Yankees Face One Catcher Problem As Austin Wells Plans Take Shape

The Yankees face a challenging dilemma as they attempt to bolster their catching roster by persuading free agent Carson Kelly to consider a platoon role despite his preference for a starting position.

The Yankees are looking for help behind the plate, but the catcher they’ve targeted may want more than New York is prepared to give.

Carson Kelly has emerged as a possible right-handed complement to Austin Wells, giving the Yankees a potential answer to a very specific problem: Wells’ struggles against left-handed pitching. The fit is obvious on paper. The complication is that Kelly may be chasing something bigger than a platoon role.

New York’s plan is to improve the catching position without pushing aside Wells, who is still under team control. That leaves the Yankees trying to thread a narrow needle - enough playing time to attract a veteran, but not so much that they abandon the catcher they already have.

That tension matters with the anticipated Dec. 1 labor stoppage approaching. If talks drag on, Brian Cashman could be forced to move on before the offseason market freezes.

Ken Rosenthal pointed to the key issue Thursday while evaluating Kelly’s fit with the Yankees. The bat is useful. The question is whether the role is.

“The question is whether Kelly would want to platoon with Wells when he might land an everyday job with another club,” Rosenthal wrote.

Rosenthal also noted that New York’s appeal, along with the chance to pick up more starts, could shape Kelly’s decision. That is a different situation from any demand that Wells be benched or traded.

Kelly became available after the Cubs chose not to keep him on a mutual option. He declined his side of a $7.5 million option after finishing a two-year, $11.5 million deal.

The appeal is easy to see in the numbers. Kelly, 32, hit .258 with 10 home runs, 58 RBIs and a .712 OPS in 121 games in 2026. Against left-handed pitching, though, he was much more dangerous: .298 with a .375 on-base percentage, .496 slugging percentage and .871 OPS in 121 at-bats, plus six home runs.

That’s exactly the kind of profile the Yankees are after. Wells hit .186 with a .292 on-base percentage and .332 slugging percentage in 2026, and his second-half work against lefties was also poor. New York has a clear need for a bat that can handle southpaws.

If Kelly signed, Aaron Boone could deploy him against left-handed starters while keeping Wells in the lineup against right-handers. The arrangement would also give the Yankees a more proven insurance option over the course of a 162-game season.

But that same setup is what could scare Kelly away. He logged 425 plate appearances in 2026, and a strict platoon in New York could mean far fewer chances if Wells remains the main catcher against righties.

For a veteran, that’s not a small detail. It affects production, leverage and future opportunities.

There is still a middle ground. The Yankees could open the season with Wells handling most right-handed matchups and Kelly taking the lefties, then let performance, defense and workload shape the split from there. That would give Kelly a path to more work without forcing New York to change its plan for Wells before spring training.

Defensively, the picture is less clean. Wells has value as a pitch framer, while Kelly’s 2026 fielding run value and framing numbers were slightly below average. So the Yankees would be buying a matchup upgrade more than an across-the-board defensive upgrade.

For now, the Yankees are left weighing their options: make Kelly an offer that matches his value, sell him on the chance to earn more starts, or pivot to another catcher who is more willing to accept a defined backup job. As of Nov. 22, Kelly is still on the market, and New York’s interest has not yet turned into a deal.

In Other News...

Yankees Face A Bullpen Decision That Could Shape Their Offseason

The Yankees have already started reshaping the back end of their bullpen by agreeing to terms with left-handed reliever Tim Hill, and the work does not figure to stop there. With relief depth always a priority in New York, the club is still weighing how aggressively to pursue more help, especially with free agency offering a few different ways to add another late-inning arm.

Adrian Morejon is on the radar, but his qualifying offer complicates the equation, and there is also a case for a different route if the Yankees want to prioritize depth over a single splashier move. Jason Adam has emerged as an appealing alternative in that discussion, with the decision coming down to contract expectations, health history and how the Yankees want their bullpen to look by the time camp opens. [Read more 🡒]

Yankees Fans Have Every Right To Be Embarrassed By This Triple-A Rollout

The Yankees Triple-A affiliate has a new identity, and it comes with a heavy dose of franchise nostalgia. Scranton/Wilkes-Barre is now the Highlanders, a name that nods both to the Pennsylvania highlands and to the Yankees own early days from 1903 to 1912, giving the club a built-in historical hook as it tries to refresh its brand.

The rollout, though, did not exactly land the way the organization probably hoped. The team unveiled an AI-created promotional video featuring its mascot and historical imagery, and the reaction on social media was immediate and negative, with fans taking aim at the production quality as much as the concept itself. For a fan base already frustrated with the broader direction of the Yankees, from ownership concerns to recent on-field disappointment, even a minor-league rebrand became another easy target. [Read more 🡒]

Jasson Dominguez Just Made The Yankees Outfield Crunch Even Tougher

Jasson Domnguezs winter work in the Dominican Republic has only sharpened the conversation around his place in the Yankees plans. After a stretch that has him hitting .375 with a 1.146 OPS in 11 games, the 22-year-old has drawn notice beyond the organization, with general manager Brian Cashman acknowledging that other clubs have taken interest as the Yankees continue sorting through their outfield picture.

For New York, the issue is not whether Domnguez has talent, but how that talent fits into a crowded mix. He is still working through defensive questions and his struggles against left-handed pitching remain part of the evaluation, which makes his path to steady playing time far from simple. The Yankees are weighing his market appeal at a time when roster decisions are already complicated, and while no formal trade offers have been announced, the attention around him is only adding another layer to the outfield crunch. [Read more 🡒]