The Yankees’ biggest offseason call at second base could come down to a simple tradeoff: keep Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s speed and versatility, or pivot to a different kind of impact bat.
Chisholm is heading toward free agency after a season that has shown exactly why New York values him and why this decision won’t be clean. He came back from the injured list Sept. 22 after a thumb injury, and entering Thursday he was hitting .233 with 19 home runs, 55 RBIs, 41 stolen bases and a .717 OPS in 136 games. MLB’s Statcast database, updated through Sept. 23, had him at a .314 on-base percentage and .403 slugging percentage.
The numbers tell the story. Chisholm still brings rare speed and real defensive flexibility, but his offense has not matched the explosive 31-homer, 31-steal season he posted in 2025.
He will play next season at 29, which gives him a younger profile than most free-agent alternatives. At the same time, the Yankees have to decide how much they want their infield built around athleticism versus another source of left-handed power.
For now, New York has not signaled that it plans to move on from Chisholm, and there is no reported negotiation with a replacement. The Yankees are still locked into their postseason push, so any roster forecast beyond that remains just a projection.
Still, second base is one of the clearest pressure points on the winter board. MLB lists Chisholm among the notable second basemen eligible for free agency after 2026, and that class includes several established veterans. If the Yankees decide the price on Chisholm climbs too high, they will have options.
One of the most interesting comes from a completely different direction.
Bleacher Report’s Zach Buckley projected that two-time All-Star Brandon Lowe will sign a three-year deal with the Yankees after the season. Lowe is coming off a strong year with Pittsburgh, entering Thursday at .262 with 34 home runs, 94 RBIs, 93 runs and an .825 OPS in 147 games, according to MLB Statcast data and the Sept. 23 game log. His latest homer pushed his career total to 191.
Buckley’s case for Lowe is all about power.
“While it can be hard for a true second baseman to get paid, Lowe’s prolific power could make him an exception to the rule,” Buckley wrote.
The projection calls for a three-year contract, with an average annual value around $25 million or higher.
That would be a very different kind of fit for the Yankees. Chisholm has 41 steals this season; Lowe has two. Lowe, though, has delivered 34 homers compared with Chisholm’s 19, and his power track record is much longer, with 39 homers in 2021 and 31 in 2025.
That’s the real roster question New York would have to answer. Losing Chisholm would mean giving up one of the team’s best speed threats. Adding Lowe would mean leaning harder into left-handed home-run production.
Age adds another layer. Chisholm is the younger player. Lowe is 32, so a three-year commitment would come with more aging risk even if the contract itself is shorter than what Chisholm might seek on the open market.
Durability also works in Lowe’s favor. Injuries limited him to 65 games in 2022 and 109 in 2023, but he played 134 games last season and has appeared in 147 this year, just one short of his career high of 149 in 2021.
He has also finished strong, with MLB Statcast showing him at .328 with a .408 on-base percentage and .582 slugging percentage in September through Sept. 22 before he homered again Sept. 23.
The Yankees entered Thursday at 91-67, five games behind Tampa Bay in the AL East and holding the top American League wild-card spot. Their second-base decision belongs to the winter, not October.
Chisholm is still a Yankee, and he wants to remain in the Bronx. Lowe is still a Pirate, and Pittsburgh has its own reasons to want him back after a productive season.
Nothing indicates New York has picked Lowe over Chisholm, or even made Lowe a formal target. But the projection lays out a real alternative if the Yankees decide Chisholm’s next deal doesn’t fit their long-term plan. Lowe would bring less speed, more age and a lot more recent power at the same spot.
That kind of choice could end up shaping one of the Yankees’ most important roster decisions after October.
In Other News...
Yankees Playoff Rotation Rumor Suddenly Feels A Lot More Real
With the AL Wild Card Series approaching, the Yankees are still sorting out how they want to open the round, and a new injury development on the other side has only added to the intrigue. Willson Contreras is reportedly doubtful because of a hand injury that has left him with significant inflammation, and while there is no fracture, his availability remains in question as the series nears.
Max Fried has surfaced as a possible Game 1 choice for New York, a move that would give the Yankees a left-handed look if Contreras is unavailable. It is still only a rumor at this point, not an official decision, but it has made the rotation chatter feel much more real with the postseason about to begin. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Doubleheader Moves Just Raised A Bigger Playoff Question
Brendan Becks latest turn in the Yankees rotation picture did not go as planned, and the club moved quickly after his start in Game 1 of the doubleheader. The rookie was charged with seven runs over five innings in a loss, then was optioned back to the minors with an 0-2 record and a 9.95 ERA in four games, a reminder of how thin the margin can be when a team is trying to patch together innings this late in the season.
In his place, the Yankees promoted Alexander Cornielle, a Triple-A arm who has not yet appeared in the majors, while Fernando Cruz was transferred to the 60-day injured list. It leaves New York juggling both the present and the near future, and it also raises a larger question about how much depth is really left to lean on if the rotation keeps getting tested. [Read more 🡒]
Yankees Could Give Carlos Rodon A Surprising Postseason Role
The Yankees are already weighing a few October wrinkles, and Carlos Rodn might be one of the biggest. With the wild-card series limited to a three-starter format, Aaron Boone acknowledged that one of his best starters could be pushed into a bullpen role to help maximize his impact in a short series, a move that would be more about fit than routine.
Rodn has been paid to start, and the Yankees still view him that way, but the postseason often rewrites the usual script. Using him in relief would keep his arm in play for the wild-card round while also preserving the option of sending him back to the mound if the Yankees advance to a division series matchup with the Rays, a balancing act that could shape how Boone lines up the staff. [Read more 🡒]