CC Sabathia didn’t exactly hand the Red Sox a gift Yankees fans would enjoy unwrapping.
The former New York ace, whose name still carries serious weight in the Bronx, offered a strong public endorsement of Boston left-hander Payton Tolle after the season. That alone would have turned heads. Coming from Sabathia, it lands with extra force.
“I love watching him, and I love his personality. I don’t think I could have pitched the way he does.
I was always way more emotional and upset… He’s top of the league as far as stuff goes. I love the way he attacks guys,” Sabathia said.
For Yankees fans, that’s a tough one to hear. Sabathia spent the final 11 seasons of his career in New York and helped bring home the 2009 World Series. He also won 251 major league games and took the 2007 AL Cy Young Award with Cleveland, so when he talks pitching, people listen.
His praise for Tolle comes after Boston’s rookie lefty already gave the Yankees a look at what he can do in the wild-card opener on September 29. New York rolled to a 9-0 win, but the scoreboard doesn’t tell the whole story of Tolle’s outing.
He worked 4 2/3 innings, allowed five hits and one earned run, walked one and struck out four. The Yankees scored their first run on Austin Wells’ RBI single in the second, with George Lombard Jr. crossing the plate. Tolle then left in the fifth with New York ahead 1-0.
Everything unraveled after that. Ben Rice homered off the Boston bullpen to make it 2-0, then added an RBI single in the seventh and a grand slam in the eighth.
He finished with two home runs and six RBIs. Cam Schlittler handled the rest for New York, striking out 10 over 6 1/3 scoreless innings to earn the win.
The final score was lopsided. The innings before Tolle exited were not.
That’s part of why Sabathia’s endorsement carries so much weight. He wasn’t just reacting to velocity or a hot streak. He singled out the way Tolle competes, and he made it clear he sees a pitcher with real substance.
The numbers back that up. Tolle finished the regular season 9-6 with a 3.03 ERA in 26 starts.
He struck out 171 batters in 148 2/3 innings, walked 40 and posted a 1.10 WHIP, according to MLB’s official statistics. His strikeout rate works out to about 10.35 per nine innings, and his strikeout-to-walk ratio was 4.28.
That’s a sharp step forward from his 2025 debut, when he had a 6.06 ERA in seven appearances, including three starts. The jump from that brief, rough introduction to a full season with Boston’s rotation says plenty about how much he developed.
It also helps explain why Tolle is now part of the conversation heading into future Yankees-Red Sox matchups. Boston reached October with him as one of its young arms, and Sabathia’s comments only add to the buzz around what the left-hander might become.
The Yankees still won the wild-card series before being eliminated in the Division Series, so there’s no changing that. But Sabathia’s words gave Boston a fresh offseason talking point - and gave Yankees fans something they probably didn’t want to hear from one of their most trusted voices.
In Other News...
Yankees Infield Plans May Hinge On One Polarizing Free Agent
The Yankees search for infield help has led them to a familiar name from across the division, with Jon Heyman of The New York Post reporting that the club has shown interest in free agent Alec Bohm. A former Phillies third baseman, Bohm brings corner-infield versatility, and he would fit into a market where New York is still weighing ways to shore up its options on the dirt.
Bohm also comes with plenty of debate attached, which is part of why his market is worth watching. His recent seasons have featured uneven production at the plate and some inconsistency in the field, so any move would be as much about fit and projection as it would be about immediate certainty. For the Yankees, the question is whether he ends up being a real solution or just one more name in a search that still has room to evolve. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Face Delicate Aaron Judge Problem Heading Into 2027
The Yankees are already thinking ahead to 2027 with Aaron Judge, and the plan is as much about preservation as production. The club expects to use him at designated hitter at times to ease the strain on his body, a sign that New York is trying to protect its biggest offensive weapon after injuries limited him to 66 games in 2026. It is the kind of adjustment that reflects both Judges importance and the reality of how carefully the Yankees have to manage him now.
Brian Cashman also acknowledged the organization did a poor job handling the public messaging around Judges calf injury in 2026, and he said the team wants to be better about that going forward. For a player whose health status immediately becomes a front-page issue in New York, the communication piece matters almost as much as the lineup decisions, especially with the Yankees trying to balance honesty, caution and the need to keep Judge available for the long haul. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Second Base Decision Is Starting To Say A Lot About Jazz
Brian Cashmans latest comments made the Yankees offseason picture at second base a little clearer, and a little more revealing about where Jazz Chisholm stands in the organizations thinking. With Chisholm coming off a strong 2025 before a tougher 2026, the club is already sounding open to alternatives, and Cashman pointed to Anthony Volpe, Jose Caballero and Max Schuemann as possible internal answers if the Yankees decide to reshuffle the infield.
Cashman also left the door open to free agency, while making it clear the Yankees could still work through a mix of internal options, outside signings and trade possibilities. For a player who arrived with real expectations, the tone around Chisholm now feels different, and the fact that the Yankees are publicly mapping out life without him suggests this winter could bring a clean break rather than a simple reset. [Read more 🡒]