The Yankees’ offseason checklist is already pretty clear: get better at putting the ball in play, clean up the defense, and stop living and dying with Aaron Judge.
That’s the shape of the problem after a 2026 season that ended with a sweep at the hands of the Rays in the ALDS. New York’s pitching held up as a strength all year, but the offense never found enough consistency outside of Judge, and the postseason only put a spotlight on how fragile the roster can look when things go sideways.
The front office has already made a few decisions that point toward change. Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Trent Grisham both hit free agency, moves that fit after neither player delivered as expected. The Yankees also gave David Bednar a qualifying offer, keeping the door open for him to remain with the club for another season if he accepts.
From there, the path forward gets more interesting. The Yankees’ biggest needs are in the middle of the diamond and at the plate, where contact and defense both need a serious upgrade.
The ALDS made the defensive issues impossible to ignore - three errors in the first inning of Game 2 was the kind of start that can bury a team fast - and the sloppy play kept showing up. That’s not new, either.
Defensive breakdowns have followed Aaron Boone’s teams for years, and if the Yankees want to be taken seriously as contenders, they have to clean that up.
They also need a lineup that can survive when Judge isn’t available. His injury hammered the team, and New York stumbled through the 95 games he spent on the injured list.
With Judge in the lineup, the Yankees were near the top of MLB in OPS. Without him, they dropped all the way to 29th.
That kind of fall-off is too steep for a team with championship ambitions.
At second base, the opening created by Chisholm’s departure gives the Yankees a chance to make a real upgrade. George Lombard Jr. is set to take over at shortstop and get his first full season there, but the second-base job should not simply be handed to Anthony Volpe after another rough year that sent him bouncing between Triple A and the majors. The better play is to shop for a replacement.
There are a few names that fit the bill. CJ Abrams moved to second base last season after a rough defensive stretch at shortstop, but he broke out offensively for the Nationals.
Ketel Marte, who has four years left on his deal with the Diamondbacks, could also be available, and Zach Neto is another option after an impressive offensive season with the Angels, even if his defense at shortstop wasn’t strong. Marte would be the safest defensive bet at second, though his periodic absences from Arizona and occasional lack of communication with the team are enough to raise a yellow flag, if not a red one.
Neto might be the better fit defensively at second, and his right-handed bat would also help a Yankees lineup that could use one.
If the trade market doesn’t cooperate, Luis Garcia Jr. is another possibility at second base, though he has not exactly thrived there before. Moving him there would create more chances for Ben Rice at DH, which could open the door for Giancarlo Stanton if he’s still around in ‘27, or allow Aaron Judge to spend more time there to help preserve his health. Even so, Garcia’s defensive track record makes that a risky route for a club already trying to fix its infield fundamentals.
Third base is another spot the Yankees need to address, and moving on from Ryan McMahon should be on the table. He’s heading into the final year of his contract and hasn’t hit enough since arriving in New York.
Last season, McMahon posted a .635 OPS with 11 home runs, 41 RBIs and 106 strikeouts over 124 games. His reputation has always leaned on the glove, but even there he was only average last season, and the bat never came close to making up the difference.
His total value came out to 0.0 bWAR, and he’s due $16 million in ‘27. If another team is willing to take that on, the Yankees should be ready to move.
Isaac Paredes would make sense as a replacement. He brings real right-handed pop, with 25 home runs and an .806 OPS last season, and while he’s not a standout defender at third, he can handle the position. Statcast had both Paredes and McMahon at a fielding run value of 0 to finish ‘26, but the offensive gap between them would be a major win for New York.
If Paredes costs too much, Zack Gelof is another name to watch. The 27-year-old had a strong year at the plate for the Athletics and is roughly average defensively. He hit 22 home runs in 111 games, though the strikeouts are part of the package, and that’s not exactly ideal for a Yankees team that finished with the sixth-most strikeouts in MLB.
Center field is the other major hole. Grisham’s season was rough by the numbers - among 41 qualified center fielders in ‘26, he ranked 40th with -6 outs above average and -5 runs prevented - and the eye test didn’t help much either. He wasn’t a burner, and there were too many plays where he seemed indifferent tracking down balls, especially on shallow chances.
Spencer Jones could get the first crack at the job. He finished the season strong, putting up a .763 OPS with nine home runs, 33 RBIs and nine stolen bases over his final 56 games. His speed stands out for a player his size, but the strikeouts are loud - 36.3% is a tough number to ignore - and he’s not a sure thing defensively in center.
If Jones doesn’t look like the answer, the Yankees may need to go shopping again. Steven Kwan is one name that fits what they need.
He’s entering his final year of arbitration with the Guardians, and he checks a lot of boxes: elite defense, very few strikeouts and excellent speed. He’d also come with a hefty price tag, but he’d help patch several of the Yankees’ biggest weaknesses at once.
In Other News...
Yankees Fans Will Hate What These 2027 Projections Suggest About Judge
Steamers early look at the Yankees 2027 lineup is the kind of projection that can make fans squirm, because it tries to map out where the offense might be headed long before that roster actually takes shape. Aaron Judge is still the centerpiece of the discussion, but the projection system sees a step back from his peak years, while younger names such as Ben Rice and Austin Wells are part of the broader picture of what the lineup could become if the clubs internal growth goes as hoped.
The catch, of course, is that these forecasts are built on algorithms, not certainty, and they tend to wobble the most when a player has limited data or a recent injury history. That leaves plenty of room for skepticism around the expected bumps for players like Ryan McMahon and Wells, and it also leaves open the larger question Yankees fans care about most: how much longer Judge can keep carrying the offense before the projection models stop believing in another big year. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Face Urgency As Late-Inning Bullpen Target Draws Rival Interest
With David Bednars free-agent decision deadline approaching, the Yankees are still weighing how much more certainty they want at the back of their bullpen. One name that has surfaced is Milwaukee closer Trevor Megill, who could fit as either a replacement plan or a late-inning partner if New York decides it needs more than one trusted arm to close games down the stretch.
The catch is that the Brewers are not the only ones watching. Milwaukee is said to be exploring trade possibilities for Megill even after its recent championship, and the Yankees are among several clubs in the mix, alongside Chicago, San Francisco and Detroit. One possible framework would send prospects Core Jackson and Carlos Lagrange to Milwaukee, but with interest building, New York may have to move quickly if it wants to stay in front of the market. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Risk Repeating A Bullpen Mistake With This Lefty Return
The Yankees have already started shaping their bullpen picture for next season, and the early signs point to a familiar balancing act. They extended a qualifying offer to David Bednar and have shown interest in bringing back Paul Blackburn and Ryan Yarbrough, while also keeping an eye on Tim Hill, the left-handed reliever who gave them useful innings before his performance tailed off in 2026.
Hill still has a clear lane against left-handed hitters, but his issues against right-handed batters became hard to ignore, and that was part of why he was left off the playoff roster. New York is weighing whether a reunion makes sense or whether it would be wiser to avoid leaning too heavily on a specialist whose effectiveness has become more limited, especially with other bullpen options still on the table. [Read more 🡒]