The Yankees were hoping Rafael Montero could be a low-cost answer for a bullpen that needed help. Instead, the veteran right-hander never got going, and on Aug. 10 his season with Triple-A Scranton came to an end when he was released by the RailRiders.
It was a rough outcome for a move that made some sense on paper. New York had taken a shot on a reliever with experience, and Montero had shown a second-half uptick with the Detroit Tigers in 2025. He wasn’t being brought in to rediscover his best years from 2019 or 2022, but the hope was that he could still give the club something useful.
That never happened.
Montero’s arrival with the organization was delayed by visa issues, the same problem that had surfaced multiple times during his time with the Astros. Because of that, he didn’t appear in a Triple-A game until April 26.
From there, the results were ugly: 28 games, 27 innings, a 5.67 ERA and a 1.70 WHIP before the release. He also struck out 33, but the damage was piling up too often, with 11 hits and four walks allowed per nine innings.
The bullpen picture around him only made the miss stand out more. The Yankees didn’t add pitching at the trade deadline, and in the process they also moved on from Camilo Doval, Jake Bird and Yovanny Cruz.
Doval and Bird were easier to understand, but Cruz had at least been showing he could help. Either way, the group has been thinned out and taxed.
No one was counting on Montero to change everything. The ask was simpler: soak up some innings in August and September and give the most trusted arms a little relief when the schedule allowed it. That was the appeal of the signing in the first place.
Instead, the release became another example of how few of the Yankees’ marginal moves have landed. Brent Headrick has worked out, but the club has also had misses such as trading TJ Rumfield for Angel Chivilli and making Cade Winquest its first Rule 5 Draft pick in 15 years.
The Yankees can hit on plenty of moves. They just miss often enough, too.
And when those misses pile up, they usually stay that way. The bigger concern now is what’s left for the stretch run: injured pitchers like Carlos Rodón, Clarke Schmidt and Luis Gil, or names most fans haven’t had much reason to know yet.
In Other News...
Yankees Passed On A Catching Upgrade And Cashmans Logic Is Under Fire
The catching market at the 2026 trade deadline did not offer the kind of clean solution contenders usually hope for. Shea Langeliers was hurt, Ryan Jeffers and Hunter Goodman were not realistic possibilities, and that left clubs sorting through a thin group of alternatives while looking for even modest help behind the plate. For the Yankees, the conversation quickly centered on whether they were willing to add a catcher at all, especially with Austin Wells handling the position and the market not exactly overflowing with answers.
Brian Cashmans deadline approach came under the microscope because of what he tends to value most: control beyond the current season. The Yankees passed on the kind of rental move that could have addressed a clear need without a massive long-term commitment, and that preference has become part of the larger critique of how the front office operates in July. In a market that did not present many perfect fits, the choice not to act on a catcher at all left plenty of people wondering whether the safer strategy also cost them a chance to get better. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Judge Rehab Gives Yankees Hope With One Big Unanswered Problem
Aaron Judge has started moving again, with upper-body training and light running now part of his rehab from the stress fracture in his right rib. It is an encouraging step for the Yankees after a stretch in which their lineup has had to do without its captain, and it comes with Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman both stressing that the ramp-up has to be gradual so Judge is truly ready when he comes back.
For now, though, the biggest question remains when that return might actually happen, and the club is offering no timetable yet. Judge is still working back from the discomfort tied to the injury, which leaves the Yankees waiting for a clearer runway even as other pitchers across the rehab circuit, including Garrett Crochet and Spencer Arrighetti, continue moving through their own recovery paths. [Read more 🡒]
Will Warren Opened Up About The Yankees Trade Rumor He Hated
Will Warren has spent enough time around trade chatter to know how quickly a rumor can take on a life of its own, and this one hit close to home. The Yankees right-hander was at the center of a false report tying him to San Diego in a proposed deal, another reminder of how often young pitchers can find themselves in the middle of speculation even when they are still trying to carve out a role in New York.
Warren said he was relieved the move never materialized and made clear he would rather keep building with the Yankees than keep wondering where he might land next. Brian Cashman later shut down the rumor, but the episode still underscored something Warren has dealt with before: being a name that pops up whenever teams start circling pitching depth, and having to keep his focus on staying put. [Read more 🡒]