The Yankees may be heading back into familiar territory at the trade deadline, and this time the focus is squarely on third base.
A year after Brian Cashman swung a series of moves that brought in David Bednar, Camilo Doval, and Ryan McMahon, New York is once again being pushed toward the hot corner. That McMahon deal was supposed to settle the position. Instead, it has turned into a problem the Yankees now need to fix.
Joel Reuter of Bleacher Report pointed to third base as the club’s biggest deadline need, and the reasoning is hard to argue with. McMahon has not given the lineup enough, and his injury only makes the issue more obvious.
"Third base looks like the most glaring hole, with Ryan McMahon (202 PA, 74 OPS+) providing little impact and utility guys Amed Rosario and Jose Cabellera holding things down now that he is injured," Reuter writes.
The Yankees sit at 48-37 and have hit a rough patch lately. Even before McMahon landed on the injured list, he was not offering much help at the plate.
In 69 games and 186 at-bats, McMahon is hitting .210 with eight home runs and 23 RBIs. His .629 OPS tells the same story, and the 74 OPS+ Reuter cited means he has been 26 percent below league average as a hitter.
That is why third base is shaping up as the priority. Matt Chapman of the San Francisco Giants would be the splashier play, while Isaac Paredes of the Houston Astros looks like a more practical fit.
There is also another layer here: because Rosario and Cabellera can move around, the Yankees could target a shortstop or second baseman instead and shuffle the infield that way. The flexibility gives them options, but it does not change the fact that the offense needs a lift.
The long view points to the 2026 trade deadline, when the Yankees could try to land a true long-term answer at third and move on from McMahon. For now, though, the immediate goal is simpler: find a way to stabilize the hot corner and hope the returns of Aaron Judge, Trent Grisham, and Giancarlo Stanton help the offense click again.
In Other News...
Cody Bellinger Finally Addressed His Struggles As Yankees Pressure Mounts
Cody Bellinger has not hidden the frustration of a season that has not gone the way he or the Yankees wanted, and the timing has only made the pressure feel heavier. With New York sliding and captain Aaron Judge still sidelined, the club has been leaning on other bats to steady things while it waits for a healthier lineup to take shape.
Bellinger is one of the players the Yankees need to come through, especially with Judge not expected back until mid-August or early September. The stretch ahead will keep putting the spotlight on New Yorks offense, and on whether Bellinger can turn his own discomfort into something more productive as the team tries to stop the bleeding. [Read more 🡒]
Matt Chapman Looks Like The Yankees Fix Until New Trouble Emerged
The Yankees have been searching for help at third base while the club tries to stop a losing streak, and Matt Chapman has the kind of profile that naturally fits the conversation. He is an elite defender, he bats right-handed and he would give New York a proven answer at a spot that has been a concern, which is why his name has surfaced as a possible target from San Francisco.
Chapmans appeal comes with real complication, though, because the Giants third baseman is currently dealing with an abdominal strain that has been bothering him for weeks. Even before any trade talk gets serious, the injury adds a layer of uncertainty to a player the Yankees would like to evaluate as a fix, and the contract situation only makes the path more complicated for a team that needs immediate help rather than another long-running puzzle. [Read more 🡒]
Tigers Rotation Finally Hit A Wall Fans Never Saw Coming
The Tigers rotation had been rolling for weeks, with Jack Flaherty, Casey Mize, Tarik Skubal and rookie Troy Melton all helping turn the staff into one of the more dependable groups in the league. The recent run was built on length and efficiency, too, as Detroit had strung together four straight starts of at least five innings while allowing two or fewer hits in each outing.
Thursday brought a much different look, and it was enough to halt both streaks at once. Detroit gave up five earned runs on nine hits and two walks over five innings, ending a franchise-record run of 34 starts without a starter allowing more than four runs and reminding everyone how quickly even a hot rotation can run into trouble. [Read more 🡒]