David Bednar’s first full season in pinstripes put him right where the Yankees hoped he’d be: among the offseason’s most coveted late-inning arms. The problem for New York is that keeping him won’t be simple.
Bednar enters free agency after converting 35 of 39 save chances in 2026, finishing with a 2.47 ERA, a 1.04 WHIP and 76 strikeouts over 69 1/3 innings. He also made a notable change to his mix, leaning harder on his splitter, which became his most effective pitch against hitters.
The Yankees have already put a $23.15 million qualifying offer on the table, and Bednar has until November 17 to accept it or chase a longer deal elsewhere. Retaining him remains a priority for general manager Brian Cashman, but there are several clubs that could make this a real fight.
Pittsburgh stands out as one of the most natural landing spots. Bednar spent most of his career there before the Pirates dealt him to New York at the 2025 deadline, and he built his reputation in Pittsburgh as one of the game’s steadiest closers. He made two All-Star teams and led the National League with 39 saves in 2023.
The Pirates also have reason to push for a reunion. They appear more committed to building around a young core that includes Konnor Griffin and Paul Skenes. With Skenes projected to hit free agency after the 2029 season, there is a clear window Pittsburgh will want to take advantage of while it still has one of baseball’s premier starters under team control.
Still, a return would not be easy. Mason Montgomery is already emerging in the ninth inning, and former Yankee Luke Weaver is also in the mix.
Even so, Bednar would deepen Pittsburgh’s late-game options in a major way. The real hurdle is the cost: the Pirates would have to pay a veteran reliever and also give up draft-pick compensation because of the qualifying offer.
For an organization that has often been cautious in free agency, that’s a tough ask.
Chicago could also be in the conversation. The Cubs finished 2026 with a 3.93 bullpen ERA, and their pitching staff could look very different next season. Shota Imanaga, Matthew Boyd, Clay Holmes, Kevin Gausman and David Peterson are all free agents, leaving the club with major questions in both the rotation and the bullpen.
The Cubs have already started to address relief depth by re-signing Jacob Webb, but Bednar would give them a proven ninth-inning option and let Daniel Palencia and Webb work in other high-leverage spots. The catch is obvious: Chicago is expected to spend heavily on starting pitching, so how much it wants to commit to the bullpen is the big question. If the goal is to boost postseason odds, Bednar would be a clear upgrade.
Detroit may offer the cleanest path to a full-time closing job. The Tigers had a rough year in the late innings, finishing 2026 with 31 blown saves before declining Kenley Jansen’s contract option. With Jansen gone and Will Vest’s recovery timeline uncertain, the need for a reliable closer is obvious.
The Tigers have already shown interest in Bednar. They explored a deal when Pittsburgh made him available at the 2025 deadline, but they never matched the Pirates’ asking price.
This time, they could pursue him without surrendering prospects. Money may not be the issue either, with significant salary coming off the books after the departures of Tarik Skubal, Kenley Jansen and Gleyber Torres.
Bednar would still be expensive, especially with draft-pick compensation attached, but Detroit may be better positioned to make that kind of move now.
Toronto shouldn’t be ruled out either, even with Louis Varland already in place as closer after finishing 2026 with 35 saves and a 1.27 ERA. The Blue Jays still need more stability in the bullpen, especially with Paul Sewald and Patrick Corbin headed for free agency.
Bednar’s splitter-heavy breakout in New York makes him a strong fit for that kind of bullpen rebuild. He threw the pitch 41.2% of the time in 2026, up from 19.7% in 2025, and opponents produced just a .353 OPS against it. That adjustment helped fuel one of the best seasons of his career.
If Toronto added him, it would give the club another high-leverage weapon alongside Varland and Tyler Rogers. The question, though, is whether Bednar would want a setup without a guaranteed path to saves.
The Yankees still have the edge of familiarity, and Bednar has already shown he can thrive in New York. But if this turns into a real bidding war, Cashman could be battling multiple teams for one of the offseason’s most dependable relievers.
In Other News...
Yankees Fans Will Hate What These 2027 Projections Suggest About Judge
Steamers early look at the Yankees 2027 lineup is the kind of projection that can make fans squirm, because it tries to map out where the offense might be headed long before that roster actually takes shape. Aaron Judge is still the centerpiece of the discussion, but the projection system sees a step back from his peak years, while younger names such as Ben Rice and Austin Wells are part of the broader picture of what the lineup could become if the clubs internal growth goes as hoped.
The catch, of course, is that these forecasts are built on algorithms, not certainty, and they tend to wobble the most when a player has limited data or a recent injury history. That leaves plenty of room for skepticism around the expected bumps for players like Ryan McMahon and Wells, and it also leaves open the larger question Yankees fans care about most: how much longer Judge can keep carrying the offense before the projection models stop believing in another big year. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Face Urgency As Late-Inning Bullpen Target Draws Rival Interest
With David Bednars free-agent decision deadline approaching, the Yankees are still weighing how much more certainty they want at the back of their bullpen. One name that has surfaced is Milwaukee closer Trevor Megill, who could fit as either a replacement plan or a late-inning partner if New York decides it needs more than one trusted arm to close games down the stretch.
The catch is that the Brewers are not the only ones watching. Milwaukee is said to be exploring trade possibilities for Megill even after its recent championship, and the Yankees are among several clubs in the mix, alongside Chicago, San Francisco and Detroit. One possible framework would send prospects Core Jackson and Carlos Lagrange to Milwaukee, but with interest building, New York may have to move quickly if it wants to stay in front of the market. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Risk Repeating A Bullpen Mistake With This Lefty Return
The Yankees have already started shaping their bullpen picture for next season, and the early signs point to a familiar balancing act. They extended a qualifying offer to David Bednar and have shown interest in bringing back Paul Blackburn and Ryan Yarbrough, while also keeping an eye on Tim Hill, the left-handed reliever who gave them useful innings before his performance tailed off in 2026.
Hill still has a clear lane against left-handed hitters, but his issues against right-handed batters became hard to ignore, and that was part of why he was left off the playoff roster. New York is weighing whether a reunion makes sense or whether it would be wiser to avoid leaning too heavily on a specialist whose effectiveness has become more limited, especially with other bullpen options still on the table. [Read more 🡒]