The Yankees would not be shopping for a simple upgrade if Adley Rutschman ever became available. They’d be staring at one of the biggest trade swings on the market - and the price tag would almost certainly reach well beyond a couple of premium names.
That’s the backdrop after ESPN’s Jeff Passan reported that Baltimore’s catcher could be in play if the Orioles decide to listen on offers. Baltimore’s core hit its peak in 2023 with 101 wins and an AL East runaway, then followed with 91 wins in 2024. This year, the club is below .500 and has little chance at a postseason spot, which opens the door to the possibility of a fire sale.
For the Yankees, that kind of situation creates an obvious temptation. Trading inside the division is not unheard of for them - they’ve done business with the Boston Red Sox before - but this would be on a completely different level than moving Adam Ottavino or Carlos Narváez to Fenway.
If Baltimore were to entertain the idea, the Orioles would be positioned to demand a massive return. George Lombard Jr. would likely be the kind of name that starts the conversation, and Dax Kilby could also be part of the ask. If New York were willing to include its top 100 prospect, the Orioles would probably push for one or both of Carlos Lagrange and Elmer Rodríguez too.
Passan’s reporting also suggests the Orioles could seek under-control arms in return, which puts Will Warren and Ryan Weathers in the realm of possibility.
Yankees OnSI’s Devon Platana floated a mock deal for Rutschman last month that didn’t include Lombard, Lagrange, or Rodriguez. Instead, it centered on Ben Hess, Spencer Jones, and Xavier Rivas.
“Is that somewhat of an overpay,” Platana writes. “Perhaps, but the sacrifice will be worth the effort if Rutschman can live up to his reputation upon joining the Bronx Bombers.”
On the field, Rutschman would give the Yankees a clear boost. He’s hitting .251/.331/.433 this season, and while that may not match what Baltimore hoped for when it drafted him in the first round, it would still be a major step up from Austin Wells.
His value isn’t limited to the bat. Rutschman’s defense remains elite, with an 80th percentile blocks above average, a 99th percentile caught stealing above average, and a 97th percentile framing runs saved, according to Baseball Savant. He also owns a 98th percentile fielding run value.
So the question for the Yankees is simple, even if the answer is not: how much prospect capital is worth paying to solve their biggest hole? If the cost gets too steep, they may have to look elsewhere. But there’s no question Rutschman would make them better.
In Other News...
Anthony Volpe Is Now Drawing A Trade Suitor Yankees Fans Will Notice
The Rays are once again in the mix as a team to watch at the trade deadline, and this time their search for lineup help has them linked to a name Yankees fans know well: Anthony Volpe. Contributors to The Athletic recently listed Tampa Bay as one of the better fits for the New York shortstop, a reminder that even a young player with real pedigree can find his name circulating when a season starts to drift from expectations.
Volpe is still under team control through 2028, so any conversation around him would be about fit, development and long-term value rather than a quick rental move. Tampa Bay has built a reputation for getting more out of players, which is part of what makes this pairing worth watching if the Rays decide to get aggressive and if the Yankees decide they need to listen. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Finally Got Injury News Fans Desperately Needed On Stanton And Fried
Giancarlo Stantons return has been one of the Yankees most closely watched injury stories since the slugger went down with a calf strain on April 24, and there is at least some forward movement now. Stanton has resumed a running progression, which is a meaningful step even if the club still has not put a firm timetable on when hell be back in a game.
Max Frieds path is a little clearer, and it matters just as much for a rotation that could use the help. The left-hander, sidelined since mid-May with a bone bruise in his elbow, is lined up for a 60-pitch rehab start on July 22, with the Yankees expecting him to rejoin the staff next week as they move into a series against the White Sox. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees May Finally Have A Real Catching Fix At A Cost
Shea Langeliers has started to look like one of the more practical catching targets on the market for a Yankees club that could use a clearer answer behind the plate. The Athletics have been open to listening, and the fit is obvious on paper: New York gets a catcher with real offensive upside, while Oakland gets the kind of pitching help it has been chasing as it tries to reshape the roster.
The catch, of course, is getting a deal to the finish line without emptying out the system in a way the Yankees will regret later. Any serious conversation is going to have to account for the Athletics' need for arms, which pushes the talks toward prospect-heavy packages and makes the price feel less like a simple upgrade and more like a calculated gamble on how much catching certainty is worth right now. [Read more 🡒]