The Yankees’ annual search for more contact and less swing-and-miss has reached the point where Luis Arraez keeps floating to the top of the conversation. This time, though, the timing is all wrong.
New York’s lineup issues have become impossible to ignore, especially after what the club just did in the ALDS. The Brewers are also giving the Dodgers a headache with a smaller-ball style that has drawn praise from Derek Jeter, who called it “this is the way baseball is supposed to be played.” And with another October flop fresh in the memory bank, the pressure to rethink the roster is only growing.
That said, the Yankees have rarely been eager to make the kind of wholesale shift that would prioritize batting average and contact over power. Part of that has been a lack of suitable options.
Part of it has been the organization’s long trust in the idea that power wins out in the end. The problem, of course, is that postseason series don’t always give that theory enough time to prove itself.
This winter does offer New York a real opening. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a free agent, and his postseason performance did little to make the Yankees feel like they have to bring him back. In fact, the criticism surrounding the second baseman has become hard to separate from the room he plays in.
That’s why Arraez keeps coming up. He fits the contact-first mold, he can play the same position, and he gives the Yankees the kind of profile they’ve been accused of ignoring for years.
On paper, it looks neat. In reality, it looks dangerous.
Arraez has been a favorite target for Yankees fans and plenty of analysts for a while now, and the calls only got louder around the trade deadline. But the fit now is very different from the fit a year ago.
Then, bringing him in would have required a messy rearrangement. Now there’s an opening.
Even so, Brian Cashman ought to walk away.
The market is going to treat Arraez better this time than it did last winter, when a player with four All-Star nods, two Silver Slugger awards, and three batting titles had to settle for a one-year, $12 million deal. That was actually less than the $14 million he earned in his final year of arbitration, and it came after he’d already been traded three times.
This offseason, the price should climb. Spotrac has his value at three years and $54 million, and a thin free-agent class could push that number higher.
If Chisholm is gone, the Yankees will have even more reason to look at him. But that doesn’t mean they should.
The concern starts with what Arraez already was before this year: a defender who had earned a reputation as a butcher in the field and eventually moved off second base. Under Ron Washington with the Giants, he became a solid defender, but that improvement didn’t hold once he was dealt to the Phillies.
The bat didn’t hold up either. In Philadelphia, he hit .278/.309/.369, which worked out to a wRC+ of 82.
And that is the whole issue with Arraez. His value lives almost entirely in those singles that sneak through the infield or drop in front of outfielders.
He doesn’t walk, he doesn’t bring power, he offers no speed, and his defensive impact has always been limited. When the hits aren’t falling, there isn’t much else carrying him.
A one-year gamble? Maybe.
A multi-year commitment that starts creeping toward $20 million annually? That’s where the warning lights come on.
The Yankees do need balance, but Arraez is not the answer they’ve been waiting for.
In Other News...
Yankees May Have Finally Found A Ryan McMahon Trade Path
Ryan McMahons first Yankees season did not go the way anyone in the organization imagined. He struggled at third base both at the plate and in the field, and with one year left on his contract, the Yankees are already being pushed to think about what comes next rather than waiting for the fit to improve on its own. If they are going to move him, they will need a partner willing to take on a short-term answer at the hot corner, which narrows the field quickly.
The Cardinals may offer that kind of opening, since they have shown interest in a short-term third baseman. That does not mean a deal is close, but it does give the Yankees a plausible trade path if they decide to move on from McMahon, and any discussion would likely center on whether a return piece such as catcher Pedro Pages could be part of the conversation. For now, it is still mostly a framework for a deal rather than a finished one, but it is at least the sort of framework New York has been looking for. [Read more 🡒]
Jazz Chisholms Old Feud Just Gave Yankees Fans Another Reason To React
Jazz Chisholm Jr. has dragged an old clubhouse grievance back into the spotlight, saying Miguel Rojas once destroyed his custom cleats during their shared time with the Miami Marlins as part of hazing. Rojas has since addressed the allegation without exactly disputing it, saying he would rather keep those kinds of matters private. It is the sort of off-field dustup that still has a way of following players long after they leave the same room.
Now Rojas has given Yankees fans another reason to take notice after showing up in custom cleats celebrating the Dodgers back-to-back championships and nodding toward a possible third straight title. For a New York fan base that is always watching the other contenders, and especially one with Chisholm now in pinstripes, the timing adds a little extra edge to a relationship that already carried some baggage. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Once Had A Future Brewers October Threat In Their Hands
Jake Bauers was one of those low-key Yankees acquisitions that looked more like a depth move than a long-term piece, but he made enough noise in 2023 to get noticed. After a strong start in Triple-A, he brought some power and patience to the plate in pinstripes, giving New York a useful left-handed bat before the club moved on from him the following offseason.
The Yankees sent Bauers to Milwaukee in a trade for Brian Sanchez and Jace Avina, and the Brewers have since gotten the better end of the deal in the short term. Bauers has fit well in Milwaukee and even chipped in during the 2024 National League Championship Series, with a free-agent decision looming next and a reminder that a player New York once had in hand could end up mattering on a bigger October stage. [Read more 🡒]