The Yankees are running out of room for caution, but Aaron Judge’s return still looks like a decision the club is keeping behind closed doors.
There’s a date on the calendar for a new round of images on Judge’s right first rib, and the Yankees aren’t saying when it is. The organization knows it.
Judge knows it. Everyone else is left guessing while the team’s offense keeps sinking.
That silence landed harder Wednesday night at Tropicana Field, where New York was blanked 3-0 by Tampa Bay. Gerrit Cole took the loss after giving up three runs in six and a third innings, Shane McClanahan got the win, and Bryan Baker finished it off.
The shutout wasn’t just another loss. It matched a franchise mark: 20 straight games without scoring more than five runs.
The Yankees are now 50-42 and five games back of the Rays in the AL East, per MLB standings. For a team that was rolling when Judge got hurt, the drop-off has been brutal.
Judge last played May 31 and went on the injured list June 4 with a stress fracture of the first rib on his right side. At the time, the club said he would be reimaged in four to six weeks to check healing and decide the next step.
New York was 36-23 when he went down. Since then, the Yankees have gone 14-17. Over their last 20 games, they’re 5-15.
The offense hasn’t just cooled off. It has disappeared.
Before the injury, the Yankees were averaging 5.32 runs per game. Since a June 20 loss to Cincinnati, that number has fallen to 2.88.
Across that 16-game stretch, they rank last in the majors in batting average, on-base percentage, slugging, runs, strikeouts and weighted runs created plus. They’ve faced only one team with a winning record in those 16 games and gone 4-12.
The broader picture isn’t any prettier. Since June 1, the Yankees rank last in MLB in batting average at .217, on-base percentage at .279 and strikeout rate at 27 percent, and they’re 26th in runs per game at 3.97, per ESPN.
No regular has been able to carry the lineup. None of them has been above average at the plate for the last two weeks.
The club’s silence around Judge has become part of the story. On a podcast during the Rays series, Jon Heyman said the Yankees are holding information they haven’t shared publicly.
“I’ve heard they do have a date in mind, which can change,” Heyman said.
He also said the team hasn’t even been willing to say when the scan is happening.
“They won’t even say when he’s getting the reimaging,” Heyman said.
When Joel Sherman asked whether the Yankees had peaked in mid-June and were now in trouble, Heyman didn’t go that far. He did leave one big warning attached to everything else.
“It’s possible they peaked. I don’t think they’re in trouble, with one caveat,” Heyman said.
That caveat was Judge not coming back at all. Nothing currently points that way.
The timeline still matters, though. Six weeks from Judge’s June 4 IL placement lands on Thursday, July 16, which lines up with the outer edge of the window the Yankees described.
Even if a scan comes back clean, that doesn’t mean Judge is suddenly in the lineup. He’d still need to get back to baseball activity, then hit, then face live pitching, then play.
For a hitter who hasn’t swung in six weeks, two weeks would be an aggressive ramp.
August feels more realistic. Maybe even later. ESPN’s Buster Olney said a mid-August or early September return wouldn’t surprise him.
When Judge was injured, he was hitting .248 with 17 home runs and 38 RBIs in 59 games. Not his usual standard, but enough to keep the Yankees in first place.
There’s also a recent cautionary tale in the Bronx. Judge missed 42 games in 2023 with a toe injury.
The Yankees were 35-25 when he went out and 19-23 without him. He came back in August, hit .196 in 28 games that month, and the Yankees lost 18 of them.
The comeback didn’t stop the slide.
That history is the argument for patience, and the front office seems to be leaning that way. Not naming a date looks less like a team ready to roll the dice and more like one trying to avoid backing itself into a corner.
But the pressure is real. Every shutout makes the wait feel more expensive.
Every game the Rays pull farther ahead sharpens the urgency. A team five games out in July doesn’t have the same luxury as a club sitting on top of the division.
Aaron Boone doesn’t have a simple answer waiting in the dugout. Ben Rice and Cody Bellinger were supposed to help cover the gap, and both have gone cold.
The rotation and bullpen have mostly done their jobs. The lineup hasn’t.
The Yankees finish this series against Tampa Bay on Thursday afternoon, then head to Washington for their final set before the All-Star break. After that comes the trade deadline on July 31.
Who the Yankees buy, and how aggressively they buy, depends on one question they still aren’t answering: when is Aaron Judge coming back?
In Other News...
Yankees Just Got Linked To A Trade Fans Will Hate Or Love
A speculative trade idea from Bleacher Report has the Yankees in an eye-catching spot, with the discussion centered on whether a utility infielder could be worth parting with a pair of pitching prospects. The appeal on New Yorks side is easy to see: Carlos Lagrange brings big arm strength and starter upside, while Eric Reyzelman has also drawn enough attention to be included in the kind of package that gets people talking.
Lagrange, in particular, has the sort of profile that makes these proposals divisive. The 23-year-old right-hander can reach 100 mph, pairs that heater with an above-average slider, and was effective in Triple-A before a shoulder injury complicated his season. On the other side of the idea sits Zack Gelof, a versatile infielder with years of team control and an .823 OPS, which is exactly why this kind of rumor can split a fan base right down the middle. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Boone Finally Addressed The Anthony Volpe Confusion
The Yankees shortstop conversation has been noisy enough that it started to feel bigger than the actual depth chart, with Jose Caballeros name entering the debate and Anthony Volpe suddenly having to answer for a position he has long owned. Aaron Boone stepped in to calm some of that down, making clear that Volpe remains the clubs shortstop and treating him like the incumbent rather than a player fighting to keep a job.
Boones comments also helped separate the real baseball question from the rumor mill surrounding Volpes role. The Yankees have supported him as the starter, and while the chatter around a possible move has lingered, the team has not asked him to play elsewhere, leaving the focus where it belongs: on how the Yankees sort out the infield behind the guy they still view as their shortstop. [Read more 🡒]
A Forgotten Yankees Prospect From 2016 Is Back For The Worst Reason
A former Yankees pitching prospect from the 2016 system has resurfaced in an unwelcome way, this time in the Rockies Triple-A orbit. At 34, he is still hanging around professional baseball after a career that never quite matched the early buzz, one that took him out of the Yankees pipeline and eventually led to a major league debut with Oakland.
What makes the latest turn notable is less the uniform than the reason for it. The right-handers path has already included the usual grind of a fluctuating career, but now he is back in the news for a suspension tied to performance-enhancing drugs, a reminder that even players long removed from the spotlight can still leave one more awkward footnote behind. [Read more 🡒]