always want it to be, and that can be tough, especially in New York, where you're kind of finding your way.”
That last part hits home. Developing in the Bronx is a different beast.
The lights are brighter, the scrutiny sharper, and the margin for error slimmer. Volpe’s journey hasn’t been smooth, but Boone’s comments suggest the Yankees are still playing the long game with their 24-year-old infielder.
Of course, Boone was also realistic when asked if there's a point where the team might move on if things don’t improve.
“Sure,” he replied, with a tone that didn’t leave much room for interpretation.
That’s the balance the Yankees are trying to strike-patience with purpose. They believe in Volpe’s upside, but they’re not blind to the results.
The leash isn’t infinite, but the runway’s still there. And with Caballero holding down the spot for now, Volpe will have to earn his way back onto the field when he’s healthy.
For now, the Yankees are sticking with the belief that Volpe’s best is still ahead. Whether that belief pays off will be one of the more intriguing storylines to watch this season in the Bronx.