The Yankees spent big on stability and ended up with a number that should make them wince.
By the time the season reached late September, the club that believed it had patched together a sturdier roster had run into a far messier reality. The bullpen had been asked to cover for too many stretches, the rotation had carried more than its share, and the everyday lineup never quite gave New York the kind of consistent middle-of-the-order punch it thought it had bought.
Three roster spots tell the story best. The Yankees committed $52 million in 2026 salary to DJ LeMahieu, Trent Grisham and Ryan McMahon, and those three combined for just 0.7 wins above replacement, according to a widely circulated data breakdown among Yankees fans. That fWAR figure, which comes from FanGraphs, is the kind of snapshot front offices live with - and, in this case, the kind that exposes a brutal return on investment.
McMahon took the biggest share of the money and was supposed to steady third base. Instead, he hit .213 with a .635 OPS and 11 home runs in 124 games, according to Baseball-Reference. His glove kept him on the field, but the bat never gave the Yankees enough to balance out the cost.
LeMahieu’s situation became even more awkward. The veteran was released in the summer with nearly $22 million still owed on his deal, a payment the Yankees remain responsible for whether he plays for them or not, as reported by NBC News and CBS Sports at the time. Before his release, he played 45 games and hit .266 with a .674 OPS and two home runs, per Baseball-Reference.
Grisham was the last piece of the spending puzzle. He came back after accepting the Yankees’ qualifying offer last winter following a career year at the plate in 2025, but the production did not carry over. He hit .211 with a .703 OPS and 18 home runs in 121 games before a September stint on the injured list, according to Baseball-Reference.
The Yankees would have every reason to point out that wins above replacement is not a perfect measure. It folds offense, defense, baserunning and position into one number, and it can miss the value of a reliable defender or a player who helps in ways the stat sheet doesn’t fully capture. But it is also the currency modern front offices trust, and 0.7 fWAR across $52 million is the sort of return that gets noticed fast.
That matters even more because the bill is not done. LeMahieu’s salary is already a sunk cost, and McMahon is due $16 million in 2027 as part of the six-year, $70 million contract he originally signed with Colorado, which runs through 2027, according to Spotrac.
So this is not just a bad season’s ledger. It is a problem that reaches into next year, too.
Aaron Boone spent much of the year juggling the lineup and trying to squeeze better results out of the group he had. A third baseman expected to lock down the position instead posted one of the weakest offensive seasons of his career.
A veteran second baseman was cut loose with a huge amount still on the books. An outfielder brought back on a hefty one-year deal ended up on the injured list during the stretch run.
For a club that has talked so much about discipline and smart spending, that is a rough look. The Yankees poured money into three spots, and the field gave them almost nothing back.
In Other News...
Cam Schlittler Just Added More Heat To Yankees Red Sox Tension
Cam Schlittler has already learned that anything he says online can ripple far beyond the app, especially when the Yankees and Red Sox are involved. In an interview with Brendan Kuty of The Athletic, the young Yankees pitcher revisited the social media back-and-forth with Boston fans, including the deleted comment that briefly took on a life of its own after he responded to a Red Sox-themed podcast.
For a pitcher trying to settle into October baseball, the noise is part of the backdrop, but Schlittler made clear he is aware of how quickly those exchanges can sharpen the edge of the rivalry. He also pointed to past online run-ins as something he has used to fuel his work on the mound, which only adds another layer to a Yankees-Red Sox storyline that already tends to carry plenty of heat. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Got A Tougher ALWCS Opener Than Anyone Expected
Boston is turning to rookie Payton Tolle for Game 1 of the wild-card series against the Yankees, a choice that adds a fresh wrinkle to a matchup already loaded with October pressure. Tolle has been throwing well lately, and the Red Sox clearly see enough in the young left-hander to open the series with him, especially with New York carrying a lineup that leans heavily left-handed and may be without Aaron Judge.
If that plan holds, the Yankees are staring at a tougher opener than many expected, with the Red Sox lining up Sonny Gray in Game 2 and Ranger Suarez in Game 3. Gray gives Boston a veteran edge as the staff ace, while Suarez brings postseason experience, so New York will have to be ready for a series that could demand immediate adjustments rather than a slow feel-out period. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Austin Wells Decision Suddenly Looks A Lot More Important
Austin Wells has spent much of the season fighting to get his bat going, but the Yankees have seen a more encouraging version of him since the trade deadline. His offense has ticked up, and he has continued handling the catching duties for a pitching staff that will matter even more once October arrives, which helps explain why the club stood pat behind the plate instead of searching for outside help.
The timing makes that decision feel a lot bigger now, with a postseason matchup against the Red Sox looming and Adley Rutschman in the conversation on the other side. Wells does not have to carry the lineup to make his presence important, but the Yankees need his recent progress to hold if they want the position to be an advantage rather than a question mark in a series where every edge will count. [Read more 🡒]