Jazz Chisholm Jr. has reached the point of the season where every at-bat feels like part of a much bigger conversation.
The Yankees came into 2026 with real expectations for him after last year’s 30/30 season, and Chisholm had even bigger numbers in mind. A 50/50 year was the target. At the All-Star break, that idea is gone, and the more immediate question is simpler: can he even finish as a league-average hitter?
That matters because Chisholm is heading toward free agency this winter, and the Yankees still haven’t opened extension talks with him. He has been candid about the possibility of a new deal, and when asked by NJ.com's Randy Miller in February what he was looking for, he said it was somewhere between eight and 10 years at $35 million per season.
That kind of price tag looks awfully steep now.
Chisholm’s line coming out of the break sits at .223/.303/.395 with a 95 wRC+. He has 13 home runs, 37 RBI and 26 stolen bases, but the deeper numbers have slipped too.
Baseball Savant has him at a 76th-percentile 90.7 mph average exit velocity, yet his .292 xwOBA, .211 xBA and .364 xSLG point to a bat that hasn’t been nearly as dangerous as it was a year ago. His 40.6% hard-hit rate and 8.8% barrel rate are solid, but not the kind of impact marks that scream star-level production.
That’s a sharp drop from last season, when Chisholm’s 15% barrel rate ranked in the 91st percentile in baseball. He was one of the sport’s better ball-crushers then. This year, that edge hasn’t been there nearly as often.
And yet, even with the bat lagging, Chisholm has still found ways to matter.
His athleticism has been the biggest plus. He has eight outs above average at second base, and Baseball Savant has him in the 97th percentile in Baserunning Run Value.
That speed and burst help explain why he still sits at 2.1 WAR, according to Fangraphs. Among second basemen, that ranks sixth in baseball, behind names including Luis Arráez, Brice Turang and Xavier Edwards.
The broader Yankees sample on Chisholm is still pretty strong, too. Since coming over in a trade at the 2024 deadline, he’s hit .241/.321/.456 with a 117 wRC+, along with 55 homers, 140 RBI and 75 stolen bases. His 117 wRC+ is tied for second with Gleyber Torres among second basemen over that span, and his 8.8 WAR as a Yankee is the first since the trade.
That’s the tension in this whole situation. The Yankees have seen the version of Chisholm that can change a game with one swing or one burst on the bases, and they’ve also seen the version that makes you wonder how much to trust the package long term.
The market for a second baseman with that kind of value has precedent. Marcus Semien was the last one to hit free agency with comparable value at the position, and he landed a seven-year, $175 million deal with the Rangers in December 2021. That contract has since aged poorly and eventually led to his being traded to the Mets this past offseason.
Whether the Yankees would go anywhere near that territory with Chisholm after a down year is another matter entirely. Their handling of Trent Grisham offers a clue. Even after Grisham’s extraordinary season last year, the Yankees gave him the qualifying offer, and it’s fair to wonder whether they would have gone to a multi-year deal if he had reached the open market.
Chisholm is likely to get the same qualifying offer next season, though the looming lockout throws a wrinkle into everything. There may not even be a season next year, which makes the whole contract picture murkier than usual.
For now, the focus is on what he can still do over the final 71 games. He’s a little below league average at the plate right now, but there’s still time to move that number. A 20/20 finish is still on the table, and if he can close with a wRC+ somewhere between 100 and 110, the way the Yankees and the rest of the league view him will look a lot different than it does today.
He also fills a need while Judge is out, and he’s been vocal in the clubhouse, saying the team needs to play better. The Yankees responded before the break. Now Chisholm’s bat has to keep pace if he wants to strengthen his case for staying in the Bronx.
That’s why his second half looms so large. The numbers he posts from here on out will shape not just the Yankees’ playoff push, but the conversation around his next contract, too.
In Other News...
Yankees Suddenly Look Like They Won The Oswald Peraza Trade
Oswald Perazas move out of the Yankees organization looked like the kind of swap that could be judged over time, and for a while it at least had some early intrigue. He opened the season with a strong stretch against his former club, while the return piece, Wilberson De Pea, was still building his case in the minors and trying to show that the Yankees had not simply moved on from one young infielder for nothing.
De Pea has since given the Yankees plenty to like. The prospect has climbed into the upper tier of the system, now sitting 12th in the Yankees rankings, and his appeal is easy to see in the power and exit velocity that have stood out in the lower minors. For New York, the deal suddenly looks less like a clean break and more like a bet that may already be tilting in the organizations favor, even if the full verdict still has some runway left. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Got Teasing Trade News On A Potential Bullpen Game Changer
The Yankees are still in the thick of the American League East race, but sitting three games back has only sharpened the focus on the trade deadline. At 54-42, they have every reason to keep looking for bullpen help, and the latest chatter suggests they could be in the market for a late-inning arm if the right deal comes together.
One possible fit has already started to generate buzz, with San Diego emerging as a team that could listen if the price is high enough. The catch, of course, is that any move for a reliever of that caliber would likely require a significant return, which is why this feels more like an early signal than a deal on the verge of getting done. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Linked To A Shortstop Gamble Fans Will Instantly Debate
Anthony Volpe is still holding down the Yankees shortstop job, but the conversation around him has only gotten louder. His offensive production and work in the field have drawn plenty of criticism, even as Derek Jeter has said the Yankees are high on Volpes potential and willing to bet on the upside that made him such a prominent part of their future plans.
Not everyone sees that patience as a virtue. Adam Schein has been openly skeptical about whether Volpe is ready for the majors, and the chatter has only sharpened as rival clubs start to enter the picture in trade speculation. With Jose Caballero having looked like an upgrade at shortstop, the Yankees are at least facing a real question about how long they can keep treating Volpe as untouchable. [Read more 🡒]