The Yankees may be staring at all kinds of uncertainty this offseason, but their rotation is not one of them. Even after the abrupt ALDS crash-and-burn, New York enters the winter with a rare kind of problem: too many starters who look capable of helping in the majors.
At the top of the pile sits presumptive AL Cy Young Cam Schlittler, with Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodón and Max Fried giving the Yankees four arms who have made All-Star teams over the last four years. That kind of group is a luxury on its own.
The catch is that all three veterans are on long-term deals and in their mid-to-late 30s, which makes depth more than just a bonus. It makes it necessary.
For now, the race for the fifth spot looks like it belongs to Ryan Weathers, who was excellent in his first season in pinstripes. New York paid three minor leaguers to land him before the 2026 campaign, and he immediately looked like a worthwhile bet. He showed better command than expected, held up for long stretches while injuries hit the rotation, and made a crucial midseason change by leaning more on spin and break to cut down the barrel rate against him.
That adjustment turned his season. By the time he faced the Blue Jays in late August, Weathers had posted a 3.60 ERA with 143 strikeouts in 137.1 innings over 25 starts.
After he started leaning away from his fastball, he surrendered only three of the 18 homers he allowed all year across his final 12 outings. There were even people arguing he should start over Rodón in a postseason setting.
But the year still ended with concern. Weathers suffered a forearm flexor strain on August 22 after a career-high workload, and that injury shut him down for the rest of the regular season. The Yankees did avoid the worst-case version of the story and even got him back for a few innings in the playoffs, but there’s still some hesitation about whether his body can handle a full season.
If it can, he’s the front-runner. He’s only 26, and the changes he made last season hinted at a higher ceiling still waiting to be unlocked. The fastball usage dipped, but the idea of him getting to a point where he can land that high-90s heater for strikes more consistently is an enticing one.
Will Warren is another name the Yankees have to sort through, and durability may be the strongest argument in his favor. Outside of Schlittler, he was the only Yankee to reach 150 innings in 2026. He’s also just the third Yankees pitcher to log 150 innings in back-to-back seasons, joining Cole from 2021-23 and Rodón from 2024-25.
Warren isn’t the easiest pitcher to love. He’ll flash nasty breaking balls and those backdoor sinkers, but the command comes and goes, and the inconsistency can drive fans up the wall.
Still, he finished strong after a brutal midseason skid, posting a 3.92 ERA with 158 strikeouts in 156 innings over 32 games. The late highlight came in late August, when he delivered seven brilliant innings against Boston to help seal the first wild card spot.
There’s plenty to like there, but the Yankees may also be thinking about a different use for him. His bullpen work late in the year could push the team toward a Michael King-style conversion, especially if New York spends most of its offseason money on offense and leaves the bullpen thinner than it would like. Warren was able to push his fastball up to 97 for two innings at a time in October, and that possibility is clearly part of the conversation.
Then there’s Clarke Schmidt, the forgotten variable. His 2026 season was wrecked by the long rehab from Tommy John surgery, and after an internal brace procedure, he returned in mid-September as a relief option before bicep soreness in a bullpen session shut him down before the playoffs. He ended the season with just 0.2 innings.
That’s a miserable stat line, but it shouldn’t erase what he showed before surgery. In June 2025, Schmidt threw seven no-hit innings in what looked like a breakout stretch.
Even after back-to-back rough starts, he still had a 3.32 ERA in 78.2 innings before getting hurt. He’s battled injuries throughout his career and has topped 100 innings only once, yet across 30 starts in 2024-25 he posted a 3.07 ERA over a full season’s worth of work.
Schmidt enters his final year before free agency with plenty to prove, and he’s clearly a long shot behind Weathers and Warren. Even so, the Yankees will want him available if injuries force their hand.
And then there’s Elmer Rodríguez, the young arm who got a major league cameo in 2026. He showed enough with his stuff and pitch mix to stand out at times, and he appears to have handled Triple-A. At 23, he’s reached the point where he needs a real big-league chance, even if the path is murky.
Maybe that chance comes in the bullpen, where his high-90s sinker could play up. Maybe he becomes trade bait. Maybe injuries create an opening nobody can predict right now.
However it shakes out, starting pitching should remain one of the Yankees’ biggest strengths in 2027. The only real mystery is who gets to be part of it.
In Other News...
Yankees Just Lost A Key Coach In A Troubling Development Blow
The Yankees are losing one of the more quietly important figures in their development pipeline, as the Astros have hired Spencer Medick away from Triple-A to become their new director of pitching. Medick had been in the organization since 2022 and spent time working with Cam Schlittler during the right-handers rise through the minors, a stretch that helped shape one of the most encouraging young pitching stories in the system.
Schlittlers 2026 season only sharpened the interest around that work, finishing with a 1.95 ERA, the lowest qualifying mark for the Yankees since 1978. So while the move is being made at the staff level rather than on the major league roster, it still lands as a meaningful development loss for a club that has leaned heavily on continuity in its pitching instruction. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Boone Just Made Jazz Chisholms Yankees Future Feel Clear
Jazz Chisholm Jr.s first full run in pinstripes never quite settled into the kind of season the Yankees were hoping for, and it ended with more questions than answers. His uneven 2026 performance was already under the microscope before a costly throwing error in the ALDS only added to the scrutiny, making the fall feel even steeper for a player brought in to bring energy and production.
Then Aaron Boone said the quiet part out loud. The Yankees manager made it clear that Chisholms approach has rubbed him the wrong way, pointing specifically to the kind of behavior that can grate inside a clubhouse, and the comments only sharpened the sense that Chisholm may not be part of the teams long-term plans. For a player whose talent still makes him intriguing, the issue now is whether the Yankees see enough fit beyond the flashes to keep the relationship going. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Could Turn Luis Gil Into A Catching Need They Actually Have
Luis Gils name is going to come up plenty this offseason as the Yankees sort through a roster that already has some obvious pressure points. The right-handers value has shifted after a rough year, and that makes him one of the more intriguing pieces New York could use if it decides to rework the pitching staff rather than simply run it back. For a club that has spent a lot of time trying to patch around its weaknesses, the idea of turning a starter into a more direct roster fit is the kind of move that naturally gets attention.
One possible path ties the Yankees to a catching situation they actually need help with, and it points toward San Diego as a logical trade partner. Luis Campusano has been floated as the sort of target that could make sense if the Padres decide they need pitching depth and the Yankees want to add a catcher with upside rather than wait for the market to break their way. It is still very much a speculative scenario, but it reflects the larger question hanging over New Yorks winter: whether a once-promising arm can be turned into a cleaner answer behind the plate. [Read more 🡒]