The Yankees have enough rotation depth to make rival clubs pay attention this winter, but if they’re going to move one of those arms, Ryan Weathers should be the one they think twice about.
New York enters the offseason with a pile of starting options. Cam Schlittler, Gerrit Cole, Max Fried and Carlos Rodon form the top of the group, while Will Warren and Weathers give the club another pair of usable fifth-starter types.
Behind them, Elmer Rodriguez and Carlos Lagrange add even more cost-controlled pitching. That kind of surplus gives the Yankees room to shop for help elsewhere, whether that means the lineup or the bullpen.
Still, Weathers stands out from the rest of the depth chart. He was the best of those extra arms, and that’s why the Yankees should not only keep him, but pencil him into the 2027 rotation.
That’s not to say he won’t draw interest. During his 2026 breakout, Weathers kept coming up as a possible trade chip before the August 3 deadline. The 26-year-old left-hander remains a valuable piece, and Texas Rangers beat reporter Evan Grant even pointed to him as part of a hypothetical Corey Seager deal between the Yankees and Rangers.
Ryan Weathers and Anthony Volpe have been cited as potential trade chips in a Corey Seager trade, according to @Evan_P_Grant #Yankees pic.twitter.com/V9rKCxcP0l
But the Yankees would be smart to resist the urge to deal him. Weathers not only posted the best season of his career, he did it while helping patch over injuries to others in the rotation.
Of New York’s top four starters in 2026, Schlittler was the only one who stayed healthy all year, which only added to his case as the team’s MVP. Cole missed the first month while finishing his recovery from Tommy John surgery.
Fried went on the injured list twice because of a bone bruise in his elbow. Rodon also missed time with elbow inflammation.
The latest Fried update only reinforces how valuable that extra pitching is. The Yankees recently announced that Fried had surgery to remove a bone spur in his elbow. He’s expected to be ready for Spring Training, but the fact remains that the club already had to navigate a rotation full of absences.
Max Fried has a bone spur removed from his elbow and will undergo six weeks of recovery but is expected to be ready by spring training whenever it starts
Weathers has had injury issues of his own. He missed substantial time in both 2024 and 2025, then landed on the IL with a flexor strain on August 23. He didn’t return until the postseason, and when he did, it was as a reliever.
When he was on the mound, though, he was a real difference-maker. Weathers logged 137.1 innings, more than 40 above his previous career high.
He struck out 143 batters and walked only 38. He also got better as the year went on.
Over his final nine starts before the injury, he threw 49.0 innings with a 2.76 ERA and 2.71 FIP, while striking out 45 and walking 13. Home runs were his biggest issue across the season, as he allowed 18, but in that nine-start stretch he gave up only two. That improvement appears tied to a shift in approach, with Weathers using his four-seam fastball less often and leaning more on the rest of his mix.
Ryan Weathers has allowed only 3 runs in his last 5 starts (31.2 IP).(via @realapp) pic.twitter.com/KzmZDrisBX
That late-season run mattered because it helped cover for the absences of Rodon and Fried. Rodon was out from June 30 to Aug. 18, while Fried returned on July 22 and made only five starts before going back on the IL.
Losing both lefties could have blown up the Yankees’ rotation, but Weathers helped keep things steady. By the time he went down himself, Rodon had just returned and Fried was only about a week away from coming back.
The Fried surgery is expected to be a short-term issue, but it still serves as a reminder of how quickly a rotation can be tested. That’s exactly why a pitcher like Weathers matters so much.
The Yankees should absolutely deal from their pitching surplus if it helps them upgrade the roster. But unless another club is ready to offer a true game-changing piece, Weathers is the arm New York should keep.
In Other News...
Brewers Face A Big Bullpen Question As Yankees Search For Help
The Yankees have made it clear that bullpen help sits near the top of their offseason checklist, and Brian Cashmans front office is already being tied to one of the more practical options on the market. New York extended a qualifying offer to free agent closer David Bednar, a move that keeps the door open while also signaling how seriously the club is treating the late innings heading into next season.
Meanwhile, a trade idea has surfaced that would send Brewers closer Trevor Megill to the Bronx as a more affordable alternative to bringing Bednar back. Milwaukee has its own bullpen question to sort through, which is why this kind of discussion has started to pick up, even if nothing official is in motion yet. For the Yankees, the appeal is obvious: they need relief help, and they may have to decide whether to pay for a familiar name or pivot to a cheaper path. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Cost Cutting Raises A Bigger Question About Real Change
The Yankees have started the offseason by trimming a couple of familiar front-office roles, deciding not to renew the contracts of senior advisers Brian Sabean and Omar Minaya as financial pressures push the club to discontinue those advisory positions. It is a notable shift for a franchise that has long preferred to project stability and resources, even as it now works within a budget for offseason transactions while labor uncertainty hangs over Major League Baseball.
Brian Cashman said other coaching decisions are still unresolved, including the hitting coach job, as the club continues to evaluate candidates. For a team coming off another year of scrutiny, the personnel moves matter not just for who is retained or removed, but for what they say about how far the Yankees are willing to go in rethinking the way they operate. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Face A Familiar Second Base Dilemma They Never Fully Solved
The Yankees are already sorting through a second base question for 2027, and it has a familiar feel to it. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is in the mix as a free agent option, while Anthony Volpe remains part of the internal conversation, but the early discussion also has brought back a name the club knows well in Gleyber Torres, now a free agent after two seasons with Detroit.
Torres gives New York something it has long valued in the middle infield: offense. The catch is the same one that followed him before, since the Yankees would have to balance that bat against his defensive limitations and whatever positional flexibility he might still offer. It leaves the front office weighing whether a reunion makes sense, or whether the better answer is still somewhere else on the roster or market. [Read more 🡒]