Brian Cashman made three moves before the trade deadline, and each one came with a case for why it could help the Yankees. That’s the frustrating part. The bigger problem is what never happened: no catcher, no bullpen boost, and no final push that matched the size of the need.
The deadline opened with a clean break from Camilo Doval. On Aug. 1, the Yankees sent him to the Pittsburgh Pirates and brought back minor-league catcher Omar Alfonzo, MLB Pipeline’s No. 17, plus Luis Cruz.
That earns an A, because sometimes the smartest move is admitting the experiment isn’t working. Doval has the kind of stuff that can make him one of the game’s elite relievers, but it never really clicked in New York, where Yankee Stadium served as his 7.08 ERA home park.
Maybe Pittsburgh unlocks him. Maybe it happens somewhere else.
It just wasn’t happening here, and this move had to be made. The Yankees were targeting a high-power, low-hit catcher and a lottery ticket, and this was the right place to start.
A day later, the Yankees went after offense, landing Luis Garcia Jr. from the Washington Nationals for Ben Grable, Yovanny Cruz, Jack Cebert and Jake Bird. That gets a B+.
It’s hard to complain about adding pop to a lineup that needed it badly, especially with Garcia sitting atop the NL in slugging percentage, just ahead of Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman. He also brings the kind of edge and presence that can leave a mark in a clubhouse; he was Washington’s longest-tenured player at 26 years old.
But the fit is messy. Garcia pushes Paul Goldschmidt into a lefty-only role, which should at least help manage his workload, and he doesn’t bring much defensively.
He played first base in a pinch this year, and while he can hit, the move doesn’t exactly scream “need” so much as “desperation in search of power.” Grable, Cruz and Cebert could all turn into something useful for Washington in the bullpen or back end of the rotation, and the Yankees can live with that cost.
Jake Bird is in there too, and the reaction is simple: know when to fold ’em.
Then came Heliot Ramos on Aug. 3, with Henry Lalane and Kaeden Kent headed to San Francisco. That one checks in at a B.
The Yankees got a controllable bat through 2029, and Ramos has done damage in the majors, especially against lefties, where he owns a .847 career OPS. Still, even this move feels like part of a larger puzzle rather than the finished picture.
Garcia was an odd fit; Ramos is a better one, but he still reads like Piece No. 2 of 4. Kent and Lalane were both top-15 names in the Yankees’ system, and the club chose to move Lalane after his one healthy season instead of waiting for his upside to show up in the Bronx.
Put it all together, and the final grade lands at C-. This was one of Cashman’s rougher deadlines as a full-time executive.
The Yankees didn’t strengthen the bullpen, and in fact made it thinner by moving Grable and Cruz to Washington. They didn’t land the catcher they were chasing, and they didn’t land any catcher at all.
Adley Rutschman went to the rival Red Sox instead, reportedly with scary medicals, and Tyler Stephenson of the Reds stayed put despite producing OPS marks of .795 and .947 in June or July. Liam Hicks would have been an imperfect defensive add too, but he’ll be in front of the Yankees soon enough when the Rays come to town, presumably still looking down at them in the standings.
Cashman opened with a few moves that made sense. He just never finished the job. The individual deals may end up helping, but the overall package falls well short of what the Yankees needed.
In Other News...
Yankees Have A Surprise Pitching Option As Return Timelines Drag On
The Yankees have a roster puzzle on their hands, and it is growing more complicated as two key pieces work their way back. Rookie right-hander Elmer Rodriguez was optioned to Triple-A, opening a path for the club to look at Trevor MacGregor, a non-roster pitcher with no major league experience, as a possible stopgap on the staff.
Aaron Judge and Clarke Schmidt are both expected back soon, but neither is ready to be activated yet because each still has rehab work to complete. New York also does not have an open spot on its 40-man roster, so any return will require a corresponding move, which means the Yankees may need some short-term creativity before the more obvious reinforcements are actually available. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Just Reopened A Giancarlo Stanton Decision That Changes Everything
Giancarlo Stantons rehab has taken another turn, and it keeps the Yankees in a familiar holding pattern. Aaron Boone said Stanton has not been ruled out for the season after the slugger dealt with a right-calf strain, and Stanton has already been back to hitting in practice. For a team that has had to juggle injuries and roster fit all year, the mere possibility of getting him back in the mix is enough to keep the conversation alive.
The catch is that there is still no obvious path for Stanton to return right away. The Yankees do not currently have room on the roster, so any move involving him will have to wait on a combination of injuries and other roster decisions. With Stantons contract and age already prompting questions about what comes next, this latest update does more than answer his short-term health status. It reopens a bigger organizational decision the Yankees did not exactly ask to revisit. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Still Face One Aaron Judge Concern Boone Couldnt Dodge
The Yankees left California with a split on the trip after a 4-3 loss to the Padres, and the focus quickly turned back to Aaron Judge and where his return stands. Judge has been out since May 31 with a stress fracture in his right rib, but he has started taking important steps forward again, including batting practice and defensive work as he ramps back up.
Elmer Rodrguez was optioned to Triple-A to create a roster spot, but the club still has not put a date on Judges comeback. He is expected to face live pitching soon, which is the kind of checkpoint that usually clarifies a recovery timeline, yet the Yankees are still waiting for the final piece before they can say when their captain might rejoin the lineup. [Read more 🡒]