The Yankees don’t need another reminder that the catching situation was shaky for most of the season. They need a real partner for Austin Wells.
Wells finished strong enough to steady his spot, but the bigger picture still screams for help. He caught 122 of the Yankees’ 161 games this year, which marked the second straight season he carried that kind of workload.
That’s a lot to ask from one player, especially when the backup options gave the club next to nothing. J.C.
Escarra and Ali Sanchez barely moved the needle, and Sanchez in particular was a liability both at the plate and behind it.
That overuse has mattered. Wells was behind the plate for 110 games in 2024, when Jose Trevino gave the Yankees a workable backup.
He also finished that season as a finalist for AL Rookie of the Year. This year, the second-half bounce-back was encouraging, but the lesson is obvious: the Yankees can’t keep running him out there every day and expecting the offense to stay sharp.
The good news is the market should look a lot better this winter. There are 14 free-agent catchers available, and most of them hit from the right side. That gives the Yankees a much cleaner path to finding someone who can split time with Wells, or at least lighten the load.
Ryan Jeffers is the clear headliner. The Yankees have already been tied to him in trade rumors, and he would bring the most upside of anyone on the market. The 29-year-old was limited to 92 games because of a fractured hamate bone, but he still put together one of his best offensive seasons, batting .256/.353/.461 with 14 home runs and a 128 wRC+.
Jeffers still has work to do defensively, but his framing has improved, and his connection to Tanner Swanson, the Yankees’ catching coordinator, could help that progress continue. He has also crushed lefties in his career, posting a .270/.365/.464 line against southpaws.
That makes him a clean fit next to Wells. With Jeffers’ experience as a starter, the Yankees could realistically divide the job and let Wells breathe a little.
Carson Kelly would be another strong fit if he reaches the market. He has a mutual option with the Chicago Cubs for 2027, but those options often don’t get picked up, so the Yankees should be ready to pounce if he becomes available.
The 32-year-old was excellent against left-handed pitching, hitting .298/.375/.496 with a 143 wRC+, and he brought solid defense as well. He also stood out in ABS challenges, something Wells does too.
Kelly handled a starter’s workload with the Cubs over the last two seasons, so signing him would mean fewer reps for Wells. But that’s not a bad outcome. The Yankees need a catcher who can help keep Wells fresh and bring some veteran stability to the position.
Kyle Higashioka is the reunion angle. He also has a mutual option for 2027, but a return to the Yankees would make sense.
At 36, he’d bring familiarity with the organization and Gerrit Cole, which should make the transition to a new pitching staff easier. He’s still not much of a bat, but he can still leave the yard now and then, and he’s posted a .420 slugging percentage over the three seasons since leaving the Bronx.
Of the names here, Higashioka offers the least upside. He wouldn’t take much of the burden off Wells, either. Even so, he’d be a clear upgrade over a minor league journeyman like Ali Sanchez.
Then there’s Gary Sanchez, who would bring a different kind of fit altogether. A return to New York as Wells’ backup would give the Yankees a much more dangerous offensive tandem.
Sanchez’s defense remains a concern, but his 2025 season with the Milwaukee Brewers has been productive because of much better plate discipline. In 275 plate appearances, he has hit .209 with a .349 on-base percentage, walked 46 times, and cut his chase rate to 23%.
The power is still there, too, with nearly half of his hits going for extra bases, including 12 home runs.
That kind of right-handed pop would change the look of the catching group. And because Sanchez would be backing up Wells rather than carrying the full load, the Yankees could choose offense or defense depending on the matchup. Sanchez also has a mutual option for 2027, though it’s unlikely the Brewers would exercise it.
The Yankees missed out on catching help at the trade deadline. This winter, they should have a much better chance to fix it.
In Other News...
Yankees Exit Reopened A Painful Debate About Two Players They Gave Up On
The Yankees exit in the American League Division Series brought an old front-office question right back to the surface: what happens when a club moves on from players who still have something left to give? After being swept by Tampa Bay and pushed to the brink in a 4-3 Game 3 loss, the conversation around the roster quickly widened beyond the immediate disappointment and back toward offseason decisions that now look a little different in hindsight.
Gary Sanchez and Randal Grichuk both found new opportunities after leaving New York, and both ended up in situations where they contributed for other teams. Sanchez went to Milwaukee and made himself part of a postseason run, while Grichuk landed with Chicago and settled into a useful platoon role. For the Yankees, those outcomes only sharpen the debate over whether they gave up on two players too soon, especially with the season ending the way it did. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Icon Just Called Out What This Club Has Been Missing
The Yankees latest postseason disappointment only deepened a familiar frustration, as their sweep at the hands of the Rays left them staring at a 17th straight season without a World Series title. For a franchise that still measures itself against the legends who built its reputation, the gap between the pinstriped past and the present has become part of the conversation again.
Former Yankees ace CC Sabathia added his voice to that discussion, arguing that the club is missing the kind of internal pressure and presence that once came from former franchise icons around the team. Sabathia suggested the Yankees could benefit from bringing those figures back into the fold, believing their presence would help reset the culture and sharpen the standard inside the organization. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Judge Now Sits At Center Of A Yankees Accountability Fight
The Yankees season ended with an American League Division Series sweep, and Aaron Judge watched it from the sideline after a right calf strain kept him out of the playoffs. Even so, the captain still ended up at the center of the postmortem, because his comments after the loss pushed the conversation toward the state of the roster and what the front office needs to do next.
Aaron Judge was named captain in December 2022, so his voice carries more weight than most in the organization, and that has only sharpened the scrutiny after another short October stay. While some of the criticism has focused on his leadership and the tone inside the clubhouse, Judges public stance has stayed pointed at personnel rather than coaching, leaving the Yankees with an accountability debate that is still very much alive. [Read more 🡒]