The Yankees are heading into another winter with the same old headache at catcher: an everyday option whose bat hasn’t delivered enough, and no easy answer for how to squeeze more offense out of the position.
Austin Wells’ 2026 season was rough. He hit .186 with 14 home runs, 32 RBIs and a .624 OPS, and his year was interrupted by time missed because of cervical headaches.
New York has also leaned on other left-handed catching options, including J.C. Escarra and Ben Rice, though Rice has spent much of his time at first base.
That setup has made it harder for the Yankees to play matchups without giving something else away in the lineup.
After the postseason exit, the focus sharpened on an offense that had trouble putting together sustained rallies. Catcher wasn’t the only issue, but it’s one area where a change could help Aaron Boone build more balanced lineups while still keeping Wells in the picture as a long-term piece.
Two names have surfaced as possible answers, and they point in very different directions: one is a bigger swing in the trade market, the other a cheaper free-agent fit built around platoon value.
Ivan Herrera is the more ambitious target. The Cardinals have been exploring the market for their catchers, and Herrera is among the names reportedly available as St.
Louis weighs its depth behind the plate. The Yankees had shown trade interest in him before the 2026 deadline, according to earlier reporting, but the Cardinals held onto him.
Herrera, 26, finished 2026 with a .241 average, 19 home runs, 69 RBIs, a .353 on-base percentage and a .735 OPS. He played 52 games at catcher and also logged plenty of time as a designated hitter.
One recently published hypothetical deal sends right-handers Carlos Lagrange and Thatcher Hurd, left-hander Kyle Carr and third baseman Ryan McMahon to St. Louis for Herrera and catcher Pedro Pagés. That is only a media proposal, not a confirmed offer or a real framework between the teams.
It would be a steep price for New York. Hurd and Carr would add two more arms to the package, while McMahon would give the Cardinals a third-base option. McMahon hit .213 with 11 home runs in 124 games in 2026 and is owed $16 million in 2027.
Luis Gil is another possible name for trade talk because St. Louis needs pitching, but he is not part of that published four-player proposal. There is no verified report saying the Yankees have put Gil into a Herrera deal.
Herrera is also under team control for three more seasons, which is a big reason the Cardinals could ask for a substantial return.
The other path is Jonah Heim, and it comes with a very different kind of appeal. Heim entered free agency after his 2026 season with Atlanta and the Athletics, and signing him would not require New York to part with young pitching.
His overall numbers last season were modest: .204 with 13 home runs and a .628 OPS. But the splits are what make him interesting for the Yankees.
Against left-handers, Heim hit .267 with 10 home runs and an .855 OPS. Against right-handers, he hit .160 with three home runs and a .471 OPS.
That 384-point OPS gap in 2026 is exactly the kind of split that can shape a platoon decision, even if it doesn’t promise the same production next year. Through seven big league seasons, Heim’s career OPS sits at .649.
He also brings a championship résumé. Heim was part of Texas’ 2023 World Series team, and that season he was an All-Star and Gold Glove winner while hitting .258 with 18 home runs and 95 RBIs.
Defensively, though, the picture is less clean. Herrera’s value is tied heavily to the bat, but any upgrade at catcher still depends on how much he can actually handle behind the plate rather than at DH.
Heim has the longer catching track record, yet his receiving numbers have slid. Statcast credited him with 12 framing runs in 2023, then minus-two in both 2025 and 2026.
His overall catching value dropped from plus-15 runs in 2023 to minus-one in 2026.
That leaves the Yankees with a real decision. A veteran brought in mainly to punish left-handed pitching still has to win over the pitching staff with his game-calling, blocking and control of the running game. And a second catcher doesn’t have to replace Wells to matter; it just has to give Boone more flexibility and better matchup options.
For now, New York is staring at two very different solutions to the same problem. Herrera would mean a bigger investment and a bigger swing.
Heim would be the cheaper route, with less prospect cost and more uncertainty. As of Nov. 4, there’s no agreement on either front.
In Other News...
Yankees Offseason Pivot Just Put Pressure On Their Backup Plan
The Yankees offseason plans have already started to shift after their qualifying-offer decisions, and the ripple effect is easy to see in the way they are reworking their target board. By extending one to David Bednar instead of Jazz Chisholm Jr., the club altered its flexibility in free agency and now has to map out other ways to address the roster, from the infield to the bullpen to the lineup.
That has pushed New York toward a different tier of options, with Tyler Stephenson drawing attention behind the plate, Alex Vesia standing out as a left-handed relief possibility and Luis Arraez lingering as a fit at second base. Tyrone Taylor also has emerged as a more affordable alternative to Seiya Suzuki, a reminder that the Yankees may need to balance ambition with practicality as they sort through a backup plan that suddenly matters a lot more. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Predicted Catcher Signing Could Change The Plan For Austin Wells
The Yankees have spent enough time looking at the catcher spot to know the fit has not been ideal, especially when left-handed pitching shows up and the offense gets squeezed. With no right-handed-hitting option in the mix, the position has been a clear area for improvement, and Bleacher Reports Tim Kelly sees a possible answer in Ryan Jeffers, whom he projects to land a three-year deal with New York.
Jeffers would bring the kind of offensive upside the Yankees have been missing behind the plate, even if the defensive profile is not as clean. His arrival would also ripple beyond the immediate upgrade, because it could alter how the club maps out Austin Wells and the rest of the catching picture as the Yankees try to balance production now with the long-term plan. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Culture Debate Just Took Another Turn After Viral Criticism
The Yankees clubhouse culture has been back in the spotlight since Milwaukee Brewers manager Pat Murphys comments about the team went viral during the World Series. Murphy later said he reached out to general manager Brian Cashman to explain what he meant, stressing that the remarks were tied to a long-running joke with first baseman Jake Bauers rather than a broader shot at the 2026 Yankees.
Even so, the episode kept a familiar talking point alive around New York, where any criticism of the organization tends to carry extra weight after a disappointing postseason. Murphys explanation may have softened the edges of the original video, but it also underscored how quickly a casual aside can turn into another debate about the Yankees identity, and why the reaction around it has lingered. [Read more 🡒]