Yankees Finally Had A Defensive Bright Spot On A Brutal Night

Cody Bellinger's Gold Glove win highlights the Yankees' defensive success, but past trades leave lingering regrets.

Cody Bellinger gave the Yankees their lone Gold Glove winner of 2026, and he did it in a way that fit the season he put together in left field: steady, loud, and impossible to miss.

Bellinger took home the American League Gold Glove on Sunday night, ending a seven-year wait for a Yankees outfielder. It was the second Gold Glove of his career, after he won in right field with the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2019.

He beat out Texas’ Wyatt Langford and Tampa Bay rookie Chandler Simpson, and he became the first Yankees outfielder to win the award since Brett Gardner in 2016. The Yankees have now had a Gold Glove winner in back-to-back seasons after left-hander Max Fried won for pitchers in 2025.

Bellinger’s case was built on the numbers. He led all MLB left fielders with 21 defensive runs saved, which tied for third among all players at any position.

He also finished with six outs above average and eight outfield assists, tied for third among left fielders. His throws averaged 93.3 mph, landing in the 94th percentile.

After splitting 2025 among all three outfield spots and first base, he made 112 starts in left this year and also picked up a Fielding Bible Award in October with 14 of 17 first-place votes.

His signature moment came Aug. 28 against the Boston Red Sox, when he fired a 99.7 mph throw to catcher Austin Wells to nail Ceddanne Rafaela at the plate and preserve a 1-0 Yankees lead in a win. Afterward, Aaron Boone called it out in no uncertain terms.

“One of the defensive plays of the year,” Boone said.

Bellinger said the everyday rhythm of one position helped sharpen everything.

“I think with one position, you get the reps, consistency and a consistent arm release,” Bellinger said.

The Yankees acknowledged the honor on social media with a simple message:

“Good as Gold. Congratulations on your 2nd career Gold Glove, Belli!” the team posted.

But the night also carried a sharper edge for New York. Two other players the Yankees moved on from won Gold Gloves elsewhere, leaving the club to watch old decisions pay off for someone else.

One of those was Ezequiel Duran of the Texas Rangers, who beat out Yankees utility finalist Jose Caballero. Duran started his pro career in the Yankees system, then went on to play every position except pitcher and catcher.

He ranked in the 99th percentile with 17 combined outs above average, and his season included 17 homers and 80 RBIs through mid-September. It was the first utility Gold Glove in Rangers history.

Rangers manager Skip Schumaker made his pitch publicly in September.

“I think something is wrong if he doesn’t win the Gold Glove,” Schumaker said.

At third base, the winner was Boston’s Caleb Durbin, another former Yankee. The Yankees added Durbin to their 40-man roster in November 2024 and traded him weeks later.

He led AL third basemen with 13 defensive runs saved and became the second Red Sox third baseman to win a Gold Glove, joining Frank Malzone, who won three straight from 1957 to 1959. Boston finished with three Gold Gloves overall, tied with Arizona for the most of any team.

Durbin played through a left pinkie injury that required surgery after the season, and he said he expects more from himself in 2027.

“There’s more in the tank,” Durbin said.

Wells also came up short at catcher, losing to Detroit’s Dillon Dingler, the 2025 winner. The full American League list included Tanner Bibee at pitcher, Christian Walker at first base, Cole Young at second base, Taylor Walls at shortstop, Ceddanne Rafaela in center field, Wilyer Abreu in right field and Duran at utility.

For the Yankees, the bigger sting may be the trail those awards traced back to two trades. In July 2021, they sent Duran, Josh Smith, Glenn Otto and Trevor Hauver to Texas for Joey Gallo and Joely Rodriguez.

Gallo hit .159 with 25 homers and 194 strikeouts in 140 games with the Yankees before being traded to the Dodgers for Clayton Beeter. Smith later won the 2024 AL Silver Slugger as a utility player.

Then in December 2024, New York dealt Durbin, Nestor Cortes and cash to Milwaukee for Devin Williams. General manager Brian Cashman had mentioned Durbin weeks earlier as a possible internal option at second base for 2025.

Williams posted a 4.79 ERA with 18 saves in 67 appearances in his only Yankees season, then signed a three-year, $51 million deal with the Mets. Milwaukee later traded Durbin to Boston in February.

Put together, those deals gave the Yankees about a season and a half of Gallo and one season of Williams. The players they moved on from have now collected three major awards since, including two on Sunday night.

In Other News...

Yankees Just Cut Ties With A Name Suddenly Near Cooperstown

Brian Sabeans run as an executive advisor with the Yankees is over after four seasons, with the club deciding not to renew his contract. It is a notable turn for a longtime baseball executive who had been part of the organizations recent front-office mix, and it comes at a moment when his name is getting fresh attention beyond the Bronx.

Sabean is one of eight finalists on the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee ballot for the Hall of Fame, with results due Dec. 6. The group also includes Lou Piniella and Bill White, two names with Yankees connections of their own, giving this round of consideration a distinctly familiar feel for the organization even as one of its recent advisers moves on. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Suddenly Face A New Coaching Problem After October Exit

The Yankees are already dealing with the fallout from their October exit, and now another layer has been added to the offseason uncertainty. Brad Ausmus, the clubs bench coach, interviewed with the Astros for their vacant manager position, putting one of Aaron Boones top assistants in the middle of a job search while New York sorts through its own next steps.

Ausmus is not the only coach with his future in question, either. Several Yankees coaches, including Ausmus and hitting coach James Rowson, have contracts expiring, and the organization is evaluating its staff after the playoff disappointment. Houstons opening came after the Astros fired Joe Espada, and with multiple candidates in the mix, New York could be looking at more than just a routine coaching tune-up. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Have A New Power Bat To Weigh At Third Base

The Yankees are still sorting through their third-base picture for next season, and the priority is clear: add more offense there without giving back too much on the other side of the ball. One name in the mix is Si Hwan Roh, the Hanwha Eagles third baseman who is available through the posting system until Dec. 1 and could offer a different kind of answer for a lineup that is looking for more impact.

Roh has built a reputation in the KBO as a steady power threat with on-base ability, which is exactly the sort of profile that can make a front office pause in the offseason. His contract situation also makes an MLB move possible now, giving the Yankees a legitimate external option to consider as they weigh whether third base is best filled internally or through a new addition. [Read more 🡒]