Yankees Face One Tough Trade Choice In Third Base Pivot

As the Yankees explore strategic moves for third base, Casey Schmitt from the Giants presents a promising path forward following Maikel Garcia's recent trade to the Mariners.

The Yankees’ search for a third baseman just got a lot more interesting, and a lot more urgent.

New York has made it clear it wants to move on from Ryan McMahon, and the club appears ready to absorb money to make that happen. The bigger picture is just as obvious: the Yankees want a third-base upgrade, and they’re hunting for a trade partner with a need for pitching. That’s the one thing they can offer in volume.

Two names surfaced Wednesday morning as possible fits, both available for starting pitching help, according to ESPN’s Jeff Passan: San Francisco’s Casey Schmitt and Kansas City’s Maikel Garcia. Garcia was the more established target, a player on a reasonable contract who is only one year removed from an All-Star season. Schmitt was the other option, and one the Yankees had already shown interest in last summer.

Then the market shifted fast. A few hours later, Garcia was dealt to the Mariners in a huge package that included Bryce Miller and three MLB pitchers total. It was the kind of return that makes you wonder whether New York would have been willing to go that far for an offense-first gamble at third base.

Garcia’s appeal was obvious enough. The Yankees know him well after he irritated them in the 2024 playoffs, when he got under their skin and had run-ins with Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Anthony Volpe during the postseason and the follow-up clashes between the teams.

He put up 5.8 bWAR and hit 16 homers in 2025, then still managed a 102 OPS+ last season even as his power dipped. He also has four years left on a five-year, $57.5 million deal.

That’s a fair contract, but not one the Yankees can chase without giving up real pitching.

Schmitt now looks like the cleaner path. The Giants infielder hit 21 home runs last season and posted a 119 OPS+, while remaining under team control through 2029. He’s the more potent bat, and the fact that he wasn’t moved last summer is a little surprising given New York’s previous interest.

If the Yankees want to get something done, they have the arms to do it. Will Warren stands out as their most attractive trade chip because of his durability, upside, and more than two years of effective major league work.

Elmer Rodriguez gives them a high-pedigree prospect to dangle, while Ryan Weathers offers the kind of breakout teams keep betting on, even with injury concerns still hanging around. Clarke Schmidt and Luis Gil could also be included if New York moves quickly, before Friday’s Day of the Non-Tender.

The Yankees probably shouldn’t rush to empty the cupboard for one player. But with Garcia off the board, Schmitt is the obvious next call, and the fit is hard to miss: an upside third baseman for pitching help.

In Other News...

Jasson Domnguez Just Reopened A Yankees Debate Fans Thought Was Settled

Jasson Domnguez is giving the Yankees something they have not had much of lately around his name: a reason to keep the conversation going. After a stop-start beginning to his big league career, with Tommy John surgery and defensive issues complicating the picture, Domnguez is showing a more encouraging offensive version of himself in the Dominican Winter League. He is hitting .355 with two home runs and 10 RBIs, a reminder that the bat still carries the kind of upside that once made him one of the organizations most talked-about young players.

For the Yankees, though, the question has never been only about whether Domnguez can hit. His long-term fit still depends on tightening up his defense and proving he can handle left-handed pitching, and that leaves his role very much in play as the club weighs its options. With Spencer Jones and Heliot Ramos also part of the roster conversation, Domnguezs winter surge has reopened a debate that looked settled for a while, and it is not hard to see why the Yankees will want a clearer answer before spring turns into something more permanent. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Just Sent A Clear Message With Two Surprise Roster Calls

The Yankees used the roster deadline to make their intentions clear, protecting a trio of prospects by adding left-hander Kyle Carr, right-hander Carlos Lagrange and outfielder Garrett Martin to the 40-man roster. It was the kind of housekeeping move that also says plenty about how the organization views its young depth, especially with the Rule 5 Draft looming and other clubs always ready to pounce on unprotected talent.

David Bednar also accepted the qualifying offer, giving New York another piece of business to close before the deadline passed. With those decisions in place, the Yankees have finalized their roster protections and signaled which arms and bats they were most determined to keep in the fold heading into the winter. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Fans Are Turning On A Reunion That Says Everything

The Yankees decision not to extend a qualifying offer to Jazz Chisholm Jr. has already shifted the conversation around his future in New York. By letting the free-agent second baseman hit the market without draft-pick compensation attached, the club kept its options open, but it also made clear that a reunion was never going to be automatic.

Fan sentiment has not exactly softened the picture. A Pinstripes Nation poll found nearly 90% of respondents opposed bringing Chisholm back for another season, even though a return is still possible, and the reaction on social media has been just as split. For a player whose energy and upside always made him a fascinating fit, the debate now says as much about the fan base as it does about the roster. [Read more 🡒]