The Yankees may have a second shot at the catcher they chased all summer, and this time the opening comes from Colorado’s changing mindset, not New York’s persistence.
Hunter Goodman was one of the biggest names on the Yankees’ radar at the 2026 trade deadline, but no deal ever came together. For a while, that looked like the end of it. Now the Rockies appear more willing to listen, and the timing is tied to baseball’s labor situation as much as anything else.
The collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1, and with the possibility of a lockout hanging over the sport, clubs are thinking differently about trade value. Teams are less eager to part with players who could hit free agency soon. Goodman is in the opposite category: he is controlled through 2029, which makes him a very different kind of trade chip.
MLB Network insider Jon Morosi reported Wednesday night that Colorado’s stance has softened. He wrote on X: “Rival MLB teams believe the Rockies are more willing to move All-Star catcher Hunter Goodman this offseason than they were at the trade deadline,” Morosi wrote. “One reason: While labor uncertainty is making it difficult to trade pending free agents, he is under control through 2029.”
That control is exactly what makes Goodman so attractive - and so expensive.
The Rockies set a high bar before the deadline, according to Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic, asking for multi-player packages that included a team’s No. 1 overall prospects. The Yankees were among the clubs that checked in.
Jon Heyman of the New York Post reported that New York talked with Colorado about Goodman, and the Yankees also explored Baltimore’s Adley Rutschman and Cincinnati’s Tyler Stephenson. A look at Minnesota’s Ryan Jeffers never got anywhere.
Goodman stayed put, and the Yankees rolled into October with the same catching setup. But the market around him has shifted since then, and the Rockies now sound more open to moving him than they were in July and August.
The appeal is obvious. Goodman is not a rental.
He is set to reach arbitration for the first time this winter and still has three seasons of club control left. MLB Trade Rumors projects his 2027 salary at $6.2 million, a manageable number for a catcher who just put together a monster power season.
In 138 games in 2026, Goodman hit .245 with 41 home runs, 88 RBIs and an .839 OPS. He became only the eighth catcher to reach 40 homers in a season, according to a Rockies season review. MLB.com reported that he led National League primary catchers in home runs and total bases, and his 25 road homers broke Johnny Bench’s 1972 NL record of 24.
That road production matters, especially for a team like the Yankees that would naturally wonder how much of the power came from Coors Field. Goodman’s bat traveled.
Colorado’s asking price still figures to be the main hurdle. The Rockies’ pitching staff ranked last in the majors with a 5.48 ERA in August, according to Bleacher Report’s Joel Reuter, so pitching remains the obvious priority in any trade. ESPN’s Jeff Passan and Kiley McDaniel identified high-ceiling arms as the type of return Colorado wants, and Elmer Rodriguez, Carlos Lagrange and Ben Hess were named this summer as the Yankees’ best pitching prospects to match that profile.
There are other questions too. FanSided’s Robert Murray reported that teams had concerns about Goodman’s defense behind the plate at the deadline, so any suitor would have to balance the bat against the glove before paying Colorado’s price.
For the Yankees, the catching picture still starts with Austin Wells, who remains the starter. He is arbitration-eligible this winter, while J.C.
Escarra and defense-first Ali Sanchez are also on the roster. Ben Rice has caught before, but he does not appear to be part of the catching plan.
Jeffers remains available as a cheaper free-agent option. Goodman would cost much more in prospect capital, but he would also bring far more offense.
Morosi did not report active talks with any team. Still, with Colorado sounding more willing to move Goodman and Dec. 1 creeping closer, the Yankees have a fresh opening to revisit the catcher they could not land in July.
In Other News...
Yankees Fans Will Love What Cashman Said About Hideki Matsui
Last month, Brian Cashman got a Zoom message from a familiar face with big news. Hideki Matsui wanted to tell the Yankees general manager himself that he was taking over as manager of the Yomiuri Giants, a move that marked the latest step in a baseball life that has already taken him from Japanese stardom to the Bronx and back again.
Matsui, the former Yankees slugger and 2009 World Series MVP, was officially named to the post on October 23, and Cashman made it clear he was proud to see him reach that point. For Yankees fans, it is another reminder of how much Matsui still means to the organization, and why his success continues to resonate well beyond his playing days. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Rumors Are Zeroing In On Two Urgent Needs
The general manager meetings in Las Vegas wrapped up with the sense that this offseason could move quickly, and the Yankees already appear to be circling a couple of areas that need attention. One of the more concrete links has been to free agent catcher Carson Kelly, while the broader rumor mill has also tied New York to pitcher Tarik Skubal and third baseman Alec Bohm as the front office weighs ways to reshape the roster.
For a team that expects to stay in the thick of the race, the urgency is obvious. Catching help and infield stability remain obvious pressure points, and the Yankees are being mentioned in conversations that could address both, even if none of it has been confirmed by official sources. With the market now shifting from meetings to real negotiations, New York looks like a club worth watching closely as the winter gets moving. [Read more 🡒]
Cashman Just Made The Yankees Biggest Offseason Concern Clear
The Yankees have already made it plain where the winter work starts. Brian Cashman said the clubs top offseason priority is rebuilding the bullpen, a need sharpened by free agent departures and injuries that have thinned the relief corps. The front office would like to bring back some familiar arms, including David Bednar and Paul Blackburn, but the broader task is finding enough reliable innings to stabilize the late-game picture.
For now, everything else sits a step behind that bullpen repair job. New voices in the hitting department and upgrades at third base or second base remain on the radar, but they are not the immediate focus as the Yankees map out their roster. The message from the top is clear: before the club worries about adding polish, it has to rebuild the foundation of the pitching staff. [Read more 🡒]