The Yankees are headed into the AL Division Series with one clear edge over the Rays and one ugly problem hanging over the matchup.
After knocking off the Red Sox in two games in the AL Wild Card Series, New York now gets the No. 1 seed Tampa Bay Rays. The teams just saw each other in a four-game set at Yankee Stadium during the final week of the regular season, and the Yankees took three of those games. That recent success is the kind of thing Yankees fans can cling to, but the matchup still comes down to a simple formula: the Yankees need to press their advantage against left-handed pitching while surviving the one place they’ve struggled for years.
Tampa Bay is a strong all-around club and won 98 games for a reason. The Rays can get offense from different spots in the lineup, even power when they need it. But against lefties, they look completely different.
The Rays make plenty of contact regardless of the arm on the mound, but their real damage comes against right-handers. Their power jumps, they chase less, and they reach base more often.
Against lefties, the picture changes fast. Junior Caminero is a beast, Yandy Diaz is more than playable, and Ryan Vilade and Victor Mesa Jr. give them two platoon bats.
After that, they’re left with a bunch of hitters who don’t offer much. Liam Hicks, a big deadline acquisition, doesn’t help much in left-on-left matchups either.
That’s where New York can make life miserable for Tampa Bay. The Yankees have two All-Star-caliber left-handed starters and a bullpen with plenty of options from that side.
Max Fried is locked in for Game 3, and Carlos Rodón could be a major factor after blanking the Rays for eight innings a week ago. There’s even a path for Rodón to start both Game 1 and Game 4 on normal rest, though Gerrit Cole’s role could change that plan.
If Cole takes the ball instead, Rodón could still fit into the picture as part of a lefty-heavy relief mix.
That bullpen depth matters. Ryan Weathers could be in the mix after narrowly missing the Wild Card Series roster. Brent Headrick, who has reverse splits, Ryan Yarbrough, and Tim Hill, who was left off the Wild Card Series roster, are all possible pieces as well.
The Yankees were burned last year when Toronto buried them under a wave of offense in two games, and they never had the chance to answer. This year, without the Game 1 Luis Gil situation from last postseason, they look better built to force Tampa Bay into lower-scoring games. The question is whether that’s really the kind of series they want to play.
Because the biggest concern for New York isn’t just Tampa Bay. It’s where the games are being played.
If the series goes five, three of the games will be at Tropicana Field. It will also be the Yankees’ first postseason game at that venue, since the 2020 ALDS was played at a neutral site because of COVID-19.
And the numbers at Tropicana Field have not been kind to the Yankees. Since 2016, they’re 34-45 there, a 70-win pace over a full season.
Away from that building, they’ve gone 416-345 in road games over the same stretch, which works out to an 89-win pace. At Yankee Stadium, they’ve done much better against Tampa Bay, going 54-37 in that span.
Their home record against everyone else has been similarly strong.
The gap has plenty of explanations. The turf helps a Rays team that leans on ground balls, speed, infield singles, and bunts.
The setting has also led to concerns about soft-tissue injuries over time. The roof, with its baseball-like color, has made fly balls tougher to track for visiting teams than for the Rays, who see it every day.
Tampa Bay has used that edge to build a 55-26 home record, a 110-win pace, and the best home mark by any team in four years.
There’s also Aaron Boone’s playoff record to consider. Under Boone, the Yankees are 8-7 in postseason series.
They’re 7-0 when they have home-field advantage, but 1-7 when they don’t. That lone win without home field came in 2020 against the Cleveland Guardians in front of zero fans.
Crowd noise may not be much of a factor in St. Petersburg this weekend, but history still leans the Rays’ way when the Yankees don’t have the Bronx behind them.
In Other News...
Yankees Make A Crucial ALDS Rotation Call Against The Rays
The Yankees are leaning into experience as the ALDS opens at Tropicana Field, choosing Gerrit Cole for Game 1 against the Rays even though the numbers might have pointed them in a different direction. It is the kind of decision that says plenty about how New York is approaching this series, with postseason pedigree carrying real weight when the margin for error is so thin.
The matchup comes with some added intrigue because the clubs are meeting in the postseason for just the second time in franchise history, and the schedule does the Yankees a small favor with a day off between Games 1 and 2. That break gives both sides room to manage arms and adjust plans, but it also raises the stakes on the opener, where New York is trusting its top starter to set the tone before the series shifts and the pitching choices get even more interesting. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Quietly Sent A Message About A Pitcher They Just Called Up
Alexander Cornielles first taste of the majors was brief, but it still gave the Yankees a look at a live arm they had developed in-house. The right-hander debuted last week and worked one inning, picking up his first two big league strikeouts before the roster squeeze that followed Giancarlo Stantons return forced New York to make a move.
Cornielle was designated for assignment and then passed through waivers, allowing the Yankees to keep him in the organization by outrighting him to their Florida Complex League affiliate. It is a small procedural note, but it also suggests the club still sees enough there to keep him close, even if his path back to the majors now goes back through the minors. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Enter Rays Series With One Big Edge Fans Will Love
The Yankees are moving on from the tension of the Wild Card round and into a Division Series matchup with Tampa Bay that feels familiar for more than one reason. New York got past Boston and now heads into the ALDS against a Rays club that earned home-field advantage by finishing ahead in the AL East, while Tampa Bay also comes in with a rested pitching staff after waiting for the bracket to sort itself out.
Still, there is reason for Yankee optimism, starting with the possibility that Aaron Judge returns for the series. The clubs just saw plenty of each other not long ago, too, and New York took three of four at home in that season set, a reminder that even with the Rays holding the higher seed, the matchup may not feel nearly as one-sided as the schedule suggests. [Read more 🡒]