The Red Sox and Yankees are almost back at it, and Tuesday brings a fresh shot at settling the score. Boston gets its chance in the Bronx after spending a full year with the memory of Cam Schlittler shutting them down in a winner-take-all Game 3 at Yankee Stadium. This time, the rematch comes in the same best-of-three setup, which makes the matchup easy to slice up one spot at a time.
At catcher, the edge goes to Boston. Even if Rutschman hasn’t been All-Star caliber since the trade, he’s light years better offensively than Wells. And after homering on Sunday, he could be carrying a little momentum into New York.
First base tilts to the Yankees, but only because of the way the matchup can play out. If the Red Sox are facing Goldschmidt, that means a lefty is on the mound and one or two of the Yankees’ best bats are out of the lineup. Even so, the nod goes to the slugger who’s carried Boston all year, even while playing hurt.
At second base, Chisholm gets the call. There are three players in this group who can all help their team steal a game, but only one brings the two-way talent to take over a contest. Even with injury concerns and a down year, he gets the edge.
Shortstop belongs to the Yankees, and this one is more about current form than future projections. If this were a debate about next season, it would be a layup for New York. It’s tighter now because of Lombard’s inexperience, but he still earns the nod because he’s been hitting the cover off the ball lately.
Third base goes to Boston. Caballero deserves credit for the way he can affect a game with speed and defense, but Durbin can do those things too, and he’s the steadier offensive player.
In left field, the Yankees have the advantage. Roman Anthony might have a case for Boston, but Bellinger’s All-Star status and comfort hitting at Yankee Stadium make this one straightforward.
Center field is another Boston spot, with one big caveat: Rafaela may be dealing with a banged-up leg. Still, he’s so reliable defensively that it’s tough to go with Jones, the high-upside rookie who also comes with plenty of strikeouts.
Right field also goes to Boston. Abreu made a real statement this year by hitting lefties better than righties, which makes it all the more striking that he was benched in the first two games of this series last year for Nate Eaton.
Then comes the star power, and that’s where New York pulls ahead. It’s almost absurd to say “it doesn’t matter if Aaron Judge is involved,” but the clear advantage still belongs to the Yankees.
On the mound, the Red Sox deserve credit for going out and getting Gray and Suárez for games like this. Boston is glad it did after what those two turned in this year. But on paper, that still falls short of Schlittler, the presumptive Cy Young winner, and two veterans with nine All-Star selections between them.
The bullpen comparison is tight enough to make Boston feel good about its group. Go look up what Headrick is doing this year in the Bronx. Even so, Chapman and Whitlock are the kind of arms you trust when everything is on the line, and that could be true for both of them multiple times this week.
Final tally: Red Sox 6, Yankees 5 (not indicative of a series prediction)
In Other News...
Cam Schlittler Just Added More Heat To Yankees Red Sox Tension
Cam Schlittler has already learned that anything he says online can ripple far beyond the app, especially when the Yankees and Red Sox are involved. In an interview with Brendan Kuty of The Athletic, the young Yankees pitcher revisited the social media back-and-forth with Boston fans, including the deleted comment that briefly took on a life of its own after he responded to a Red Sox-themed podcast.
For a pitcher trying to settle into October baseball, the noise is part of the backdrop, but Schlittler made clear he is aware of how quickly those exchanges can sharpen the edge of the rivalry. He also pointed to past online run-ins as something he has used to fuel his work on the mound, which only adds another layer to a Yankees-Red Sox storyline that already tends to carry plenty of heat. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Have A Costly Roster Problem Fans Cant Ignore
The Yankees roster math has become hard to ignore, especially when so much money is tied up in players who have not given the lineup much return. A chunk of the 2026 salary ledger is already committed to DJ LeMahieu, Trent Grisham and Ryan McMahon, and FanGraphs metric has the trio combining for only 0.7 wins above replacement. For a team that always expects to contend, that kind of production from that kind of payroll space is exactly the sort of inefficiency that turns into a larger problem.
McMahons season has been the clearest example of the dilemma, with his offense lagging even as his glove kept him in the lineup, while LeMahieu was released in midseason with nearly $22 million still owed. Grisham, meanwhile, never quite matched last years level and also had a September injury stint to deal with. Put together, it has left the Yankees paying premium prices for very little margin for error, and the roster consequences are not going away anytime soon. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Got A Tougher ALWCS Opener Than Anyone Expected
Boston is turning to rookie Payton Tolle for Game 1 of the wild-card series against the Yankees, a choice that adds a fresh wrinkle to a matchup already loaded with October pressure. Tolle has been throwing well lately, and the Red Sox clearly see enough in the young left-hander to open the series with him, especially with New York carrying a lineup that leans heavily left-handed and may be without Aaron Judge.
If that plan holds, the Yankees are staring at a tougher opener than many expected, with the Red Sox lining up Sonny Gray in Game 2 and Ranger Suarez in Game 3. Gray gives Boston a veteran edge as the staff ace, while Suarez brings postseason experience, so New York will have to be ready for a series that could demand immediate adjustments rather than a slow feel-out period. [Read more 🡒]